ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel

Who is Mother Goose?

Updated on August 23, 2017

The Origins of Old Mother Goose in Witchcraft

Mother Goose is best known as an old lady, usually depicted reading to children or riding a flying goose. She is synonymous with nursery rhymes, thanks to the many treasuries and nursery books that her name became famous for.

But take a closer look at the characteristics of Mother Goose, and you will find many similarities with witches. In fact, many early illustrations of Mother Goose show her wearing a pointed witch's hat and sometimes flying on a broomstick rather than a goose!

Read on to discover just where the true origins of Mother Goose really lie...

Photo credit: Mother Goose book cover. Image in the public domain

The Real Mother Goose!

Mother Goose: The Old Nursery Rhymes - Illustrated by Arthur Rackham

Photo Credit: Image in the Public Domain

Just as the early fairytales have far darker meanings and content than their modern counterparts (think Brothers Grimm), so too does Mother Goose find hero origins in darker places than the mere imaginations of the storytellers of old.

The origins of Mother Goose nursery rhymes and stories can be traced back as early as the 1500-1600's. During this time, many women were being accused of witchcraft as part of the infamous witch hunts in Europe and America. If we examine Mother Goose carefully, we can see that she shares many characteristics with the perception of witches during this era.

Indeed, many illustrations of Mother Goose have in the past depicted her as a witch, complete with pointed hat!

Did you think Mother Goose was a Witch?

Have you ever associated Mother Goose with a witch or is this news to you?

See results

Old Mother Goose: Which is Witch?

Old Mother Goose Display in the Museum of Witchcraft, Boscastle, Cornwall, UK

Photo Credit: Copyright of Author

Old Mother Goose was more often than not portrayed as a witch, depicted as a crone wearing a pointed hat and often riding a broomstick rather than a goose. The riding of geese can be found in magical folklore around the world. Mother Goose is also often depicted as a goose rather than an old woman - this once again has connotations with witches and shape-shifting.

The Museum of Witchcraft in Boscastle, Cornwall, England has a fascinating display of vintage witch paraphernalia, which includes Old Mother Goose d├ęcor, vases and dolls as pictured above.

Old Mother Goose Rhymes

Connections with Witches

"Old Mother Goose

When she wanted to wander

Would fly through the air

On a very fine gander.

Mother Goose had a house;

It stood in the wood

Where an owl at the door

As sentinel stood."

Book cover from 1909

Photo Credit: Image in the public domain

Cackle, cackle, Mother Goose,

Have you any feathers loose?

Comparing Mother Goose and Witches

Here are the main similarities and influences behind Mother Goose's link to witches.

  1. Mother Goose is shown as an old lady. Although women of all ages were tried as witches, the popular conception of the era was of an old crone, with no man around to defend her against witchcraft accusations
  2. Witches were thought to be able to fly. In the case of Mother Goose, her broomstick has been replaced by a goose, although some pictures do depict her with the broom. Riding geese also has origins in worldwide folklore as well.
  3. Witches had "familiars". Nowadays we know that these are merely animal spirit helpers, but in the time of the witch hunts, they were said to be evil spirits who aided the witch and took the form of an animal. Common forms were the cat, owl, bat, wolf, raven, frog, pig, goose, goat, crow and mouse. Many of these animals featured in nursery rhymes.
  4. Few verses have actually been written about Mother Goose, but those that have reveal further connections with witches. The quote in the previous section is from "Mother Goose and her Son Jack". As well as noting that Mother Goose rides a goose, it also mentions that she lives in a wood (synonymous with the idea of the solitary witch) and has an owl for a sentinel (which could be construed as her "familiar").
  5. The verses near the end of this rhyme mention the actual act of witchcraft:

    "Then old Mother Goose, that instant came in,

    And turned her son Jack, into famed Harlequin.

    She then with her wand, touched the lady so fine,

    And turned her at once, into sweet Columbine."

  6. Witches are often described as "cackling" when they laugh. Geese cackle too, but this could be another possible reference in the other well-known Mother Goose rhyme "Cackle, cackle, Mother Goose."

Mother Goose and the Secret History of the Nursery Rhyme

Further links between Mother Goose, her rhymes and the times of the witch trials may be found buried into the actual rhymes themselves. Although many secret meanings of nursery rhymes are nowadays thought to be pure folklore (such as Ring a Ring o' Roses referring to the plague), there are still those who believe that many of the old rhymes held hidden meanings about the events and cultures of the time.

One consideration is that the reason so many nursery rhymes contain the likes of cats, owls, mice, frogs and other typical "witch familiars" is that they were written in the time of the witch trials (16th and 17th century), when so many people were blaming witches for unnatural weather and illnesses. Children would have grown up with stories of witches and witchcraft as well as these nursery rhymes that may well have been influenced by the times.

Photo Credit: Jupiter Images

Lots more information on the Secret History of the Nursery Rhyme and their hidden meanings can be found in the Origins of Mother Goose section of the Rhymes.org.uk website,

Witch, Wicce, Mother Goose

The origins of Mother Goose begin around the time of the terrible witch hunts of Europe and America during the 1400's to the 1700's. This book examines the witch stereotype and why the witch hunts arose in the first place, providing an in-depth study to this dark time in the history of witchcraft.

