Think about this:
What are the odds against you having been born a "human being" and not a "dung beetle?"
Having been born human is pure serendipity!
"Fundies" will quote alota scripture on this one...:
Is "serendipity" too big a word to consider?
Maybe it's just too controversial to think about?
Or maybe the "fact" that the odds that we'd be born human just don't exist? or exist as a googolplex possibility?
Or maybe it is just based on an assumption - that it would have been possible at all to be born as anything other than human - which not many people believe.
Elaborate on that pls...ty
There are billions of species of life on this planet. Why do you think that the only possibility you and I are human is because there was no other possibility?
Clear this up for me pls....ty
Why do you think there could be more than one possibility? That would assume that we have an immortal soul, and that this immortal soul is capable of incarnating into any animal.
To me, your question is like asking - why is this piece of toast I am eating a piece of toast and not a bagel?
There is no reasonable answer to that because it is not a reasonable question. The question assumes that there was a point in time at which my snack could have been either toast or a bagel, and then something happened to make it toast. There was never such a point. It never could have been a bagel. I don't even have any bagels.
The bagel/toast example doesn't make sense. :
Both were dough at one time. Someone decided which item that dough would become.
The "energy" (whatever it may have been) that existed as "you" before it became an egg or sperm, happened to be at the right time and place to have been part and parcel of both facets of human origination i.e. human sperm and ovum. That "energy," that dynamic, could have been part and parcel of the sperm and ovum of a "dung beetle."
A better example might be the inexplicable reason for the "Big Bang theory."
What are the "odds" against there being another "Big Bang?"
No one knows! The odds don't exist.
It's all "good fortune" i.e. "serendipity!
The toast and bagels weren't the best example, you're right. I was just eating toast at the time. Here's a better example: Pointing at a car and asking why it isn't a butternut squash, saying 'what are the chances that would be a car and not a butternut squash'. The chances are a 100%, because it just is a car and couldn't ever have been a buterrnut squash.
The Big Bang one is a better question. But if we don't know the odds, we can't say it is good fortune that it happened, just that it may have been. For all we know the odds of the big bang happening were 100% - so it wasn't good fortune at all, it was innevitable. And as the only thing we really have to go on in assesing what those odds may have been is the fact that the big bang did happen, it would seem more likley that the big bang was either highly likely or innevitable than that it was a very unlikley thing and we just got incredibly lucky.
I guess if you take everything - the universe being as it is, life coming about on earth, humanity evolving and so on then we got amazingly lucky to exist. If that was your point then I agree. But then everything else would have been just as lucky to exist as it does - I'm sure a dung beetle doesn't think it is so bad being a dung beetle.
Sorry - your butternut squash and the car don't qualify - the squash is a living thing that started with a little bang , like humans, but the car is inanimate and so cannot have a soul at all.
And the big bang may not have been fortunate at all - I mean all thos souls were quite happy out there in nowhere then they had to travel all that way and climb into some disgusting creature like a frog, or a vampire bat or one of the Bush family - or maybe even just lay there like a butternut squash - all hoping against hope that someone would come along with a particular edition among editions of a particular book among books that by all the forces of serependipity happened to be the one that contained those special words and then our poor little soul would be saved to watch all the other souls burn and get tortured for eternity which is a very long time that was also a result of the big bang -
Now ya got it!
It's all pure serendipity.
If ya like, just say: hmmm! I don't know. It just happened.
No, I think I was just overcome by a totally out of character wave of niceness and wanted to try to find common ground. I don't think its serendipity or luck at all - its just the way it is.
Is there a dung beetle out there wondering if he might possibly have been born human?
Forgot to say. Serendipity is one of my favourite words !
Maybe you are a dung beetle just dreaming of being a human ?
The chances of you being you are the same as atoms of hydrogen and oxygen meeting up and it raining on your parade, it is a chain of cause and effect that starts (maybe) with the big bang, just like everything else. If anyone thinks that things happen for them when coincidences arise then just think how many times this happens every time it rains.
Hmmm don't know--good question.
Must ponder this--do the various beliefs in reincarnation allow for trans-species incarnations?
Always something interesting to ponder.
If a dung beetle takes a bite out of a butternut squash, would it have preferred a bagel?
by qwark 10 years ago
What was the "medium" within which the "Big Bang" happened? There are other interesting considerations.
by uncorrectedvision 9 years ago
As I understand it, everything did not exist at all a nano-second before the "Big Bang" and everything, absolutely all the energy in the Universe was in existence a nano-second after the "Big Bang." From where did all of this come? How did it come to be? Is it...
by Ron Hooft 9 years ago
I'm interested in your thoughts. Not how. I'm not interested in the idea that a god did it or not. I am interested in your thoughts on why there is something instead of nothing.
by Joseph Attard 5 years ago
Does the Big Bang exclude God or does it prove His existence even more?The universe began with the Big Bang. This is essentially conclusive and may stand as the most profound discovery of all time.
by Peter Leeper 8 years ago
Question for those with faith and atheists. Existence. No Preaching Please!Whether you beleive in a God or you do not, both arguments would have to explain how something could come to exist from nothing. For religious people, how did God come to exist? For Aetheists or...
by John Harper 10 years ago
"The Big Bang was the result of the inevitable laws of physics and did not need God to spark the creation of the Universe."What say you?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|