Like many Hubbers, I use Amazon product images when I'm writing about a product, as allowed by the Associates operating agreement. However, I'm wondering if book covers and album/CD covers fall under the same license.
The difference (to me) seems to be that product images were created by the company for the sole purpose of marketing the product, while a book or CD cover is often a work of art in itself, created by an artist. If the band or author is only using the cover image under license from the artist, it seems strange that that license would be transferable to Amazon for use by Affiliates.
I guess maybe I don't fully understand what rights an artist is granting to a musician or author when they create a cover. Does Amazon really have the authority to grant affiliates the use of these cover images?
On the other hand, in the very links Amazon provides they use the image of the album or book cover, so there must be some leeway for the sake of commercial use and advertising the product.
I'm interested in your opinion on this, especially if you know what you're talking about. Thanks!
I've used a few album/CD and book covers in by hubs as graphics not linked to Amazon as an affiliate. I don't think most people will have a problem with it unless you use it in a derogatory manner. Whether it's a graphic or simply text, if you bash the artist you could get sued for defamation of character or whatever it's called. I used album covers for my hub about hippie music as main graphics and sourced them to the record company that released the album. I feel comfortable with doing that. Give credit where credit is due and most people won't complain because it's free advertising for them. On the other hand, if they don't want you to use it, they'll see you gave them credit and be nicer when they contact you to remove the graphic from your page. At least that's what I found the one and only time I had someone ask me to remove the graphic from my old website.
I was unsure of this grey area as well, when I wrote a book review about Poland. I opted to scour wiki-commons for actual photos and art concerning Polish culture, instead. I was even fortunate enough to find a creative commons photo that was very similar to the cover art on the first edition of the book!
I have been hesitant to write any more reviews, though, before finding out more about using book related art in such a hub.
If you are being swayed by the notion that there is such a thing as 'album art', think again. No such thing. So morality is not an issue.
There is only the law.
Is someone going to sue you for forcing people to look at some terrible PR photo, or pretentious CD cover? Not impossible but very, very unlikely.
In some music genres album art is indeed very important, at least to the fans. For heavy metal bands in particular there are some artists who are very well known for their album covers. While the mainstream may not consider them artists, they and their fans (and the bands they create covers for) certainly do. Legally I would not want to compromise their work, but out of respect for the artist I would not want to do so ethically either.
However, I get your point in some cases. But I'm still unclear on to what extent, legally, Amazon is allowed to extend their license.
If I'm understanding your question correctly, the Amazon link is for purchase of said product, correct? If so, of course the image is going to be used, and Amazon is selling the product, and a picture of the product is implicitly allowed for use of sales and marketing.
That's my logical line of thinking as well, but when it's artwork created by a 3rd party . . . or 4th party, I guess . . . it seems like maybe there's more to it.
The company which produced the album owns the artwork on the album cover. Typically, it's produced under a 'works for hire' copyright, which means that the artist never owned the copyright personally. If the product is on Amazon, you are free to use the image if you an Amazon affiliate selling the product through Amazon.
There's a case from a couple of years back where a photographer sued an artist for creating a derivative work of a Miles Davis album cover, for which he (the photographer) apparently owned the copyright. So, while it seems to make sense that a record company would want to own all copyrights to album art, it may not always be the case.
Obviously that case is much different than what we're talking about here. I suspect the crux of it is probably as you said, if Amazon is making the image available to affiliates it's probably okay.
I'm not familiar with the case. It sounds like artist was selling a piece of art that too closely resembled the original to be an "original" itself.
http://www.techdirt.com/articles/201106 … y-up.shtml
I'll have to spend some time reading it.
However, this has NOTHING to do with your use of Amazon images designed for selling a product as advertisements to sell said product on your hubpage articles.
As far as I am aware no one on HP has ever been sued for copyright breach of any kind. People get their hubs unpublished for using images inappropriately but that is the worst that has happened so far. In the circumstances, I would risk it.
I should point out that big stock photo concerns like Getty can be really nasty, so avoid their images.
