Is the United States a Republic or a Democracy?
So most people believe the United States is a Democracy. The US was actually founded as a Republic. Some of the founders had put much thought in what they wanted the country to be. They knew that all of the previous democracies in the past had failed, and moved towards tyranny. So they created a Republic with democratic processes. Who can tell me the differences of a Republic and Democracy? Also, why have all Democracies failed in the past, and if true why did we switch from a Republic to a Democracy instead of listening to history?
Wow, so my response grew so big it became a new Hub! o.O
You can check it out...
Is the United States a Republic or a Democracy?
You have the perfect answer in your hub, Gecko, so I will only expand a little. 1) The Continental Congress is what conservatives seem to want to replicate and 2) our democratic republic idea is actually historically based-on Greek and Roman ideas.
Excuse me. The biggest influence to the early Americans was the Native American confederations. There was nothing like that in Europe. Let's keep it real and adopt more of their wise ways.
See? This is the kind of muddled garbage that floats around the internet. Everyone who makes it all the way to fifth grade knows how the government was established. We all know that it is a republic as well as a representative democracy. So, asking a question about whether it is a republic or a democracy is either too lame to believe or subversive.
Now, folks in other countries may be confused, but it hardly matters. A true democracy is one person, one vote. Because of the disparity of population from region to region this would not be fair. Of course you know that, because you are Thomas Jefferson and you helped to reach a compromise. Go on down to Fox News and MSNBC to remind them how it works. In case you forgot . . . we work together.
Hey, how do you get a picture to show up in your comment?
I have to agree with SB asking the question. When 1/2 of America doesn't know who the current VP is, I suspect just as many don't know, or care, what a demcracy, republic, or representative democracy is; I think it is a legitamite question
Submit comment, click edit comment, add photo option is above quarky, drupal box. I get my image from Yahoo before I submit (right click save image url) so it is ready. It is better to use your own image if you have one.
A Republic is representative government ruled by law(Constitution). A democracy is a government ruled by the majority (mob rule). A Republic recognizes the inalienable rights of individuals while democracies are only concerned with group needs.
What? I thought you couldn't get good LSD anymore.
Hey LD, sorry I didn't get my question approved by you, next time I'll run it by you first.
A democracy is all about individual rights. This is a republic, because the elite of the day did not trust the common man of the day to make good decisions. From listening to you, they may have been right. Where are you really from?
You are absolutely wrong about that. In a democracy, 51% have power over the other 49%'s rights. In a republic you can't take the rights away from anyone.
How do you figure? In a republic the ones in power can blow off the majority. Where have I heard this before . . . oh yeah . . . the "Peoples" Republic of China.
You are tripping. We have a constitution that guarantees the rights of the individual. This keeps the majority from disregarding the rights of the minority. We choose our reps by a democratic process. China used military - murdered opposition. No fun
It's a democratic republic. Incidentally, you don't capitalize those words. "Republican" and "Democrat" are only captialized when they refer to members of those respective parties, because then they are proper nouns.
As far as listening to history, when it comes to republics or democracies, the US is making history. Although it is one of the youngest countries in the world, it is the oldest republic or democracy in the world.
I don't really understand the point of this question, and it is a question with a point, not an actual question. It probably belonged in the forums, although it did inspire a Hub, so perhaps I'm wrong there.
I can never get the capitalization right, and it Pisses me of, lol. I freely capitalize conservative, constitution, president and other such words sometimes properly and sometimes not and it upsets me that I don't remember when to and when not to.
Sorry for the capitalization. There are differences between a republic and democracy. Republic you have individual rights, where as in a democracy, the majority has rights. Democracies have always failed in the past. We can't be both at once.
The last democracy was in ancient Greece. Hello? Is anybody home?
Sorry, I sounded pretty pedantic there. A pure democracy would be a disaster. We need something (like our Bill of Rights) to protect individuals from the tyranny of the majority. Have there been any pure democracies?
Have there been any pure forms of any type of government? o.O
A republic since the people of the United States elect people to represent them in government, rather than a true democracy in which everything the government does is put up for a vote by everyone (that would be interesting).
Neither, anyone who thinks that we the people have any say in government anymore is living in la la land. We were taken over by the banks in 1913 when the Federal Reserve was established. It's been downhill ever since.
A republic can be a democracy. The question is not well framed despite the table above, which includes bias against republics.
It is neither. Your grid is off, as well. Corporations and those with money are at the top of the US government. The US is a plutocracy with a thin veneer of appearing as a democratic republic.
Have things really changed much then? The wealthy at the top ruling over the rest of us. Doesn't seem to matter which form of government we choose (or, they choose) =\
thegecko is right doesn't matter what form of government, there is always a top class and bottom class. We used to have a middle class in which people were able to live comfortably, but government inflated the money, and caused transfer a of wealth
Throughout history people in power end up failing. Those not in power overthrow them. Time passes. The once usurpers transform into incompetent leaders. They in turn become overthrown. Cycle continues.
After all the feedback and answers provided, it motivated me to write my own hub on the subject. Feel free to comment and argue your points.
http://sportsbetter.hubpages.com/hub/Wh … -Democracy
by ga anderson 17 months ago
My fear starts out with the basics: Pure Democracy is no more than mob rule. Have you ever heard of the term "mob rule" used in a positive context?Pure Democracy has no allowance for minority interests. It is the essence of "Might, (as in most numbers), makes right." Is that a...
by Kathryn L Hill 4 years ago
Democrats expect people to pull together to help one another in a collective way. They do not realize this system removes a certain amount of individual freedom through raising taxes. Republicans want to empower the individual by keeping taxes low. They believe individuals, (through the self-effort...
by Poppa Blues 11 years ago
America is NOT a democracy! To understand the difference between a democracy and a REPUBLIC, read on, and you'll realize why the health care bill is unconstitutional!"A Republic, if You Can Keep It" Written by John F. McManus Monday, 06 November 2000 11:31 The...
by Danny R Hand 11 years ago
WE DO NOT LIVE IN A DEMOCRACY!!!!! We live in a Republic. Does everyone not read and just settle for being indoctrined these days? There is a big difference between the two!
by VC L Veasey 4 years ago
Should States Be Allowed To Secede From The Union of the United States Of America?Which Could Effectively End The Union That So Many died during the Civil War to maintain.
by Kieron Walker 7 years ago
If you could tweak one thing about democracy in general, what would it be?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|