Indiana Disgraces America (Homophobia)
Indiana Disgraces America (Homophobia)
THIS ARTICLE WAS WRITTEN ON Monday, April 23, 2007
Yet again, the US has embarrassed itself -- this time, in response to an article written by a sophomore at Woodlan Junior-Senior High School, in one of the most morally backward parts of the country (northeastern Indiana).
The sophomore, Megan Chase, wrote an article stressing the virtues of tolerance and respect for the differences between gay students and heterosexual students. As a direct result, the school newspaper adviser, Amy Sorrell, now stands to lose her job.
I stress what I have stressed in previous messages pertaining to the homophobia that is rife throughout the US. Quite bluntly, the US is morally backwards, obtuse, and childish in its refusal to acknowledge the differences between gay people and heterosexual people. Only in America, in the year 2007, could a school teacher face losing her job as the result of permitting the article in question to be printed.
The "controversial" material in question? Read the following, quoted directly from Chase's article:
"I can only imagine how hard it would be to come out as homosexual in today's society," she wrote. "I think it is so wrong to look down on those people, or to make fun of them, just because they have a different sexuality than you. There is nothing wrong with them or their brain; they're just different than you."
Yes -- this statement, published in the school newspaper, led the school district to recommend the sacking of Amy Sorrell, who has been placed on administrative leave following the publication of this "controversial" statement.
I know that this is difficult to believe. As the entire world moves forward and embraces the humanity of gay and lesbian people, America disgraces herself in public. Sorrell now faces the loss of her job -- merely because she permitted the school newspaper to include an article stressing the need for tolerance of people who are different from the majority of their peers.
There is one glaring irony to this display of moral infantilism. Because Sorrell works for a public school, which is a political subdivision of the State of Indiana, she can bring suit against the school district for violation of her First Amendment rights -- and should Sorrel bring suit, she stands an excellent chance of winning, given the clear and unambiguous line of decisional law handed down by the US Supreme Court and the US Courts of Appeals with respect to cases of this nature.
What is shocking, however, is the fact that the advocacy of tolerance of human differences could lead to the possibility of a school district firing a teacher. What is shocking is the fact that tolerance is seen as being "controversial" and that writing about the difficulties faced by gay and lesbian students as they come out to their peers could become the fodder for a group of bloody-minded, pious, mealy-mouthed hicks.
The following statement, made by the assistant superintendent of secondary education and technology, Andy Melin, is illustrative of the mentality of so many Americans, who appear to be incapable of independent thought (that is to say, incapable of dealing with any material that they have not heard uttered from church pulpits):
"The way we view it is the broad topic of homosexuality is a sensitive enough issue in our society that the principal deserves to know that it's something the newspaper is going to write about."
Unbelievable! Unbelievable, but true. A bona fide insight into the mindsets of so many self-professed "Christians" in America today.
Fortunately, a gay advocacy group named Parents, Families, and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (P-FLAG) has taken up this issue and is firmly on the side of Sorrell and Chase. Should the school district actually be so stupid as to fire Sorrell in the face of First Amendment jurisprudence that bears directly on this, and similar, situations, the school district will almost certainly lose, and lose big time. Even the most conservative Courts of Appeals have found, consistently, for teachers and students in the face of dilemmas such as that in which Sorrell is now mired.
I am a US citizen. There was a time that this made me proud.
Now I am ashamed.
"Small man, Big world, Lost beyond the pale..."
Pet Shop Boys -- Red Letter Day
Gay Rights in America
- Gay Rights in America
This essay describes the manner in which gay sex between men is singled out for harsher treatment by many heterosexual men than is gay sex between women. This essay also discusses US Supreme Court decisions and the impact of gay marriage on religion.
Gay Marriage in America (The Gathering Storm)
- Gay Marriage in America (The Gathering Storm)
This essay discusses the current status of gay marriage in America, and reveals the desperation underlying the "National Organization for Marriage" and the $1.5 million advertisement ("The Gathering Storm") (which is actually funny!)...
The Federal Courts, Gay Rights, and the People
- The Federal Courts, Gay Rights, and the People
This essay discusses the role of the federal judiciary in our system of government, and explains the concept of judicial review...
Justice at Last -- Gay Equality in America
- Justice at Last -- Gay Equality in America
Gay Equality, the Right to Privacy, and Substantive Due Process: this essay discusses the US Supreme Court decisions that created and expanded the right to privacy, and discusses the cases of Bowers v. Hardwick (1986) and Lawrence v. Texas (2003)...
Homophobia -- Fear and Loathing in Florida
- Homophobia -- Fear and Loathing in Florida
This essay discusses the behavior of school officials at Ponce de Leon High School, and the manner in which the school principal trampled the First and Fourteenth Amendment rights of gay and gay-supportive students at this school...
The Supreme Court, Gay Rights, and Lawrence v. Texas (2003)
- The Supreme Court, Gay Rights, and Lawrence v. Texas
This essay discusses the US Supreme Court and the damage it did to gay Americans in handing down Bowers v. Hardwick (1986), as well as the manner in which this Court overruled Bowers and apologized to gay Americans in Lawrence v. Texas (2003)...
Gay Americans and the US Supreme Court
- Gay Americans and the US Supreme Court
This essay discusses the homophobia that informed the US Supreme Court decision Bowers v. Hardwick (1986), and how gay Americans turned to state supreme courts to strike down sodomy laws until the US Supreme Court handed down Lawrence v. Texas (2003)
Religion, Gay Americans, and the Law
- Religion, Gay Americans, and the Law
This essay discusses the impact of high court decisions upholding laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation on religious organizations that offer public services (and are thus bound by anti-discrimination statutes)...
Gay Equality, Homophobia, and Another Country
- Gay Equality, Homophobia, and Another Country
This essay discusses and compares social and legal attitudes towards homosexuality in the US and the UK, emphasizing the greater degree of acceptance of gay persons in the UK...
Loving the Sinner but Hating the Sin (But What is the Sin?)
- Loving the Sinner but Hating the Sin (But What is the Sin?)
This essay debunks the illusion that is is possible for a person to love gay people but not the actual expression of their sexual orientation; the one is inextricably intertwined with the other, just as a person's race is an indelible part of him...
I Feel, Therefore I Hate (Internalized Homophobia)
- I Feel Therefore I Hate
This essay discusses the evidence that homophobic men are often struggling with their own sexual orientation, and are often closeted homosexuals...
Mormons Meddle and Destroy Marriage
- Mormons Meddle and Destroy Marriage
This article discusses the manner in which members of the LDS participated in the campaign to pass Proposition 8 in California, thereby nullifying the effect of the California Supreme Court decision legalizing gay marriage in that state...
What a Fool Believes
- What a Fool Believes
This article discusses the belief of South African ex-President Thabo Mbeki that HIV does not causeuAIDS, and the horrific consequences to that nation's infected citizens...
Initial Victory in California (Discussion of the Court's Reasoning)
- Initial Victory in California
This essay was written BEFORE Proposition 8 was enacted; it discusses the legal analysis invoked by the California Supreme Court majority in the historic gay marriage case in that state (in re Marriage Cases, S147999 (2008))
California Gay Marriage Case
- California Gay Marriage Case
This essay was written BEFORE Proposition 8 was enacted; it discusses in greater detail the legal analysis invoked by the California Supreme Court majority in the historic gay marriage case (in re Marriage Cases, S147999 (2008))
Gay Marriage Gains Ground in America
- Gay Marriage Gains Ground in America
This essay discusses recent judicial and legislative victories in the fight for marriage equality, including recent developments that have changed the terms of the debate (including legislation in New England, passed without judicial prompting)...