Last night I went through several of my articles and added parentheses to some material in the title so that I could see the response in traffic. The parentheses were removed by HP editing and replaced with a dash. Why?
example: My Dog Was Hit by a Car (So What Happens Next?)
was replaced by My Dog Was Hit by a Car—So What Happens Next?
I think it also causes problems on Googles end or any other search engine...most of those signs are not good to use in titles.
On the contrary, John Mueller from Google once said that it's not a problem and many top sites use it. And it does increase CTR when used right. Because your title stands out and even if it is on the 3rd spot people who usually only click the first result tend to take notice.
Because it does not make sense to include parenthesis here. A hyphen does make more sense.
That is very subjective. My Dog Was Hit By a Car. Period. End of sentence. Next sentence is What happens next?
Exactly it's more like next sentence. It can stand on its own. If it stands on its own, I would personally not put it into parenthesis. Yes, it's subjective. But based on my experience writing meta titles for my own sites and clients sites this is what I do for the best CTR.
My tomato hub that you saw yesterday, could also use a hyphen instead. But for some reason, it was accepted.
What do you think of (5 things that happen next)?
I think this would make sense:
Why Does My Dog Have Swollen Elbows (My Home Remedies)
Not sure if it is the best keywords or if you are losing a long tail, but the parenthesis here could be accepted. Parenthesis does not look good on the title to be honest, so only use it when you really think it is necessary. The increased CTR can be achieved by just making your title stand out. You can do this by answering the searchers query directly.
i would personally change this to (again not sure about the keywords):
My Dog Was Hit by a Car - Here's What You Must Do
I would personally click this title rather than My Dog Was Hit by a Car (So What Happens Next?) because with my title I am sure that I am getting help. With your title I could expect that you say the dog suffers and could possibly die, etc. It does not tell me with 100% certainty that this page is indeed going to help me.
Using non alphanumeric characters could possibly cause problems (delimiter collision), although there's usually a reserved set of characters that are used as delimiters (e.g. forward and back slashes). They're probably trying to avoid something like that happening.
Here is a useful article I found. See item 34 about parenthesis:
https://northcutt.com/seo/53-enlighteni … itle-tags/
In my opinion, if the text within parenthesis is a subtitle to the title, then it makes sense. Otherwise using a hyphen or "em dash" would be better.
DrMark, your first post has a good example of this. "My Dog Was Hit by a Car (So What Happens Next?)" The part in parenthesis is not a subtitle, so it doesn't work well in parenthesis.
Brandon, the example you gave shows the other case. "Why Does My Dog Have Swollen Elbows (My Home Remedies)" The part in parenthesis is indeed a subtitle, so it works.
This makes things a lot easier. Thanks, Glenn.
That is a great link, but it does contradict another that I read yesterday. I want to see how parentheses perform on my own pages.
The comment about adding (video) was interesting. Do you feel something similar might help traffic here? Adding (Text, photos,and video) for example.
You're asking me for my opinion, which may or may not be correct. Nevertheless, in my opinion, I can only repeat what I said before—that parenthesis are useful for subtitles. I don't see (video) as a subtitle, per sé.
Having said that, I wouldn't rule it out either. It's worth experimenting with it. But I remember doing that myself a long time ago for a hub that had a YouTube video in it. I included (embedded video) in my title and one of the HP editors removed it.
by Dr Mark 6 months ago
Do the titles of your article tell the reader what is in it, but do not encourage a reader to click to read more? In the past I have read that titles should be simple but it now appears that titles should tell the reader what is in the article but also have some catchy words. Google will point the...
by pinetreehugger 7 years ago
What happens next after your hub score reaches the number 1?
by Ivorwen 5 years ago
While trying to come up with a creative title, I found this title generator:http://www.fictionalley.org/primer/title.htmlThe titles it generated were not the most helpful, but it did get me thinking (and laughing). All in all, while it may be a poor title generator, it is a great idea...
by Thallia Roberts 5 years ago
While entering "pant..." I got an interesting hub title suggestion:"Smart Ass Thong Panties for Moms Product Review"Sure is an interesting topic! I suppose it would be fun to write about, but it would probably get flagged.Has anyone else experimented with the topic/title...
by easyspeak 8 years ago
What do you think about dashes in titles? Does it affect the SEO of that hub?
by Vic Dillinger 3 years ago
I'm relatively new to this site.I know most sites of its type do their best to be "Google friendly" which translates into "family friendly" (a phrase I hate, by the way). Over the years when tempted to use profanity either in a title or in the body of an article (and I can...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|