I am going to be writing an article that fits into this topic. I am undecided where to post it. We know that Google doesn't get along very well with most medical articles that are not on .gov sites. Quite frankly, it is also my understanding that Google pretty much "black listed" HealDove in the past. I really need to know the status of HealDove with Google at this time.
In my opinion, what with HP's editorial policy, HealDove should be a favored site by Google. But my opinion means nothing; it is Google's opinion that makes or breaks a site.
I am sincerely requesting all information, opinions, clues that might shed light on what Google's opinion of HealDove is at this time. If someone wants to say something, but does not want to say it here; an email is not only fine, but would be appreciated.
Best regards to all,
I have a number of hubs on Heal Dove. However, I am very careful to not give medical advice because I think that is where the problem is with Google.
As for where your article goes, you have no control over that. The team decides which niche to use, not you. So, I wouldn't worry about that part of it.
Health articles often are viewed as YMYL...which means it can be risky to write them. However, it's worth a shot!
I have never seen a site that sends editors into it's writers articles to arbitrarily change their work. I think it is an insult and completely outrageous. I thought our work belonged to us. Hub Pages should not have the right to mess with it.
I see there are no responses. Sometimes, no news is good news; but I'm beginning to suspect this is not one of those times.
First draft of my article is completed. Just got to find some pretty pictures and proofread it the usual half-dozen times.
Thanks for the above responses. I am in a quandary, but I do love the HP Ad Program.
Well, I picked some HealDove hubs at random; incognito. Some of them did indeed show up on page one of Google. I might add I did it by typing in similar titles, no pasting or in quotes. Not bad. Not bad at all.
Will the article be appropriate for Remedy Grove?
Also, I've argued my case when I thought my articles were sometimes on the wrong site, and the team took another look at it and agreed. They are usually pretty fair. Good luck.
I had an article that got significant traffic that's on HealDove, but when the site got slapped by Google awhile back its traffic dropped and still hasn't recovered. So, from what I've seen there hasn't been a recovery.
Nate, you reminded me of my biggest fear. And this applies to all network sites, not just HealDove.
1. Hub(s) accepted and put on network site.
2. Hub(s) builds up seniority, lots of inbound links, lots of steady traffic, reliable earnings.
3. Then an editor kills it.
This has happened to me before. And I've repeatedly seen complaints in the forums about the same thing being done to others. I just now ran the numbers; in my case, I guesstimate that editor has and is costing me somewhere between an extra $400-$500 a year.
I love the HP Ads Program, but I just don't know what to freaking do. If I put the hub on my website, it will earn a lot less; but it will be income I can depend on. Or at least I will only have to worry about Google, instead of having to worry about both Google and the editors; especially since I consider the editors the much bigger threat.
I had that happen to an article on a different account here. It got a lot of views, was edited and views dropped, never recovered. I leave it there for now because it is at least making some money. Frustrating though, no doubt about it.
My conundrum continues. As all relevant variables stand as to HP and as to my website, no decision can be made. I have to sit and wait until one of those variables changes. I realize this is a big yawn for everyone else, but for me it is a big deal . My decision absolutely, categorically has to be right; I just plain can't afford to make any mistakes.
The article is ready to publish (somewhere), however I am in absolutely no hurry to do so. My subconscious has done me very well in the past; all I have to do is wait and sooner or later it serves me up with the correct decision. Besides, other information affecting that decision may become available in the meantime.
Always listen to your gut feelings, they are always right.
I feel bad that you are having this dilemma. Are you sure you don't want to write to the team and talk about it with the editor, or maybe another one? I had to do that with my astrology articles, and in the end we decided on THREE niche sites, Exemplore for the teaching ones, Letterpile, where I wrote fictional stories (but as a means to teach) and some of my metaphysical ones are in the form of book reviews or natural healing. It took time, but the staff was willing to work with me to decide what really belonged where.
Because I often wrote about astrology doesn't mean all my hubs should have been in Exemplore. I am now waiting for dozen of them to be moved to Owlcation, as Greek Myth with references does not belong in Exemplore, it's Humanities. I did my part, and expect them to move all 12.
They should at least be open to hearing what you would be willing to do to get the article back on HealDove in a similar form where it was making you money. It benefits them too.
PD I have never had a bad experience with an editor as long as I'm not trying to do something against HP policies. If at all, the editor makes a change which I am not happy with, I go ahead and change it back. The threat that it will be removed from the niche site is always there. But from my limited experience, this is never done unless you put in links that have been snipped or amazon products that have been snipped (my hubs never got sent back).
You should be able to explain to the editor or someone on staff why you are doing what you're doing against what the editor thinks you should be doing. Every page on the website functions differently. You are a master of your own page. HP as a business understands that I hope. From my experience, the senior staff get this, not so sure about every editor working for them, though.
Why are you losing up to 500 bucks on a hub? What change did the editor make that you were not happy with? If you don't want to post here you can also send me an email, if you want to.
I offer to help you and my score goes below 90... typical
lobobrandon, most of my editor experiences have likewise been positive. Unfortunately, it only takes one to really cause a disaster. In my case, it wasn't a hub; it was an interrelated group of hubs. My guess is HP is still sending out over a 100 404's a day to Pinterest and elsewhere as a result of that incident. I've emotionally gotten over it. But intellectually, the experience will always be a prominent factor in any decisions involving interacting with HP. I want to post the article here. However, there's that old paraphrased saying: " <snipped> me once, shame on you. <snipped> me twice, shame on me."
by Seth Tomko 6 weeks ago
I am uncertain if this same situation has happened to other writers, but I am wondering about why it seems hubpages has become a second-class citizen in its own network. I've written articles here for the last decade and been happy with it for the most part. In the last year or so,...
by Kate Daily 4 months ago
Just curious, but does anyone have experience with this? How'd you do it? Did you tell Google the article moved somehow or do anything else fancy? Or did you just copy, paste, delete from HubPages, and wait for Google to catch up?Im guessing there might be some duplicate content penalties from...
by Paul Goodman 7 years ago
I know that many people don't like HP cracking down, but I personally am hoping that HubPages will continue to find new ways in 2012 to encourage the good writers on here and discourage the spammers and spinners - I really do think that it helps the site's reputation overall with Google and the...
by Athlyn Green 2 years ago
Having written across of a number of sites, some that did the Google dance before dying a slow death, there's a chilling pattern that unfolds, not only for site owners but for their writers. Owners start by making changes--sometimes huge, time-consuming, expensive ones. Earnings climb and just as...
by Tessa Schlesinger 5 weeks ago
So now hubpage pro goes and ruins my article. They remove the first picture which is what draws the traffic to my article. This is how it works. I know this because I used to get 1.5 million views on posts in the early days of G+ And I did that often enough (2 or 3 times a week over a two year...
by Cholee Clay 2 years ago
Is there a common standard or set guidelines that all the editors use to select articles? Or do all the different network sites/editors have their own guidelines for their own sites similar to when we submit our own articles? Is there a way to find all the different guidelines, without trying to...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|