Background - I have 2, 2 year old Shih Tzu brothers (from the same litter) When we got them at 8 weeks old, Oscar was larger and heavier than Deefa. Furthermore, Deefa was the litter runt. We gave them lots of fish oil during their first year to help Deefa's brain develop.
I have tried to work out which is the pack leader, and thought it was Deefa because he always is closer (physically) to me than Oscar.
However, during the past two weeks, Deefa has demonstrated some very "unpack" like behaviour. Here is what he has done.
Usually when I'm preparing dinner, they both sit in the kitchen. However, last week, Oscar asked to sit on the lounge, so I put him there (it is winter here and the floor is fairly cold). I prepared everything for the meal, and then the second I turned on the stove and put the frying pan on it, Deefa ran to the lounge and jumping against the lounge tapped Oscar, and then ran back towards the kitchen looking at Oscar and waiting for him to follow.
Then last night, I gave them their dinner in separate food bowls as usual. Oscar sniffed his, and walked away. He went to the lounge and asked me to put him up. Deefa sniffed his food, then, noticing that Oscar wasn't there, went to the lounge, jumped against it tapping Oscar, then went towards the food and waited for Oscar. I had to take Deefa to his bowl because he didn't want to go by himself.
Can anyone explain this? BTW neither of them can get up onto the lounge, but they can both jump down.
The relationship among social groups in dogs is rather fluid compared to what we are used to believe. According to the APDT quoted " In many households the status of one dog over another is fluid; in other words, one dog may be the first to take his pick of toys, but will defer to the other dog when it comes to choice of resting places." I hope this helps explain why the behavior you are seeing in your dog does not abide to "pack behavior' as we would expect. Best wishes!
I don't have an answer for you, but this could be a question you could always ask K9Keystrokes, the HubPages' resident dog expert(as far as I am concerned).
I hope someone can explain it.
Warning bells rang when you said you couldn't work out which dog is the pack leader.
It should be you mate.
You do realize to them you are the pack leader! Neither of them are the pack leader because you supply them both with food, shelter, and love...they see you as the leader.
I'm sure Deefa was simply trying to tell Oscar that he needs to get in the kitchen to wait for his food! He probably noticed that him being on the lounge is not "normal" behavior and wanted him in the kitchen with you--their pack leader!
I would also probably seperate them during the day, and let them play together when you say its ok. That way they'll enjoy their play time more too.
I have to agree with Libby1970, Deefa was sayin, "Oscar, dude, she's fixin vitals! Get in here or I might eat what's left!" Why Oscar went to the lounge at such an important moment as food can be anyone's guess, but now that this "game" has started it may become habit for Deefa to "tap" Oscar when its time to eat. Dogs just wanna have fun.
And she's also hit it on the head about the "pack leader". There is nothing between Oscar and Deefa, it is YOU that they see as their leader and they are merely your minions.
Two sibling dogs will not necessarily have a dominance/subordinance based relationship. All that is happening is that one is more affiliative (wanting to be together) than the other, at least right now.
Dogs in households do not always follow the strict pack order like you see in wolves, if they are content animals.
Furthermore, I would be much more concerned about your animal refusing food then I would be spending all my hours wondering which of my dogs is "alpha". Does he do this often? This is not something to sneeze at with most dogs.
Thanks for your comment. No, I wasn't worried about Oscar not wanting his food because it was a once off - he usually enjoys his meal, just not that day. He may just have been having a day when he didn't feel very well.
Wolves don't follow a strict linear pack order either. The earlier research was biased to find that. But wolves also have particular friendships and their attachments change of quite short time periods.
Yes, I've become aware of that since I started this thread. Since learning that, I've been watching them, and in different situations, they change who is leading, and who demands attention and when. I've started to understand them better since learning that pack behavior is not always a correct assumption.
great discussion. Good Hub material, huh??? I have two shih tzus and neither of them have ever demonstraed dominence over the other. They are very polite to one another, and have never been jealous of my attention to the other. They play together well, too.
