So I'm at a lost about how to proceed here. During my first week on this site, I wasn't familiar with the system and I ended up spamming a couple of articles which were blocked for dupe content (one was quotes and the other I think was too similar to one of my other articles).
The end result was that all of my articles were unpublished. Instead of informing me, or replying to my requests, HP waited until I came to the community to ask for assistance before condescendingly telling me that I was a big fat spammer and locking the forum topic. Fair enough. I operated in opposition to the rules of the ToS, and got a slap on the wrist. I can deal with that.
The problem is that now I can't seem to get anything published. Out of the 32 articles I used to have published, I've only been able to get 5 of them back up. I have a bunch of them submitted and all that happens to them is every 1-2 days one gets rejected for some reason or another. One was for having some text in italic that apparently made my article look ugly, another was for having "unrelated tags" because the moderator wasn't aware that the they were common names for jobs within the industry that my article was about... The latest one (which, like all of these being rejected, was previously published without problem) was rejected for dupe content & being substandard... and the way things have been going, even *if* I can figure out how to randomly reword it (I wrote it from hand and have no idea what or how much is matching some random place on the Internet), *and* figured out why it's considered substandard and fixed it, I have the feeling that next time they'll flag me for unrelated or excess tags (I've searched and searched, and even asked, but have never gotten an answer to how many are considered excessive).
One of the few articles that has gone through - discussing some scientific research on the effects of red wine - has had ads banned from it... I cannot for the life of me figure out why and can not get an answer from HP to clarify.
So, my question to the veterans here is, is this common practice; how I can expect to be treated for the foreseeable future? Is this HP's way of telling me that I'm not welcome here, by harassing me and wasting my time so that I'll just pack up and go away?
Over-all this is a very good system, and the community here has been great, but if my abilities here are going to continue to be crippled - so much so that even making a multi-part article isn't worth trying because at least one of them is going to get moderated, breaking the series - then this toxic relationship isn't of any real use to either of us.
The system is pretty much automated. If you are not getting the notification emails you need to check that they have a current email address for you and their email is on your "safe" list.
I do get some replies from them so they have my address... and the rejections are not automatic - they *all* passed 'before the fall' and most of them specifically say under the reason for rejection "This information is based on a human review of this Hub"
And in each case you should have an email saying exactly what rule the hub is breaking. Have you search to ensure the emails didn't go astray? If you still don't find them, ask for them to be resent. until you know what the infraction is how can we tell if they are using a different standard for you versus the rest of us?
If you make enough mistakes you will end up having all hub held and reviewed before publication--but that is still done to anyone who has a certain number/rate of infractions not just because someone doesn't like them.
Appreciate the info, as always, Psycheskinner. If they at least communicated what was going on with me and replied to my requests for clarification, I'd feel a lot more like we were working towards a resolution rather than being firmly stuck in this quagmire.
I very much doubt that they hold a grudge.However what they might be doing is checking everything you have done very carefully. After all you have broken the rules by your own admission. As psycheskinner says- check your e mail link, e mail the team and allow plenty of time before you get a reply.
Well i can help you with the red wine one, you cannot use Adsense in articles with alcohol related topics, thats Google rule.
"Ads are also not permitted on pages which sell or promote the sales of beer, hard alcohol, or liqueurs."
"Promote" seems to be a gray area right now.
It's not Hubpages' TOS that's being crossed by the wine content, but Google's TOS that's being crossed. They don't allow work that promotes buying or using alcohol, so your article could have crossed a line somewhere.
Oh come on! Seriously? Seriously?
My hub "15 Things to do in Fresno - Vacationing in California" was rejected for 'Gambling, Alcohol, Tobacco, or Weapons', because one of the 15 things is taking a friggin' wine-tour??
Is there absolutely no level of allowance for common sense? If I wrote a story about my dog named Vodka would it be pulled because I'm encouraging children to go out and lick strange dogs in the hope they might actually taste like liquor?
The best thing to do under these circumstances will be, to start your own blog or site with all those articles, use adsense codes in them, and see what happens.
Just an idea
That's good advice, SunSeven. I am moving a lot of my articles over to my own server; it's just unfortunate, as I really like Hubpage's interface and the community atmosphere here.
You may want to write for TRIOND, they are a revenue sharing site that has an active community and from what I understand let people write on whatever topics they want.
The content you submit to them must be original because they have software that can detect duplicates as well.
The system is based on keywords, use enough of them and you will get a warning. To avoid a "vanishing" that is when you contact support....
certain words seem to trigger the censors,probably a software program and not an actual person.yeah the response can be slow.
hubpages is trying to stay a successful online business since Panda hit so being careful is for the sake of the site and all the writers..
Some people are like moths. They just keep throwing themselves into the flames.
With content writing I think it is always good to spread your risk over more than one platform. So if this material seems to be okay for adsense but not for Hubpages you might try branching out into another host like Squidoo or Infobarrel?
I've not known HubPages to hold any grudges in all the years I've been on the site... But it's fairly common for disgruntled site users to do so.
by lesterd2009 7 years ago
Hey guys,I been a member of Hubpages since early 2009 really almost going on 4 years now. In the beginning was very excited since I a lot people were sharing and commenting on the info I was sharing with the Hubpages community.Anyways I decided to stop by after almost 9 months of not visiting the...
by Audrey Selig 7 years ago
Is there a way to exclude hubbers who do not have idled hubs from the 24 hour review for new articles? This may be the wrong place to enter this request, and maybe it is an impossibility. It would be nice if staff could facilitate the process of newly written material.
by Mary Craig 7 years ago
Wouldn't it be nice if some explanation about the hub came with the above mentioned notices. All you get is the general notice that you hub is overly promotional or substandard and it needs to be fixed. If it is re-submitted and is not fixed properly you could be banned from...
by Persecution-ave 6 years ago
I just tried to publish my first article and it received a substandard ratings. I then got a form letter email that said absolutely nothing. In the email it referenced a website that I referenced but that's it. It's not a subversive site or anything, in fact its a website put up by the american...
by ziyena 14 months ago
Lately, I've been checking the feed. I've flagged a couple of articles related to spamming one's own business. After looking more closely, I've also noticed published articles (not even articles) that most would consider extremely sub-standard. I'll be the first to admit that I'm...
by January Moon 7 years ago
Why are some hubs flagged for substandard articles, and other hubs that are Plainly substandard andare not flagged? Ive seen articles with two paragraphs, or pictures only with one sentence, these articles have not been flagged for correction, so Id like to know what the real criteria is for...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|