When a stray cat is sick, vets always say the humane thing to do is to put it down. The same thing often goes for if you have an elderly dog or cat. Put her down. End her suffering. It's the humane thing to do.
These animals don't get a choice. They don't get to decide that they want to live a few extra months or years, even if it is in pain. The vet says its the humane thing to do, they get put down.
So why is it inhumane, immoral, and so wrong to engage in assisted suicide? These people are sick, at the end of their lives, have no chance of getting better, and are choosing to let go. They are making the choice that an animal doesn't get, and yet we take that from them.
I think one of the issues is that animal lives aren't valued. Even a sick animal that could be cured is often put down under the guise of being humane when it's just convenient.
Also, humane lives are valued entirely too much, to the point that if we can keep an empty shell of a humane alive for 10 years by attaching it to a machine, we will do so. Is this humane?
So what is humane?
Its a tough one. I think euthanasia should be an option for people who want to die with dignity and I think they should be allowed to end their suffering but its an emotive issue that others strongly believe should not be accepted in any situation. There was a High Court case here in Ireland recently about a woman who was in the final stages of Multiple Sclerosis and she wanted to be able to die with dignity she said. The Court said while they sympathized hugely with her they could not let her win the case because it would open the floodgates and what may seem moral in one case might not be in another. She died only recently of natural causes from her illness but it was tough she could not choose her own time.
Its a hugely religious issue too i.e. we are told animals don't have souls but humans do and only God should be allowed to choose when a human's life will end. Still that's not helpful to you if you want your suffering to end and you are not a believer of God. You are being governed by people who are mistaken as far as you are concerned and yet there is nothing you can do about it.
I think an individuals right to choose is the humane choice, but we are a long way away from widespread agreement on that one unfortunately.
Most people do not consider assisted suicide based on rational and informed choice to be inhumane. They either feel it is too difficult to reliably get rational and informed choice, or that suicide is forbidden by God.
Interesting. I can see the religious implications, but in countries which supposedly have freedom of religion, I don't see why it should be an issue.
As a side note, I just realized that I spelled "human" as "humane" every time in my original post. Sorry, I was tired.
by SomewayOuttaHere6 years ago
I looked through a few threads for discussions around either topic. If anyone can direct me to a discussion - thanks.If not? do you have comments on either technique - pros and cons. would you want either or...
by Dave Mathews4 years ago
JOHN:15:13 tells us."Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends."The churches today are quoting this Biblical Gospel Quote to substantiate and advocate for DNR ( Do Not...
by SheMis7 years ago
What is everyone's opinion on "assisted suicide"? Do people have the right to make that choice and should they be assisted by medical professionals?
by Dave Mathews5 years ago
Abortion and euthanasia, and suicide all require a cessation of life. For abortion it is a requirement for the cessation of life of the fetus. For euthanasia and suicide, it is a requirement by an already living and...
by Deborah Sexton6 years ago
I watched the new 2010 movie about Jack Kevorkian on HBO. "You don't know Jack" One of the statements they made was that "If a person goes into a coma, the hospitals are allowed to pull the plug and allow...
by Laurel Rogers5 years ago
Dr. Kevorkian, infamous for his assisted "Suicide Machine," died Friday after a brief illness. He was 83 years old. "Doctor Death" was a zealous supporter of assisted suicide and came to the...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.