jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (4 posts)

What would the Legions of Ancient Rome have done if Rome was doing what D.C. Is

  1. turgeo2004 profile image61
    turgeo2004posted 6 years ago

    What would the Legions of Ancient Rome have done if Rome was doing what D.C. Is doing today?

    what would the Legions do if (Washington D.C. was put in Romes place in AD 70 and Obama had been Caesar? would they

    A. Bow before him and say yes master we agree with you on taking away our rights.
    B. Rise up under a General and cross the rubicon Enter Rome, “Take Care of business” then restore the republic.
    C. Rise up under a general and cross the rubicon Enter Rome, “Take care of business” Create a new Dictatorship?
    D. Roll around in the hay outside of town butt naked and having a dope smoking contest while they trip on LSD and Protest? but without any results coming from the protest?

  2. Wil C profile image60
    Wil Cposted 6 years ago

    This is a difficult question, since we are not quite the same republic as Rome.  I would hope we do not over react as they did and have another civil war.  We do not need that or want that.  Peaceful protesting has always been the most effective way to enact change in our country.  But to answer your question, I believe they would exhaust all measures of diplomacy before taking to arms.

  3. Mr. Happy profile image82
    Mr. Happyposted 6 years ago

    I am not sure why you chose the Legions of Ancient Rome as an example. The Roman Empire collapsed from within just as the United States Empire is crumbling from within now.
    I am of the opinion that the military should not be in charge of taking decisions in a country. Military people are good at war not at governing.
    The Legions of Rome were loyal to their general for the most part. That is why generals could walk with their armies in Rome and declare a dictatorship - under whatever general was leading the army at any given time.
    Cesar did that, Marc Anthony did the same, etc.
    I would not want generals leading any country ... I look at Burma, Thailand and such countries where the military is in charge (Pakistan also) and I see nothing good.

  4. uncorrectedvision profile image60
    uncorrectedvisionposted 6 years ago

    There were Roman generals during the time of the Republic that would remind the Senate of its duty to the People.  Once the Republic was gone and Rome became an Empire it became a matter of sufficient resources, ambition and loyalty as to whether one would remain Emperor or be capable of challenging the Emperor for power.

    Today, if we lived with a military with Roman morals and ethics - thank God we do not, the Commandant of the United States Marine Corps would be the most dangerous threat to the existing government..