ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Politics and Social Issues»
  • Social Issues

7 Arguments to RACIAL PROFILING: Is it a Bad Idea?

Updated on July 13, 2009

Top 7 Arguments Against Racial Profiling

Racial Profiling Doesn't Work

  • black suspects were no more likely to actually have drugs or illegal weapons in their cars than white suspects.
  • According to the Public Health Service, approximately 70% of drug users are white, 15% are black, and 8% are Latino. But the Department of Justice reports that among those imprisoned on drug charges, 26% are white, 45% are black, and 21% are Latino.

Racial Profiling Distracts Law Enforcement Agencies From More Useful Approaches

  • Focus on suspicious behavior leads to more arrests than focus on race.
  • The increase in arrests on suspicious behavior alone is 24%.

Racial Profiling Prevents Police From Serving The Entire Community

  • The message is sent to the community that whites can be more trusted and Blacks and Latinos are seen as criminals.
  • Having a poor raporte' with the community makes preventing crime almost impossible.

Racial profiling prevents communities from working with law enforcement.

  • This connects with the prior argument.
  • The community won't come to you and report crime if they know you already have a biased and narrow-minded focus on certain people.
  • Racial profiling sabotages community policing efforts, and offers nothing useful in return.

Racial Profiling is against the 14th Amendment

  • It is clearly stated in our Constitution that no state may "deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."
  • By searching Latinos ad Blacks more often, Whites less often, there are unequal protection of the community.

Racial Profiling will likely escalate into riots and racially-motivated violence

  • Refer to Rodney King case.
  • By having a lower standard of evidence to take police action against Latinos and Blacks, police brutality and over-exertion of power is greatly heightened.
  • Reports of suspicious deaths involving unarmed Latino and black suspects trickle out of our nation's major cities on a regular basis.

Racial Profiling is Morally Wrong

  • Racial profiling is Jim Crow applied as a law enforcement policy.
  • It creates a world where Blacks and Latinos are remain in as segregated and second-class citizens.

 Bigotry has been a side effect of every long-term national struggle the United States has been involved in. The War on Terror is no exception.


Looks Like The Enemy

Of the 19 hijackers who directly instigated the September 11th attacks, 15 hailed from Saudi Arabia, three from the United Arab Emirates, and one from Lebanon.

Our reaction? Build simple prejudices. WE built into our laws additional airline security for Arabs boarding airlines...the additional scrutiny really made us more secure! (sarcasm aside)

A Dangerous and Unconstitutional Approach

As we racially profiled Middle Easterners, it decreased attention to other passengers. That's great news for non-Arabian terrorists!

A Pathway to Abuse

The popular anti-Arabian sentiment and racially profiling against them has spread like wildfire across America. It has affected those who oppose the Iraqi War from coming into our country and has impacted a wide range of decisions.

Even those Arabians trying out for a football team may find themselves discriminated against!


Tell Me....

Have You Been a Victim of Racial Profiling?

See results

Racial Profiling in a Store


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • profile image

      Sanxuary 12 months ago

      I have no idea how anyone could racially profile anyone these days. I can not tell one aisian from another, one spanish person from another, or anyone of color from another. Its an absurd tatic in todays World where you need 50 different languages a day just to say hi to everyone. If you commit a crime it does not matter who you are. The big mistake and constant is when you approve discrimination of someone else the same law can apply to you later and it usually does. This is the dumbest point constantly made but ignored by racist. We fought a World war and we have Natzi's in America. They exist because everyones rights are protected. With out those rights a lot of old veterans would have taken care of that problem a long time ago. There is no law that applies to only one group and if it does it should not exist. I wonder what Hitler would have done if he could check DNA? Maybe thses Natzi groups should check their membership. Brad got kicked out because his DNA test was not good. It doesnt take much to realize how stupid and insane it is to be a racist.

    • thinkbefore profile image

      thinkbefore 7 years ago

      Thanks for this quick summary with arguments against racial profiling. I agree, but as kschag pointed out, it is kind of unclear how you define racial profiling exactly. I try to point out certain ambiguities in the definition in a hub I've just written.

    • kschang profile image

      kschang 7 years ago from San Francisco, CA, USA

      Interesting list of 7 reasons, some of which are taken from the Amnesty International website almost verbatim.

      Also fails to define racial profiling, and analyze WHY it is bad.

      Sorry, thumbs down.

    • SOBF profile image

      SOBF 8 years ago from New York, NY

      Excellent hub! Nothing speaks the truth louder than real life.

    • fen lander profile image

      fen lander 8 years ago from Whitstable

      That brought tears into my eyes- thank god they didn't all turn a deaf ear and a blind eye. I live in England where I hope this kind of thing would never happen- we get our share of racially-motivated murders though, so I dare say it does. An experiment of similar kind would be a good idea perhaps? I know a bloke with a camera...

    • profile image

      Hack Retis 8 years ago

      The video is atrocious, and I think we can all agree the only profile we need to judge you on is your MySpace one.

    • LondonGirl profile image

      LondonGirl 8 years ago from London

      I think a judicious use of racial profiling, inter alia, can be useful.

    • AsherKade profile image

      AsherKade 8 years ago from Texas

      well said!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • someonewhoknows profile image

      someonewhoknows 8 years ago from south and west of canada,north of ohio

      I can't agree more,however the way I see it much of what has happened ,even the 911,and many other race related war's as well as political and religious profiling ,such as the murdering of the brabch davidians in waco texas ,and the internment of the japanese during world war two,and the hazing of "legal" immigrants during the massive immigration in the latter half of the twenith century,as well as the American Indians and last but not least black slaves since long before the founding of The united states of America.Things only change when the children of those involved are taught to respect each other as human beings instead of being taught to pre-judge someone based on race or creed .Fear begets fear and love begets love.