I moved back to the US after 15 years in a country where stores closed on all Holidays and Sundays. I even remember when that was so in this country. Life goes on even when we can't shop 24 hours a day, 365 days a year and I think it has/had more quality when we had to occupy ourselves with family and friends or just a quiet day.
I think the stores are crazy, because it is actually is just more expense, and no real profit. They are giving us convenience that we pay for in higher prices.
I have been told that roughly 20% - 25% of the holiday shopping is done on black Friday. Even if this is true, why is it necessary to constantly move the bar earlier and earlier? Why isn't there more resistance?
We went trough this when we started opening on Sundays years ago. Because each retailer wants your dollars and they know if one is open your allotted amount may be spent there, so they all must open in hope they can win you away from the others.
I think stores should be open 365 days a year. I don't see the point in closing just because of a holiday. What's the point? In this economy I am sure there are plenty of people who would offer to work these days for the over time/ holiday pay. I have an issue with the idea of companies or in some parts of the usa, the government trying to control when people can and can not shop.
Capitalism has got out of hand. Isn't anything sacred any more? But what should we expect from a society who gives no second thought to the plight of the natives who once lived on and cared for the land?
I think it's all in the name of greed and why not close for the day to give employees a break and time with their families for one day, rather than have them dealing with crazed lunatics fighting each other over stupid sales items. I get more and more disgusted with our culture and how it has corporatized everything. Sad.
You are right. And companies use the excuse that other retailers are doing it. Not one of them can be an example because they are greedy. Customers willing to spend their time in lines and fighting over deals, don't value or use their time wisely.
I don't think so. Let the employees spend the whole day with their families where they want to be. Unfortunately, the holidays have become so commercialized people have lost focus as to what they really mean. So sad.
Just imagine, the day after Christmas we'll be seeing Valentine's Day stuff in stores, the day after Valentine's it'll be St. Patrick's day stuff. People allow companies to shove "stuff" down their throats.
I don't think they should. It is not a day that people should work. There are some days that everyone should just have a day off. I don't think we respect the holidays or each other enough. For someone to go shopping on a holiday is just insanity.
My opinion is a little different. While I think celebrating Thanksgiving is a wonderful tradition - it is just that a tradition. Often we become slaves to tradition and allow that to govern our actions.
If a person wants to celebrate a traditional Thanksgiving, then they are free to do so and they can stay home from the shops and out of the crowd.
Businesses are likewise free to be open or not and yes, their chasing after the almighty dollar can be a frustrating thing to watch, I don't think it should be mandated that stores are closed on that holiday.
I agree with you. If people stay home on Thanksgiving stores will lose money. Then next year they won't do the same.
I totally agree DianeTrotter. It's the stores' choice but customer actions play a HUGE role. I choose to shop on days other than holidays, but I can't and wouldn't make that law. There are hundreds of other days to shop if desired/needed.
Stores don't lose money, because people don't spend more because they are open more, they spend what they have at different times, so it costs them more to stay open, which in turn must be covered by increased prices!
Justsilvie, then when the prices are too high, shop at Target!
I don't think so because it's unfair to employees that would prefer to be elsewhere. We have so much available online on Thanksgiving and HUNDREDS of other days offline. Would people literally DIE if they (and others) couldn't skip Thanksgiving to go shopping of all things? I tell you, some of these companies and shoppers need to go spend a day volunteering at their local food bank or shelter on Thanksgiving since they soooo desire a day out. Perhaps they'd learn the meaning of it all.
absolutely - It boggles the mind how we spend a day being thankful - allegedly, and then people literally the very next day (now the same day) trample each other for more junk. Many would benefit from an eye opening experience like a soup kitchen.
I think employees should make their own choices and be paid double time if they work. Some employees could use the extra money for Christmas.
It's entirely up to the store owners, which is to say it's not our business to decide. What is ours is the decision of where to shop. If you don't want to buy from a place that opens on holidays, then go elsewhere, but don't presume to instruct others, or the stores, in what to do.
I've noticed that a few here have responded stating it is up to the business if they want to open early during the Thanksgiving holiday. The unfortunate result of these actions is a further deterioration of the family unit. I fondly remember when we had the Sunday Blue Laws in place and stores were required by law to be closed on Sunday. What was the end result? Well, families took the proverbial Sunday drive, visiting other family members or friends. A family oriented Sunday dinner was cooked and served with everyone around the dinner table. It was a day of bonding and spending quality time with each other.
In the climate of profits over people we have lost what the real value of family is. A flat screen TV purchased on Thanksgiving for $125.00 is not worth the price of skipping out on family or loved ones in order to save a few dollars. In my humble opinion, opening a store on a holiday is a further indication of the eroding of moral values versus the corporate profit and loss statement.
I would say no - one extra day of shopping does not matter - but retailers are crazy and will do anything to get a jump on the competition. Regardless, I won't be out shopping on Thanksgiving (or the day after for that matter) . . .
As someone who spent many years working retail - Thanksgiving is 1 of 2 days during the entire calender year that you get to be home from work with the rest of the world. The other being Christmas.
Otherwise, you're working weekends, and all your shifts are 11-8 or 12-9 or something horrible like that. Not easy if you've got a family and school age children.
Let the retail workforce have some reprieve. They're gonna be there til the wee hours of the night on Wednesday getting ready. Then right back when the clock strikes 12am on Friday.
Some stores do, but I think most should be closed for the employees' sakes. Who wants to work on Thanksgiving? Yuck.
I donot think stores should be open on any holidays!They should be only open on regular days & with regular hours,without all these crazy hours & crazy times!We survived shopping the old fashioned way before & we will be able to survive it in the future!This way everyone can enjoy the holidays &people will not get trampled simply by just going shopping.
by Arthur Russ 2 months ago
Paid Vacation (Holiday Leave)In the UK everyone gets six weeks paid leave (vacation) by law from the first day of work. In contrast there is no legal minimum in the USA but my understanding is that typically Americans usually get about two weeks’ paid vacation once they’ve worked for their...
by r2moo2 10 years ago
I was just doing a little study on Walmart, as I was updating my Boyfriend Gift Ideas blog, and found out that many companies went bankrupt because of Walmart.As I am in a country, Singapore, which does not seem to have direct influence from Walmart, I want to ask how it has been for you, and your...
by tnvrstar 9 years ago
Or is it just me?
by Writer Fox 7 years ago
I could hardly believe my eyes when I just saw this news:http://www.foxbusiness.com/industries/2 … day-plans/Walmart is going to start its Black Friday sales push by opening up at 6:00 pm on Thanksgiving Day! That means that their employees don't even get the day off. Are...
by Faith Reaper 7 years ago
In the month of September, does it make good business sense for retail stores to sell decorationsMy husband and I went to a major chain restaurant that also sells retail items. When we walked in, this month of September, we were greeted with Halloween, Thanksgiving and Christmas all at once....
by nanderson500 8 years ago
Which of the following holidays is your favorite?Halloween, Thanksgiving, or Christmas?
Copyright © 2021 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of Maven Coalition, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|