Readers are not stupid. We can see when someone knows what they are writing about and when they are just rewriting material from the web.
I was looking for (I leave this out, I think, don't want to attack specific people) I first googled it, read a few reviews, then checked some products on Amazon and then searched on Hubpages. Many of the hubs were just repeats of what I have read before and they were the ones on the first page. Only one hub had extra information which made searching on Hubpages worthwhile.
I know people want to make money, but picking a random object with a good price and then rewriting other sites is not the way to inspire confidence in Hubpages as a whole. I want someone's personal experience of a product or some professional knowledge or at least have the impression that the writer is clever enough to do lots of homework before trying to get me to click on something.
who are you to deny those with no talent, knowledge, or creativity the oppertunity to make money online?
You'd be surprised, but quite a few people use hubpages to promote outright scam
Comparing to this lousy review is peanuts
I have seen hubs that are almost identical to the stuff on a manufacturer site literally copy paste and put on website to make money
unfortunately people are bastard quoted bastards with bastard fillings (those are Dr Kelso's words, Scrubs)
But truth is people are greedy pigs and any slight chance of making a quick buck, they'll jump at it so therez pretty much nothing you can do about that..
Hubbers reviewing products they haven't used themselves?
(1) Law in the U.S. is that if you do a review or promote a product YOU must have used the product at some point.
(2) If a Hubber states that they have not personally used the product or service offered, then their creditability is false.
Just a thought.
Get enough incoming links and it makes no odds.........
And some of us are not in the US.....
At least I am not trying to sell you a device to run your car on water or make a fortune in forex in 3 weeks.....
Hey Mark, I understand some are not, but HubPages is a U.S. Based Company and can be held accountable? If you think not, then you really underestimate the power of the U.S. Government.
That must be true, however the content that Mark Knowles publishes is his. His domicile is not US so...
Where exactly does it say that you must use a product you review/write about?
Since you don't care to answer. Here's the word : http://hubpages.com/hub/What-is-Domicile
And YAY!!! I'm right.
You completely misunderstood, because I was talking about HubPages being held accountable for the actions of Hubbers, who sell products/goods or services, and those people(U.S. based). I said that the U.S. Government if wanted to.....could extend it's reach or use loopholes in the Law(s) to attack HubPages because of the actions of it's users.
Is that clear enough for you?
Pretty clear. Next time you sign up to a website, read its TOS first.
And, you think the U.S. Government of all people think that the rules HubPages outlines is going to make a difference? You keep dreaming. The U.S. Government has gone after and won against much stronger opponents. But, you keep thinking that.
Not in the slightest. All the time google is making substantial moneys - you are safe. Notice they have no qualms about advertisers?
And really. This is peanuts to the US government Inc.
hmm...i have always loved big construction equipment, you know, like those Caterpillar machines...also cranes. i have been wanting to write a hub about them for a while now. mostly from a standpoint of how much they fascinate me. having never used them, could i still write about them? i would have to do some Google-ing, obviously, to add some technical info about them.
What document? What paragraph? Where can you look at it?
well i will write mine from a general perspective i guess. i think it will be pretty obvious i never used a crane in my life
Are you selling them? If not, then you don't have a problem.
I think his point is that if you didn't review the item you must state in your review that your information is not from personal experience and is based on information gathered from other sources, also the fact that hubpages is a US company anything they allow to be posted is their responsibility no matter where the posting comes from because they are liable for the content placed on their site. This is best seen in AdSense, Google dictates strict guidelines and hubpages moderates hubs based on these guidelines because Google does not only hold the hub author responsible but holds hubpages responsible if they do not deal with it properly.
you know whats worse than a reviewer reviewing things for the sake of a hub/traffic without knowing the product?
I am sick of hubbers who have like 100 hubs on the same subject but with minimal tweaking. This is a random and very fake example but hubs that sound like how to use a mouse, how to use a mouse attached to a laptop, how to use a mouse with your right hand, how to use a pink mouse, how to use a pink mouse with a mousepad on and on and on and on
how is that valuable information???
I totally agree with you, i have stopped following people for that very reason. Read the the first hub and thought great, well written, informative. Then read others and thought "hey this sounds familiar" same stuff just moved around changed words, but basically the same. I just stop following and don't bother reading anything they produce, and some I have to say are highly rated hubbers...
I have highlighted items I have never used and talked about their features, but you can't call that a review. I have read the books I have reviewed
I don't understand why people would review products they never used in the first place. To me, that just shows a lack of integrity.
See if this helps clarify?
http://www.ftc.gov/bcp/edu/pubs/busines … bus28.shtm
thanks very much Cagsil. this is why i like the forums...i learn a lot.
I used the products I talked about in a hub of course that was on thigns that aren't back friendly and I know from experience
me too, mostly because i like to share personal stories about said Hub topics.
Cags, some people will just never get it...lol It really is simple, it is like a newspaper or news channel, if they report something they are told by me and my information is wrong, not only am I responsible but the one who published it is also responsible.
I am pretty sure that there is something in the TOS that also states hubpages has the right to remove or unpublish any hub it chooses especially if it can cause harm to hubpages.
The US laws would over ride any TOS I assure you. If the FTC deemed a hub violated something and hubpages did not act to correct or prevent the issue they would be held responsible right along with the person who wrote it.
because the reason hubpages reserves the right to remove or unpublish a hub is to protect them from the very law we are discussig. Hubpages staff and owners know that they can be held liable if they do nothing to prevent or correct a hub which violates a US law.
I know enough to know that the initial point in this post is true, that false reviews in attempt to sell a product are against US law and that hubpages could be held liable if the FTC found reason to go after a hubber who was writing false information to promote or sell a product
by Liz Elias 12 years ago
Well, I've done a fair amount of research on my own, not necessarily understanding all of it, and I've read several articles by fellow hubbers that explain things more simply, still requiring me to bookmark the hub for future reference, as I cannot retain it all in one reading.There seems to be a...
by girly_girl09 13 years ago
http://www.ftc.gov/opa/2009/10/endortest.shtmFrom what I understand, it affects bloggers that are directly paid to endorse or review a product. Here on HP, we don't get paid to write reviews (well, some of you might), however most of us do benefit if someone purchases a product that we reviewed...
by Ceres Schwarz 10 years ago
Hello. I've read the learning center guide on proper image use. I understood the topic well enough but what has me confused is the subject of fair use. From what I understand from reading the guide on image use, fair use lets one use copyrighted images for review-based hubs. Is this...
by Pollyanna Jones 7 years ago
Can anyone help with this one?I've had notifications of a few of my hubs that have "snipped" with a message explaining that this has been done by a moderator so that my article could be moved to one of the new niche sites.Now all of these snips have been for Amazon modules. I've not been...
by lindashockley 10 years ago
It seems hard to see that anyone actually makes any money here. Can someone provide me a hub that I can look up on the internet outside of hubpages & see it? Before I commit any more time to this, I want to know if it will be worth my while. Thanks.
by Gemini Fox 8 years ago
Published a hub on Oklahoma (please don’t get started on how it might be too generic – I had fun doing it). It became the template for my following hubs on Arizona and New Mexico. The Oklahoma one published just fine. The Arizona and New Mexico ones are now Not Featured due to Quality....
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|