"Are you really in control, or is your every decision predetermined? ..."
All of life is an illusion created by each human. If one doesn't like their illusion they should change it.
You live in a predetermined state until the day you know that you can decide if, when and how you shall die.... And that day is the day of your birth, for it is the dah you begin to Live. Life is absolute freedom.
I wouldn't really care if Scientists believed this if it wasn't for this:
"Though everyone must be held accountable for his or her actions, neuroscience and the nonexistence of free will should be factored into some criminal cases, the scholars argued."
That is severely worrying. If we posit that there is no free will then we can posit that there is no such thing as morality. Very dangerous.
Yeah, they don't seem to care..
They believed they are predestined to not care anyway, so no one can blame them right?
It leaves everyone unaccountable, which is simply silly.
Yes, we have free will, and thinking the opposite holds no logically sound basis at all.
If "I" want to be a mail-man, then it is a 'personal' desire and I go apply.. [who made me do it??]
That comes from 'freedom'...
People have blown the concept into confusion because some people wrote long paragraphs and twisted the logic...
You 'take' freedom from people with guns and power. You can't 'take' what people don't 'have'... Therefore they 'have' freedom, and in freedom they have free will..
PS: Don't want to hear anyone bashing me, you can't say "I don't have free will, something made me this way I 'had' to say something.."
An interesting article. Six is a small segment of a larger population. I found further interest with left brain thinking being 4 and right brain being 2. Pedrog's statement is intriguing too. Bookmarked the article for sci-fi adventure story ideas. I ponder more from the historical perspective vs. the evolution of science. Rational thought vs. empirical thought flows a bit. Now, the question to be considered - was this decision made just now, after writing this blurb, predetermined to post? And, those posts made prior to this post, were they predetermined to give cause to the overall post - content, thoughts, biology, etc. Who knows about the next reader? Or, the subsequent returning viewer too. Is this thread empirical in nature or rational? And, what about the song coming on my internet stream right now 'Baba O'Riley' by the Who. Odd . . . as the P90X commercial says, 'Push the button . . .
In some ways it is. There are only so many choices you can make in any given situation. Future is not set -do'nt believe in that. Things are just more likely or less likely.
btw.. if you conclude on the assertion that no one has free will, then you are bound by your own words and moral conclusion to free all thieves, murderers, serial killers, pedofiles, rapists, etc.. as 'they didn't choose to do anything'...
hmm, yeah - can't wait to see that political agenda.
i'll be LEAVING the country. Of my OWN FREE WILL.
by TruthDebater7 years ago
Does free will exist, or is it an illusion that is predetermined by our programming? Is free will compatible with determinism? If no free will, how are genetic mutations explained? If something is random from...
by TruthDebater7 years ago
Do the hubpages forums show that you have free will? Or is every answer you are about to write already determined by how you are wired? If you wrote what you first thought of writing, then change the comment simply to...
by janesix3 years ago
Free will or fate? I think most people believe in free will, but I suppose I could be wrong. It doesn't seem to matter whether someone is a theist or an atheist as to which they believe. It just seems like a personal...
by Eric Dierker3 years ago
I just started a forum looking into the subject. It was great and polite but the discussion veered into all about people who believe in God and how that is fallacious.Here I hope we focus on the atheist. Can the atheist...
by Alem Belton6 years ago
Early this morning a young Marine died while crossing the street here in New York City. This tragedy got me thinking, "this kid could have died while serving time overseas in a war torn nation, but instead died on...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.