ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Sports and Recreation»
  • Team Sports»
  • Baseball

MLB Awards and Steroids in Pro Baseball

Updated on December 29, 2015

MVP Award

2011 NL MVP Ryan Braun holding the award with former Milwaukee Brewer outfielder Robin Yount
2011 NL MVP Ryan Braun holding the award with former Milwaukee Brewer outfielder Robin Yount | Source

Cheating in Sport

If a player tests positive for PED's are they cheating?

See results

Using Steroids

I have to admit I was a little bit disappointed when the 2011 National League Most Valuable Player award was won by Milwaukee Brewers outfielder Ryan Braun. Braun had a great 2011 year, being a main reason why the Brewers won the NL Central division, but I just felt he didn’t have the same statistical numbers as another National League player did.

Looking at the year, from a purely statistical point of view, I thought Los Angeles Dodger outfielder Matt Kemp had a better year. Kemp flirted with the Triple Crown for most of the year and finished the season leading the NL in both home runs and runs batted in (RBI’s). He finished third in batting average behind Jose Reyes and Ryan Braun. His third place showing in batting average was .13 behind Reyes and .08 behind Braun. In the other two categories Braun finished tied for sixth in home runs with six less than Kemp and fourth in RBI’s knocking in fifteen less than Kemp.

Where the MVP voting has always gotten controversial is whether the MVP has to come from a winning team or not. Sure putting up monster numbers has to be a great feeling but making it to the postseason has got to feel even better. The Brewers benefited from Braun’s great year on their way to capturing the division crown while Kemp’s Dodgers struggled mightily in the NL West and floundered to a third place finish.

I have always disagreed with the mindset that the MVP, or the CY Young award which is given to the league’s best pitcher, has to go to a player from a winning ball club. Both of these awards are intended to reward an individual player for their accomplishments and achievements from the season. Since these are individual awards the rest of the players should be excluded from the formula. I don’t believe it is fair to punish an offensive player for the team having a poor record because the team’s pitching staff is horrible and can’t keep the ball from flying over the fence.

Every year players are omitted from individual awards, especially when the participants for the All-Star game are announced. Fans, annalists, etc. all dissect who made it and who didn’t so my reasons above can easily be categorized with all of the other opinions on an award recipient. It does get a little bit dicey when some controversy erupts regarding an award winner; something like steroid use maybe?

Steroids in Baseball

Back in December of 2011 Braun tested positive for elevated levels of synthetic testosterone. Testosterone is a normal hormone in men and sometimes it becomes elevated for a few different reasons. The key here is that the tested urine samples detected synthetic testosterone. Synthetic testosterone will come from some kind of medication or drug and not from our own body’s natural fluctuation of the hormone.

Of course Braun has denied knowingly taking any kind of performance enhancing drug (PED) and has filed an appeal of the ruling. He has issued statements that prescriptions he had been taking were the culprit in the positive tests.

If Braun’s appeal is unsuccessful he is slated to be suspended for the first fifty games in 2012 which is almost one third of the season.

I’m certainly not going to pass judgment on Braun and I really hope the tests are not accurate. Ryan Braun is a young star in the league and really seems like a nice guy.

Steroid Use in Sports

Questions have come up if he should be allowed to keep his MVP award which he just accepted over the weekend. I think that he should because Major League Baseball (MLB) will never completely know how many players were juicing during the steroid era. The late Ken Caminiti won the 1996 NL MVP but later admitted to using steroids during that season.

If Braun’s suspension is upheld, and the critics keep pushing for MLB to strip him of his MVP award, does that mean that the league should also take away a deceased man’s award? Personally, I don’t see it happening.


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • adjkp25 profile image

      David 5 years ago from Northern California

      pmanpartyman - What still leaves a bad taste in my mouth on the Braun acquittal is that he wasn't found not guilty. The positive test was thrown out because the handler didn't get it to FedEx fast enough.

    • pmanpartyman profile image

      Matt Pardy 5 years ago from Rhode Island

      I agree with you, Kemp definitely got robbed. They like to award the MVP to a player who brought their team to the playoffs and without him, wouldn't have the same success. I am relieved though that a superstar and role model of the game, Braun, wasn't found guilty of the PED's. The game needs icons like that.

    • adjkp25 profile image

      David 5 years ago from Northern California

      The problem with taking his away is what to do with the other awards given to guys who took PED's. I don't think MLB wants to go there.

    • adjkp25 profile image

      David 5 years ago from Northern California

      I have been a fan of McGwire since 1987 but he got some bad advice during those hearings. He has never been a man that enjoys the spotlight.

      Big Cardinal fan too, hopefully the team can move on from Pujols and Wainwright can return to form quickly.

    • michiganman567 profile image

      michiganman567 5 years ago from Michigan

      I would take his MVP away. Kemp had a deserving year. I think that they can take a few away from Arod and Bonds too.

    • marriedwithdebt profile image

      marriedwithdebt 5 years ago from Illinois

      Good questions. If it can be proven that he took the PEDs during the season, he should at least be pressured to give up the award.

      I'm a huge Cardinals fan but I don't think McGwire should ever get in the Hall because of his shameful display at the Congressional hearings.

      If he gets to keep it, put Pete Rose in the Hall.