Witch, Wicce, Mother Goose: The Rise and Fall of the Witch Hunts in Europe and North America
Witch, Wicce, Mother Goose: The Rise and Fall of the Witch Hunts in Europe and North America

Amazon says:

"This is an exciting new illustrated examination of witch-hunt panics and persecutions in colonial America and Europe.

* Examines the witch stereotype and the growth of torture to elicit confessions and challenges and enhances existing interpretations of the witch-hunt phenomenon.

* Explains the origins of the witch-hunts in reaction to the growing threats to Christendom 400 years earlier.

* Written for the general reader, jargon-free and accessible with thirty black and white illustrations, this book offers a fresh approach with new evidence."

 

Who is Mother Goose: Witch or Old Lady? - Witch Is She?

Do you think Mother Goose has origins in the witches of the past, or do you think that she is merely a storytelling old crone who has fairytale elements, created by storytellers of the time?

Is Mother Goose...

Mother Goose and Witches Today

Mother Goose is a significant symbol to witches today. She represents the strength and endurance of witches and the fact that, despite the years of Christian repression and demonisation, pagan practices have survived to this day.

For at the height of the suppression of witches, there she was all along - a blatant image of the witch, for all the children of the land to see and read stories from. Even though witches were being burned for their supposed crimes, their traditions were being passed on, from their classic role as storytellers, to their spells and prophecies, found in the very pages of nursery rhyme books!

Here are two such rhymes that clearly base themselves on old wives' lore and the hedge spells of the old wise women:

"This knot I knit,

To know the thing, I know not yet,

That I may see,

The man that shall my husband be,

How he goes, and what he wears,

And what he does, all days and years."

"One-ery, two-ery,

Ziccary zan; Hollow bone, crack a bone,

Ninery ten:

Spitery spot,

It must be done;

Twiddleum twaddleum

Twenty ONE. 1"

Read more research and observations on Mother Goose as witch and wise woman in this piece from the Lady of the Earth website, "Aphrodite, Hecate, Witch- Mother Goose!?"

Old Mother Goose Paraphernalia

Find old Mother Goose collectibles, plates, dolls and imagery at markets, auctions and other sources of old paraphernalia. Use them to create a Mother Goose display in your home or place a Mother Goose doll or ornament on your altar or ancestor area, to celebrate this enduring symbol of witches and our survival.

I hope you enjoyed this lens Who is Mother Goose? and found it useful. Please leave your thoughts here in the Guestbook before you go! Thank you,

Did you Enjoy Meeting Mother Goose? - Please Leave your Comments and Feedback here!

    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • Jeri Studebaker profile image

      Jeri Studebaker 2 years ago

      Mother Goose was a Germanic goddess (Holda) who was associated with children, babies and childbirth. I think she was disguised by her worshipers as Mother Goose in order to keep her safe during the Witch Burnings. But the Church tried to convince people she was a witch in order to vilify her. So artists depict her both ways: as an innocent old grandmotherly figure, and/or as a sinister looking witch. For more on this, see my FB page: https://www.facebook.com/jeri.studebaker

    • Missmerfaery444 profile image
      Author

      Missmerfaery444 3 years ago

      @Lionrhod: Thank you!

    • Lionrhod profile image

      Lionrhod 3 years ago from Orlando, FL

      Fantastic lens. Might want to reset your counter though, :) I love Mother Goose. Definitely a witch.

    • Chocolatealchemy profile image

      Chocolatealchemy 5 years ago from London, United Kingdom

      You've created a great Lens on Mother Goose - I loved the witch analogy and rhymes!

    • Aquavel profile image

      Aquavel 5 years ago

      Fun lens! I found your lens on Google because I'm currently researching the origins of Mother Goose for a Nursery Rhyme Quiz I'm currently writing for Squidoo! I didn't even think of the witch angle, other than realizing that Elizabeth Foster Goose was born in Boston when all the witch trials were taking place. I think the people who illustrated her collection of nursery rhymes over time made her into a witch-like character. It's far more fun than an illustration of a singing grandmother.

    • greenspirit profile image

      poppy mercer 5 years ago from London

      Great lens.I love the illustrations. Such an example of the old oppression of the wise woman, and her survival through disguise.

    • TonyPayne profile image

      Tony Payne 6 years ago from Southampton, UK

      Excellent lens, I really didn't know much about the origins of Mother Goose, she is just a character from Nursery Rhymes and Pantomimes. This was very interesting, blessed.

    • GreenfireWiseWo profile image

      GreenfireWiseWo 6 years ago

      Yes it was nice to meet her again.

    • Philippians468 profile image

      Philippians468 6 years ago

      thank you for this interesting lens! cheers

    • lemonsqueezy lm profile image

      lemonsqueezy lm 6 years ago

      It never occurred to me that she might have been a witch. I never saw it. Very interesting!

    • TapIn2U profile image

      TapIn2U 6 years ago

      Wow! Is there really mother goose? I thought it was only i fairy tales. This lens really intrigued me.

    • WildFacesGallery profile image

      Mona 6 years ago from Iowa

      Wow you just blew my mind. Can't say I ever noticed a connection. Really fascinating and blessed.

    • profile image

      anonymous 6 years ago

      Yes! Thank you for sharing this information. I knew much of it but I'm not sure how many do - and I didn't know about Mother Goose Day! I'll have to be sure and create her a card too :D