We all know that it is against Google's terms of service to link to sites that sell firearms or ammunition.
While it may be "fine" to write a review of a shotgun, or what have you, it is at the same time a violation to link to a gun dealer's site...even for an image credit.
So forth, and so on.
Here is my question:
Just now I denied someone's comment on my hub about twelve gauge shotguns used in deer hunting because the comment included a link to some firearms auction.....would that comment, had I left it there, be in violation of Adsense TOS?
If not...is there anything clear as to whether or not such links in the comments on a page...get the page penalized by the ...all seeing eye of search engines?
Hey Wesman, I don't know about it affecting the adsense part of things, but I deny any comments with promotional links because I heard it was frowned upon by HP. Sorry I couldn't answer your question better.
You did the right thing by denying the comment that links to forbidden topics. Adsense TOS explicitly states:
Sites with Google ads may not include or link to:
Pornography, adult or mature content
Content related to racial intolerance or advocacy against any individual, group or organisation
Gambling or casino-related content
Illicit drugs and drug paraphernalia content
Sales of beer or hard alcohol
Sales of tobacco or tobacco-related products
Sales of prescription drugs
Sales of weapons or ammunition (e.g. firearms, firearm components, fighting knives, stun guns)
Sales of products that are replicas or imitations of designer or other goods
Sales or distribution of coursework or student essays
Content regarding programs which compensate users for clicking ads or offers, performing searches, surfing websites or reading emails
Any other content that is illegal, promotes illegal activity or infringes on the legal rights of others
Or to any page with an unsupported language.
I personally do not allow links in my comments that do not add value to my content. For the most part, I only allow links in my comments that point to other hubbers hubs and then only if the content is related. I delete any comments that point outside of my content to unrelated topics.
I think it would best best not to allow in comments what is not permitted on the page. I would not trust a bot to know the difference between the two.
Absolutely true... I'll add though that unless you are running on your own site where you can noindex your comments... the comments that are allowed to remain become part of the content... It is dynamic content in the same manner as RSS feeds that is constantly changing and being crawled by the SE's.
It is one of the main reasons why so many bloggers put the noindex/nofollow attribute on their comments, the comments section can run havoc on your page if left unattended.
I've noticed for a while that fresh comments on my hubs tend to spike the traffic a bit. I'm just not the sort of web comprehending guy to know how to find out some facts about it...just an observer of what I've done, etc.
Thanks for making it clear to me how I need to delete spam comments of my blogger blogs.
You follow suit of the best course of action. Links to sites selling firearms is forbidden, and therefore should not be allowed, otherwise, the WHOLE HubPages community could suffer.
I have a link to a heart website on a comment from a doctor who liked my hub on wearing apparel for winter. She wants to know if I want to put a link on their website. Is that OK? Wesman. you did the right thing. It can get confusing.
A link here and there to unrelated content is not going to hurt you. What hurts is excessive link exchanging (hundreds or even thousands) where there is a 'I will link to you if you link to me' type of linking scheme going on. Also, allowing links to bad properties can hurt, not only your page but also your entire subdomain.
Just remember, the comments here on hubpages are part of your overall content. There is no signal to the SE's that tell them content ends 'here.' Dynamic content should be related to the overall content of the page... this is the reason hubpages took away the Newsfeed RSS capsule and other RSS capsules. The feeds were delivering unrelated content mostly because they were being used incorrectly. Dynamic content is content that changes on its own or content that is constantly updating. It is good to have this since the SE's see something new each time they crawl. However if they 'see' something thing that links to a bad neighborhood or other bad behavior, you will get penalized.
Best practice is to not allow active links in your comments without first following them to make sure the content is relevant or adds value for your readers.
Brakel: I have done that for people if their website pertained to my content. For example I did an article on sea glass jewelry due to a website I had seen. I placed the link to her website, she made sea glass jewelry in my article.
by Paula 7 years ago
I am curious what you think about people that post links to their other sites (hubpages or others)?I have been getting lots of comments but that have links to my hubs, and it seems they are trying to promote their stuff on my pages. I am curious what you think about this and others as well....
by Eddie Carrara 6 years ago
Is it OK to put links to other hubs in the comment boxes?Sometimes I want to point a reader to another hub of mine where I know they will find the answer to their question. So is it over promotional to add a link to another hub of mine in the comment box. I have done it in the past and haven't had...
by Rajan Singh Jolly 5 years ago
When one has hundreds and thousands of readers, how does one manage to read their hubs?And keep a track.
by BaliMermaid 7 years ago
If a visitor to any given hub makes a comment I believe that's a good thing. But what if that visitor leaves a link, usually embedded into their name, to another website or another hub. Thsi has happened a lot and generates a lot of questions in my mind.For example; If the hub is on back pain and...
by Laura Izett 7 years ago
Do you accept or deny comments that leave a link to someone's website?I don't mind people leaving a link to one of their hubs but I don't know about people leaving a link to their own website.
by Faith Reaper 4 years ago
I know that it is against HP rules for someone to place a link in a comment of a hub, but is it okay for someone to place a link in a comment when answering a question, even if it directs people back to their hub? Also, it seems to be okay to place links in the forums' comments, as the link...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|