ArtsAutosBooksBusinessEducationEntertainmentFamilyFashionFoodGamesGenderHealthHolidaysHomeHubPagesPersonal FinancePetsPoliticsReligionSportsTechnologyTravel
  • »
  • Books, Literature, and Writing»
  • Literature

"Frankly my dear..." A Review of T.C. Boyle's The Women

Updated on May 6, 2009

And Frank Didn't Give a Damn, According to Boyle's Account of the Scandalous Life and Times of Frank Lloyd Wright

In an interview about his newly released book The Women, author T.C. Boyle confessed that he never knew much about Frank Lloyd Wright until he moved into Wright's George C. Stewart House in California. Before reading Boyle's book my own knowledge of Wright was also sketchy, consisting of vague images of jutting planes, a hokey Simon and Garfunkel song and a blurb about Jugendstil from my high school A.P. Art History textbook. This past weekend all that changed when I gorged on Boyle's toothsome book detailing the lives of the women who orbited Wright's libidinous and prodigious genius.

Boyle's novel, set in the early 20th century, chronicles the lives of Wright's three wives and mistress from the point of view of Tadashi; a fictional Japanese apprentice and biographer of Wright who inserts footnotes and, we are given to understand, spent many years at Taliesin- Wright's physical and spiritual home in Spring Green, Wisconsin.

A book I read on the Art Noveau movement, the time when Wright was at his height of fame, called it a period of "spiritual anxiety": old forms of being and living dissolved into the new social, cultural, and moral climate of industrialization. The Victorian era was over and women began to, figuratively and literally, loosen their corsets. Ideas about sex, art and life eddied and swirled. These threads of anxiety are cleverly interwoven throughout the text of The Women.

Frank Lloyd Wright

One Man, Four Women

Although Wright's architectural genius is explored, the novel is mostly centered on the experience of the women in Frank's life, thus the title. All four women in the book could be viewed as before, during and after aspects of the Modernist movement taking place during the early 20th century in literature, art and science.

Wright's first wife, Kitty, is a remnant of 19th century sensibilities, embodying the past and the "separate spheres" ideology that reigned under Queen Victoria's rule. Her nickname Kitty (given name was Catherine) denotes a harmless pet. In the 19th century a woman was supposed to stay in her world of "Kinder, Kuche, Kirche" (children, kitchen, church). Wright, an egomaniac and control freak, even goes so far as to design and dress Kitty as if she is his own doll and their house in Oak Park is a dollhouse.

Wright shakes off his wife, and twenty years of marriage and six children, to have an affair with Mamah Bothwick Cheney, a woman rooted in the 20th century and a staunch women's rights supporter and an acolyte of the Swedish free love activist Ellen Key. It is for Mamah that he builds Taliesin in Wisconsin.

After Mamah, Wright marries sculptress and narcissistic southern belle Miriam Noel, a woman steeped in the drama of Art Noveau and the Parisian scene. But Olgivanna, a Russian foreigner, is the wife he will ultimately spend his golden years with. Olgivanna's angular asceticism sets the stage for the post-modern era of track homes and ennui that will eventually follow Wright after his death.

Does Wright really love these women? It is hard to say and I won't give away the plot by explaining further.

Taliesin in Spring Green, Wisconsin

BY Royalbroil CC
BY Royalbroil CC

A Novel Structure

Rather than tell the story straight, Boyle employs an interesting narrative device by beginning the story with Olgivanna, working his way back to Kitty and Mamah at the end of the book, then looping back to Miriam for the finish. Doing this challenges our notions of perspective in much the same way Wright did with his buildings. We also get to pop inside the heads of all of the characters to get their spin on things. Using an omniscient point of view limits our ability to empathize with the characters and keeps Wright and his women somewhat removed from us as readers.

Some reviewers on Amazon have also complained that the prose is often very flamboyant and purple, with needless frills and inexplicable phrasing. The book is replete with such gems as: "But word does get out. Word travels fast, it seeps and bubbles and runs in the ditches like heavy rain in a wet country, and when she began to show, when there was no hiding it anymore and the leaves turned and dropped from the trees and the clouds moved in low to scatter sleet across the new windows and new roofs of Taliesin II, the phone rang again." (Boyle, 67)

Why did Boyle do this?

