If Heaven exist, they go. If Heaven doesn't exist, they won't know the difference (when they die). Are Religious fundamentalists in a win-win situation?
Aren't you assuming there are no more gods with different rules? If they are worshiping the wrong one they lose anyway! So no, they are not in a win-win situation
When I talk about god in my question, it's in a broad sense. It would seem that the 'god' side wins if it was 50/50. Obviously, there are more than one 'god'. But the question works, being that "fundamentalists" can't see outside of their 'god'.
It is called, "Pascal's Wager".
Your post is an old old question, and has been argued for centuries now,.
For me, the question is new. If it isn't for you, then move along.
It isn't new for anyone who has studied any bit of Theology or Philosophy.
Why don't you google pascals Wager and read up on it.
This has been a debate of great interest for many.
Here it is for you...
There is nothing new under the sun as to this topic, that can be brought out here.
I'm sure that every thought that I have (in regards to religion) has been established. With that said, I don't Google my thoughts prior to posting. I do appreciate you informing me on the topic so that I have a further reference to look into (in regarding the topic).
Most religious and non-religious folks are in a bubble of their own and so then none win, because we are too busy thinking about ourselve's to know anything about it. Plus if there is nothing to observe, there is nothing to measure it against the facts that are already apparent. If I have never seen heaven or hell, I can't say that they can be classified or filed under any sensible category. statistics only realy apply to reality, heaven and hell are no reality we can percieve subjectively or objectively. We simply don't know that they exist.
This is a backward version of PASCAL'S WAGER one of the weakest arguments for God in existence. The problem is this is setting up a false dichotomy between the Fundamentalist Christian God and the non-existence of God. The scenario ignores all the other possibilities such as:
1) The possibility that a different brand of Christianity is true
2) The possibility that a different religion is true and a different God or set of Gods is real
3) The possibility that no religions are true but there is a God that is not affiliated with a religion.
4) The possibility that there are no Gods but there is some kind of afterlife that isn't dependent on a deity.
Etc, etc, etc.
by Castlepaloma3 years ago
Man started wearing clothes 170000 years agoAdam and Eve were naked 6014 years agoAnatomically modern humans originated in Africa about 200000 years ago , most people can believe this, then how come most people are...
by Ethan Green4 years ago
I've only recently discovered some of the pretty intense religious debates raging across these forums. My question is, and I know it's perhaps a difficult question to answer if you haven't spent much time in both...
by stillcurious5 years ago
If I’m lucky, no one on Hub Pages remembers me. But, I’ve never been lucky so I am back to apologize to the fundamentalists. I told myself I left in disgust at the forums; but the truth is I was disgusted with...
by Melissa Barrett2 years ago
It was suggested to me that I start a thread about my own faith... I think that's a wonderful idea. Christianity, which was always fractured at best, has largely broken down into the progressives vs. the...
by lizzieBoo5 years ago
"Science without religion is lame, religion without science is blind, " according to Einstein. The new fundamentalist secularism, as lead by the likes of Hitchens, Dawkins and and Hawking, is...
by Cranfordjs5 years ago
Why do religious fundamentalist proclaim to know the unknowable?
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.