Recently four people and one three month old baby were killed during a high speed police chase. Can high speed police chases be replaced by technology to trace the offenders and thereby avoid the deaths of innocent pedestrians and motorists..
The moment a chase becomes dangerous it should be stopped.
They should be allowed to pursue a high speed chase in cases where what the chasees might do if left uncaught is worse than the potential damage than the chase itself.
Lisa, do you seriously expect a young guy in a uniform to make a sound decision about the risks involved, while in the middle of a high speed chase, eager and anxious?
Let's put it this way.... I don't expect the police to not chase a criminal who has a kidnapped person in the car. It may be dangerous, but I would imagine it would be more dangerous for the guy to get away with the kidnapee.
So it's ok when a few innocent people get killed and injured in the process (quite possibly including a kidnapped one), and some serious property damage is inflicted, as long as they catch the criminal, right? So the justice can prevail no matter cost?
I could care less about personal property. It can be replaced. And no, I don't want or expect innocents to be hurt or killed. But I do think that is the exception and not the rule.
It would be nice, Misha, if people made all the right decisions and we all treated one another according to the golden rule. Things in the real world don't work that way, though. No matter how good of a job you do in a high speed situation, you never know when your luck is going to run out. When you also consider the fact that, most times, you don't know why someone is running...well how can you expect a person to make the right call when they almost never have all the information they need?
Maybe at some point. Right now, it still takes boots on the ground. And when it is a satillite, who knows, maybe it'll zap the wrong car or something. Nothing will ever be perfect. When people act dangerously, they endanger others. I don't think a different technique will ever change that. Especially if it's someone crazy just out to cause mayhem (rare, but it's happened).
Six of one, half dozen of the other. A cop involved in a high speed chase doesn't know why a person ran, the only thing they can know is that they did run. I had a friend who used to be a cop who was injured in a high speed chase while chasing someone who kidnapped a teen right off the street and was planning to rape and kill her. When the chase became dangerous, should the cops have called it off?
The fault here doesn't lie with the police who are doing their sworn duty. The fault lies with the scum who run from the cops and put us all in danger. There are some attempts to use air assets like helicopters to keep track of fleeing suspects. Hmmm. Perhaps General Atomics can whip something up similar to the Predator that law enforcement can use. If they can drop the cost low enough for even small departments to use them, it might become a viable alternative to high speed chases.
"I had a friend who used to be a cop who was injured in a high speed chase while chasing someone who kidnapped a teen right off the street and was planning to rape and kill her. When the chase became dangerous, should the cops have called it off?"
Yes, absolutely should have called it off. How many more people need to die?
That might seem cold to you but how did your friend know what the bad guy planned to do?
Even if her being murdered was the end result he couldn't have known it would end that way.
It is actually, because it recognized that you're not thinking of other people's protection, regardless of what your words say. So, enjoy.
You have to assess the risks involved. This guy wasn't just some punk vandal or even someone carrying paraphernalia, this guy proved he was willing and able to snatch someone from the street, rape and murder them. Given the level of threat this guy posed to the population, I have to disagree with you, the cops were justified in chasing him down.
Nah, high speed chase is akin to using a machine gun in a crowded mall. Unprofessional, to say the least.
Wow! I find myself in agreement with both Jim and Misha in the same post - nearly.
When the chase becomes dangerous, the cops should break it off UNLESS they know that the risk of letting the suspect go is greater then the risk to the public who gets in the way of the chase.
...no...even when they are just at the beginning of a pursuit, accelerating with sirens on...not everyone can hear or notice at first...and some don't get out of the way fast enough...i kind of cringe when i see them moving fast at intersections....wouldn't take much to hurt someone....and then of course those trying to get away are moving fast and don't want to get caught...big risk takers.
I don't think it is worth the risk...anytime. My 'pop' was a cop...and was hurt in a chase....flipped his vehicle and all that....chasing an escaped convict.
High speed chases are dangerous and irresponsible. I would rather the criminals escape slower, which they will if they are not being pursued at high speed.
Well I'm not sure but if the police weren't involved, high speeds probably wouldn't be attained. I think all miscreants should have governers on their cars to limit their speed.
I would take a more Monty Pytonish approach and make a law that says all those avoiding the police must ride bicycles.
I feel sure they would comply!
they should just shoot a tracking device onto the car and as back up have a helicopter follow the car too. i don't think they should chase at all. i heard once that some police departments have something they can shoot at the front of the car to zap the engine into shutting down. to me those methods would be better than doing 100 or more and risking a lot of innocent lives, but the cops are just to hot for those high speeds, sometimes they're as bad as the criminals.
We have specialized air units in most departments and there should be a new procedure written. Response by air as needed "case by case" seems reasonable to me?
by RealityTalk 5 years ago
Should police be allowed to commence high-speed chasesI was watching HLN today & they brought up a chase in Florida where a driver suspected of DWI was chased by police at high speeds through the streets. A former police officer/commentator for HLN commented "there is always some...
by lady_love158 7 years ago
http://biggovernment.com/wshughart/2011 … amanomics/Okay I know Obama is a harvard graduate but if he is really that smart where does he get his bone headed and ridiculous ideas?? This is latest nonsense... people in the USA don't take trains and to ride this boondoggle will likely cost more...
by GERALD-710 3 years ago
Why doesn't the United Stares have high speed rail?The Europeans, Japanese, Chinese and many developing nations have high speed rail, why doesn't the US develop a high speed rail system?
by paradigm search 3 years ago
I figure this would be an excellent thread for people to find out if they are being robbed blind or not. I'll start.$30/month here. Verizon DSL. I'm actually somewhat fond of them. How about you?An update caused by the posts I've seen so far. My bandwidth is unlimited, Verizon never even brought up...
by Takako Komori 7 years ago
Would you ride the high speed train in California when it goes into effect?There is a plan to build high speed rail service between L.A. and San Francisco. If you would use it, why? If not, why not? What are the problems you see that would hinder the rail service from becoming successful?
by missyb3666 7 years ago
How to handle a dog who chases cars?I am attempting to help a friend who has an 8 month old GSD that likes to chase cars. I have observed the owners with the dog and there are definitely alpha issues. At this point, I have only suggested that they correct the dog while walking her. (ex....
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|