They are so much alike, it's scary. With all the fireworks going on, they were both equally terrified. Both shook with fear. I gave them a pill the Vet. gave me. My two truly love each other!
Hi Mary, Its always nice to meet another Shih Tzu owner. My boys are also polite to each other, but they are also very dependent on each other - kind of glued at the hip and shoulder, and always worry about the other. Bath day is pretty bad as each pines for the other when being washed! Couldn't live without them though :-)
You are the pack leader after saying that I would say that the more domiant out of the two of your dogs is Oscar. People tend to forget dogs have an Alpha Male and an Alpa Female. You are the Alpha female and the pack leader as long as you treat them like a mother pack leader would you wont have much hassle however one of your dogs will be more dominant than the other and could try to become the Alpha male.
I believe Oscar is the more dominant as when he went into the lounge Deefa let him know when he should be in the kitchen. Deefa also refused to eat when Oscar wasn't present which is a submissive thing to do. Instead he tried to tell Oscar to hurry up it is tea time and I am hungry, I want to eat but I know you need to start eating at least at the same time or just before me.
The more doninant dog starts eatting first if this helps you at all.
Good points here! Yes, I've noticed that Oscar is a little more independent. He likes to sit on the lounge after we eat, but Deefa has to sit on my lap which is Okay in winter, but in summer it is not on. Therefore, I am teaching Deefa that sometimes I say no and mean it.
Maybe you are watching a doggie discussion about the food you are giving them, I read the whole thing as "let me out of here, I don't want what you are cooking" and the rest just one persuading the other not to upset you and eat the stuff anyway BTW I am a qualified house trained husband.
I have three female dogs of which I am the pack leader and they all know this but, like your dogs they take turns keeping each other in check with my orders. If I've called them to come inside and one doesn't come when called one of them will go get that dog. They also take turns initiating play which sounds a little bit more of what your dogs were doing. One of my dogs will be sitting on the couch and one of her sisters will just come around the corner and pounce on her and vice versa. Then they chase each other around the house. I wouldn't worry about it as long as they listen to you and enjoy each other's company you should be good to go.
I have two dogs, the dachund is a year older than the jack russel. When Clara (jack russel) joined the household, it seemed as if they were trying to claim who is going to be pack leader, made a lot of noise the first few days. Then on the third day I realised, (ding!) but I am the pack leader. They must have felt it because their competitiveness stopped there and then. They are great friends. I see similar behaviour with Chloe towards Clara. If Clara stays outside to long, Chloe will go and fetch her, same with food etc. Think it is that nurturing instinct, plus they get along wonderfully, and care for each other, so they look after each other.
by hinckles koma 9 years ago
the nature of a man is to be a pack leader right? so why act like a dog with women?
by Cosmic Bus 6 years ago
What can you do in a multiple dog family when they try to establish who is pack leader?
by BrittanyVN 8 years ago
I want to know how to train my two dogs not to run away?They are both yellow labradors. Fences are not an option and both of my dogs are nuetered. My older dog is the problem he likes to hunt so he catches a scent and takes off. He once took of during a snowstorm for 6 hours across acres of fields....
by Karen Ranoni 2 years ago
To anyone who believes in God, please explain this:To anyone who believes in God, please explain this:1.God creates light and separates light from darkness, and day from night, on the first day. Yet he didn't make the light producing objects (the sun and the stars) until the fourth day (1:14-19)....
by keepitnatural 7 years ago
Can anyone explain exactly what we will experience at the end of linear time on Planet Earth (2012)?Is this the end of life as we know it, or in simple terms 'are we all going to die'? Or do we live on in this life but with expanded awareness of some kind? If linear time no longer exists then how...
by Peeples 6 years ago
Can anyone please explain the Obama health plan?If not can you provide a website that can. I am a little worried at how it may impact our family when it kicks in. At what income are you requird to pay for healthcare? We have several family members who can not afford to buy healthcare. Is...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|