In my opinion Boyle's book, though the characters are finely wrought, is less about character and more about the structure of a novel. The book itself, the way it is organized and written, is a symbol or allusion to Frank Lloyd Wright. Like Frank and his buildings, the book is artfully and carefully built: a tad narcissistic, with emotional, sometimes florid, flourishes. And yet it is also stark, remote and ineffable-completely unknowable and often new, even though you turn its pages and crease its binding. This is a book about people, yes, but it is also the embodiment of an idea and an ideal that can be found in the formidable and flame tortured Wright home Taliesin. The Women represents a society on the cusp of nihilism and narcissism, invoking in its pages the spirits of Darwin's champion Clarence Darrow, madness, modernism and artistic passion.

Author T.C. Boyle in Leipzig,Germany (BY Amrei-Marie CC)
Author T.C. Boyle in Leipzig,Germany (BY Amrei-Marie CC)

Okay. Go on with your bad English Lit self! But is it worth reading?

Yes. Yes it is.

I admit it. I am an English Literature nerd. I never met an 18th or 19th century book that I didn't like and have often shied away from those books written in my lifetime. Luckily I am a devotee of bubblegum mags so I read about this book in O. Thanks to synchronicity I found The Women at my local library and, voila, I am now a T.C. Boyle fan. I am ashamed to say that I never read a book by T.C. Boyle until now. He is fabulous writer.

What more can I say? I loved it and relished every morsel that I read. The Women is lush, cinematic, and a bit naughty- without being disgusting or graphic. The book explores questions about genius, the importance of love, and the ability to be redeemed without giving us a prefab answer. It is an excellent selection for a book group, or a rainy April afternoon by the fire, with a little Simon and Garfunkel in the background.

Four stars.

So long...Frank Lloyd Wright...

Do You Like Frank Lloyd Wright's Style of Architecture?

See results

Fallingwater in Pennsylvania

CC GNU Free Documentation License
CC GNU Free Documentation License
Hollyhock House
Hollyhock House
Wright's Imperial Hotel
Wright's Imperial Hotel


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • talkmary50 profile image

      Mary Guimont 18 months ago from Pacific Northwest

      Hi K.D. I have never read this book but after reading this I am most definitely am going to get the book and read it. Thank you


    • K.D. Clement profile image

      K.D. Clement 8 years ago from USA

      It is like the rest that I posted. Some people have complained about his "purple" style but I loved it. Guess I am a fan of purple prose. :-)) I know, who could have thought the architect's life was so spicy? Thanks for commenting.

    • JamaGenee profile image

      Joanna McKenna 8 years ago from Central Oklahoma

      K.D., if the rest of The Women is like the passage from page 67, then I'm hooked on Boyle already! As for FLW, I was never curious about his private life until now. I *have* to find this book. Thanks!

    • K.D. Clement profile image

      K.D. Clement 8 years ago from USA

      AE, how wonderful. And you are welcome. I am stymied in the novel writing department but I would love to hear how you are getting along.

    • AEvans profile image

      Julianna 8 years ago from SomeWhere Out There

      I am writing a novel on romance and I am certainly looking forward to reading this one, thanks for the review. :)

    • K.D. Clement profile image

      K.D. Clement 8 years ago from USA

      It is a fun read! One I could put down-but also had no problem taking up again.

      Maybe you could write a hub about writing a romance book? I would be very interested in learning how one writes for that particular genre.

    • MissJamieD profile image

      MissJamieD 8 years ago from Minnes-O-ta

      This is awesome! Seriously, I have a one year old and haven't had time to read a book, at least in its entirety. I am going to make a special trip across the street (literally) to the library and request this book as well, if it's not already there. This is an awesome review and I appreciate that you did it because now I'm interested in 18th and 19th century stories as well. I am just now learning to write romance myself and think this would be a great book to enjoy AND learn from. Thanks again, great hub:)