This is a problem since the forums get to heated up or are very in apropriate.
I wrote a hub about my grandparents and their wonderful relationship in response to a hubmob challenge so it was automatically catagorized. and when this feature was pointed out to me I checked and there is a link to a forum thread about what to do if your husband doesn't sitisfy you in bed.
This feature in my opinion should be removed.
There are some not so nice links attached to my hub about my grandchildren as well.
I've noticed the same thing, I also dislike this feature. A lot.
Agreed. I have even emailed hubteam about these forum links in hubs. I wish they would remove this feature altogether. It is not useful at all.
When I was writing my latest hub I saw the related hubs on the right side and was glad for that. Then as soon as I hit the "publish" button, the related forums capsule showed up and the related hubs disappeared.
Where does one see the links? Is it at the bottom like RSS or in the text?
I never even noticed the link to forum threads - is that new? I agree with you all, I don't think it's necessary at all and should be removed, especially when the potential exists for links to inappropriate banter.
Links to other hubs is enough. The forums are irrelevant.
No it's been here for awhile. I've had some really nasty titles show up in the Home and Family category. I just emailed HP and they moved the topic who the sandpit.
Lately I've found safe categories and I just bury all of my hubs into those. I try to go deep into the category to get away from the main ones which is where I've found the most problems.
But if you want to post in Health or Gender and Relationships it's going to be a bit scary at times.
You email them for that? That option is built into the report button also "wrong forum category"---> "suggest a category"
It seems to work, I use that button a lot in the knowledge and help forum threads and the are usually moved very quickly.
I just wish the system kept up w/ the thread creators who consistently cant figure out that their thread belongs in the sandpit and eventually revoked the new thread option for them
Especially considering we all have to showcase "related forums" for some daft reason,
why anyone want to divert traffic from a hub to a forum-especially from a monetization standpoint is beyond me
Yes I email them for that when the forum title is totally disgusting and I'm furious. Other times I just use the report function. If I'm really aggravated I use both.
Depends on the level of frustration.
But as I say, I've adjusted by limiting my categories.
Thats a good thought, But I dont see why related hubs and related questions wouldnt be sufficient.
Directing traffic to the forums would have substantially less advertising in the visitors face and with all the drivel that is usually showcased..just cant understand the motivation.
I think your solution is well thought out, but its a bit of a shame that you have to resort to that since you lose out on a couple links from the category pages...minuscule issue, sure, but why should a writer be disturbed by the "social" element
..I would hide the forums and questions as far away from visitors eyes as possible
I agree sunforged. HP staff can see the big picture and maybe not many people leave the hub for the forums.
I'm more concerned about adsense targeting and the perception of the hub by the customer. And I can't see how some of these titles conform to Adsense TOS.
This may be a daft question but can traffic from search engines see these forum 'quotes' or just signed in Hubbers? I assumed that it was only the Hubbers ... I suppose if I sign out and return I will find out.
I just assumed they appeared when people where signed in. If it is shown also to incoming traffic how can people take the Hub writers seriously when some of the clipped 'quotes' are unsuitable for the hubs subject. I am off for now to check this.
tuesday, yes, anyone can see the forum posts. you don't have to be signed in to see them, plus anyone's hubtivity is open.
that does makes me think that I will pick my categories with extra care. I have two hubs that I put non-commercial on because I did not want unsuitable ads. appearing.
Just another thing to consider when setting up a hub I suppose. I find picking categories confusing anyway, sometimes none of them seem what I am looking for.
The worrying thing is that some of the 'odd when out of context quotes' are not in the forums that you would expect to throw up quotes that might seem strange next to a hub.
I would prefer the two were kept separate - Hubs and Forums. As it is some traffic might just leave because of a forum quote and not bother with the hub next to it that would have otherwise interested them. Thanks RebekahElle.
Hi Dao Hoa,
Looking at a page with a hub on it -
the profile picture is top right
now scan down and below the question box and above the tags is the forum box - with the quotes and links to them. hope I have explained that right.
One would think it was better to promote related hubs over related forums to generate revenue to the site as well to the writers.
I kind of look at the forums like a break room in a factory, nice for the workers but you sure do not want your customers in there!
I wonder if the staff could be persuaded to re think this feature or at least give us the choice of opting out if we want to.
by Phyllis Doyle Burns22 months ago
I fail to see the need for the "related hub" section on each of my hub pages. Sometimes these hubs do not really relate to mine. Readers come to our pages to read the hubs we wrote or because they like...
by Dr. John Anderson4 years ago
This issue has been raised many times in the past – but given the 20% drop in traffic it should be rectified urgently (good enough is no longer sufficient (IMO)Links to unrelated pages is something that Panda and...
by Simone Haruko Smith4 years ago
Last week, we announced on the HubPages blog that we are giving Hubs a makeover, and that the new Hub layout will be first tested in the Fashion and Beauty category.I am happy to say that the change is now live! Stop by...
by Marcy Goodfleisch23 months ago
Do you have ideas on ways HP could improve the site or its usability in the coming year? No flaming, please; hoping to have some serious and helpful suggestions for staff to consider.Please share your ideas on:...
by Carolee Samuda2 years ago
I did a little experiment with opting into the EC program for three months. To begin with,last year one of my better performing hubs become Editor's Choice. That hub was getting an average of 20o+ views per day, peak....
by Lorelei Cohen8 months ago
I have seen a few mentions of putting our articles into groups but when I went to put in a heading I found myself stopping because I wasn't sure what to put there. Do we go broad categories ie: foodie:healthOr use...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.