If you were an employer, who would you most likely hire? The person with a degree or the person who actually had experience in the field?
That totally depends on the job. Some work cannot be done without the degree first. Having said that there is no substitute for experience but people with "half a brain" can always be taught. So I would still say the degree outweighs the experience only because assuming the job needs a degree it would be required.
I would take the person who has experience, even a little over those who have a degree. The experience cannot be out done by a degree.
I believe that through experience you gain knowledge, so I would hire the person with the experience.
I disagree, without knowledge, you will not know what will you be doing. Knowledge is the basis for skills or experience. Yes, you had an experience but you do not know what's behind of doing that or so..
2-1 so far. thanks for taking the time to answer. The reason I asked was because I was curious as to why they all say that you NEED a degree of some kind to even be considered for a position. I personally would rather have an experienced person working for me. I find that knowledge from a text book is sometimes quite different from the actual application.
I think it may depend somewhat on the type of job.
In mechanical engineering both are vital to a full understanding.
I believe many with long term experience will have a degree or be able to pass the test of understanding all the necessary theory.
I would pick the one with the best people's skills, and personality. If you have the degree and no experience, you can always be taught and gain that experience within the company. Employees with experience might also have acquired some 'bad habits' along the way, or some preconceived attitude about what falls under his specific job description and what doesn't. They can't be molded according the the needs of the company.
agree. It depends on the job. In my current position, they wanted someone with the right kinds of skills etc but not specific to that job. They actually didn't want someone too experienced or qualified in that area, because they wanted to train them their way.
Qualifications and/or experience may get you a foot in the door, but it doesn't guarantee success.
It seems the more socially savvy employee retains their job, rather than the most competent.
I'd hire the applicant who has both.
The choice of one over the other, however, would depend on the job. Some employers might want to mold a new employee (preferring the degree), while others might need an instant fix (preferring the experience).
by Grace Marguerite Williams5 years ago
Many recent college graduates are currently unemployed. They contend that there are very few jobs comparable to their education. There are some recent college graduates who remain unemployed 4 years...
by Sarah Griffith7 years ago
Are you in a job now that uses the degree you earned in college?
by Ray Iron19 months ago
ABSOLUTELY NOT!!! Ability and social skills are BY FAR the most important in getting a good job. Steve Jobs dropped out of college, and look how he prospered! There is a long list of people who have done...
by Nithya Venkat4 years ago
What is the difference between knowledge and wisdom?
by Riece2 years ago
The common wisdom is that you should go to college, get a good education, and find a job afterwards and you will be financially successful. Isn't that an outdated concept? The average college grad is unemployed for two...
by L. Spikes6 years ago
Do you think the value of a college education is being reduced by the growth of free and reliable online learning resources? I'm primarily talking about the majority of bachelors degrees and not most professional...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.