Internet service providers cannot be required by national courts to install filters that would prevent the illegal downloading of files, an EU court said today.
The ruling is a blow to artists who had sought to have their intellectual property rights protected.
“EU law precludes the imposition of an injunction by a national court which requires an internet service provider to install a filtering system with a view to preventing the illegal downloading of files,” the EU Court of Justice in Luxembourg said in a statement after today’s ruling.
SABAM, a Belgian company representing writers, composers and editors, established in 2004 that users of an internet service provider called Scarlet Extended SA were illegally transferring files.
A Belgian court last year sought the EU top tribunal’s guidance on whether forcing an ISP to stop illegal file sharing on its network is in line with the EU’s rules.
But the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled today that this would require monitoring of all electronic communications of all of Scarlet’s customers, infringing on their rights, and violated EU law.
The ruling may also have some impact in Ireland. In 2009, High Court judge Mr Justice Peter Charleton granted an injunction instructing Eircom to block controversial website Pirate Bay, which provides links to locations where copyrighted material such as music can be downloaded for free. Its activities have been the subject of numerous lawsuits.
The injunction was part of a settlement with record labels that saw the telecoms operator implement a "three strikes" rule that would see persistent file sharers cut off from its broadband service.
The Internet Providers Association of Ireland said the ruling set an "extremely important precedent" for ISPs, and would undoubtedly be seen as a landmark judgment.
"This outcome is of particular importance for us since the Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation in June tabled wording for a statutory instrument which would purportedly bring Ireland into line with its European obligations under the copyright and e-commerce directives," the group said in a statement.
"The injunctions regime provided for in the broad wording of the proposal, however, could potentially encompass not only blocking but mass filtering obligations and furthermore, the eventual introduction of a graduated response system is not inconceivable in these conditions. Today’s ruling will certainly set limits on this."
by Sherri6 years ago
I've sent three emails and a certified letter to a website owner who has stolen one of my Hubs, following the DMCA protocol to a T. (I got the vital stats and a postal address from Who Is.) All with no response...
by Thomas Swan2 years ago
Recently, I found that a number of my articles have been stolen for use on various sites and blogs. In at least two cases the stolen version has been outperforming mine, and ranking higher on google. I have been busy...
by Pamela Sarzana5 years ago
If copy writing is the only way to keep your content from getting stolen or "plagiarized". Then how do you go about copy writing it? Is it complicated?
by Ceres Schwarz3 years ago
Hello. I've read the learning center guide on proper image use. I understood the topic well enough but what has me confused is the subject of fair use. From what I understand from reading the guide on image...
by pmccray6 years ago
I like to read the opinion of my fellow hubbers regarding the ruling struck down by the Supreme Court today. It seems that the all Republican appointees struck down a ruling regarding regulation of corporations'...
by Stacie L5 years ago
Germany Women Bras Court RulingGerman bosses can order women workers to wear bras but they must be white or flesh-coloured to avoid being see-throughA court in Germany ruled today that bosses have the right to...
Copyright © 2016 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.