I can remember a guy coming to the forums about a year or so ago, all panicked because a photographer found out he used his photo illegally and hit him with a bill.
The guy didn't understand he was violating the photographers copyright by snagging a photo he found on Google search and using it in his Hub. Eventually the photographer was kind enough to work it out with him.
Also, I don't sleep so well at night as it is, and the fewer things I have to worry about the better.
Eric needs to decide whether he should trust the ultra-responsible person that he was raised to be, the drunk, or the guy in the hoodie.
It was a cold day on the Oregon coast after a 200 mile motorcycle ride, what would you suggest I wear?
A self-declared drunk should not be your fashion consultant.
I suppose that's true. A hoody, while not my favorite garment, is quite a good thing to have on a ride because once you get where you are going and take your helmet off, a simple adjustment of the hooded sweater you are already wearing keeps your ears and head warm!
Also related to the subject, your own pictures of vintage album covers and or record labels, 8 tracks, what ever I believe fall under the fair use guide lines, look at eBay for instance, that's actually selling vintage items with photos, for nothing but commercial intent that the artist doesn't even earn from, apparently that's OK. I Believe if the resolution is lesser than the stock copy you are OK.
This leads me to believe technically the Amazon images are OK to use as an affiliate, but if you used those photos just on your own, you could run into problems, even then would it not fall under "fair use"? If I did an article about Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon for instance, and used a high resolution photo, I believe this would still be covered under fair use.
The main point is, you are not supposed to hinder the original artists ability to earn from the original. You could make the case that an article would enhance that ability and not hinder it.
The fair use doctrine is vague and open to interpretation, I guess it boils down to who is doing the complaining and who is enforcing a take down. Take what I just said with a grain of salt, I am not a copyright expert.
It is a convocation.
Now we just need someone to sit on the papal throne for the ritual examination.
I have been writing very commercial stuff for many years and if anything smacks of a PR photo then it is fair game, as far as I am concerned.
A photo of an album cover that is being used to the sell the album is a no different to a photo of a toaster that is being used to sell the toaster.
Forget the 'album art' crap and sleep well.
Good enough, and everyone appears to agree with you.
If anyone has a dissenting opinion I'd like to hear it, but otherwise I'll move on.
Thanks for everyone's input!
I once had a publisher tell me to take down the cover art of their book from a blog post I made about the company (a not very positive one). My response: go for it.
They never did anything about it. The cover is there to be the public face of the book. Therefore it is used widely and no sane publisher will object to that.
Hi guys. This 'How To Use Photos Legally' is freaking me out. I promote authors and books. The authors provide me with their copyrighted material themselves. Now, what about all those ads running on the hubs? Will I still be able to monetize my hubs if the author or owner of a particular photo personally gives me the go-ahead to use his/her photo/book cover/whatnot?
I wrote a Hub about how to use photos legally, it's a bit simpler than the HubPages official version but it still meets the legal requirements. You'll find it in the slider on my profile.
Provided you have the documentation to prove you have the author's permission, you can use their photos in your Hubs. Just caption the photo accordingly (i.e. copyright photo used by permission of the author).
Thank you so much Marissa! Okay, I'm scooting over to that post of yours.
by Ceres Schwarz 10 years ago
Hello. I've read the learning center guide on proper image use. I understood the topic well enough but what has me confused is the subject of fair use. From what I understand from reading the guide on image use, fair use lets one use copyrighted images for review-based hubs. Is this...
by Christophe Vaille 10 years ago
Does anyone actually make money with the Amazon Affiliates program? If so, what's the key?I've been hubbing since last April, and haven't had a single person purchase anything via my Amazon listings. Other hubbers claim to make money through their Amazon Affiliate listings. Is it just a matter of...
by Kate Swanson 9 years ago
eBay is changing its affiliate scheme in October and there is one HUGE change which has been sneaked in.Their cookie is now a 24-hour cookie, same as Amazon. For Hubbers, that makes eBay effectively worthless and I strongly recommend you remove your eBay capsules! Amazon will now be a...
by Mark Ewbie 11 years ago
My little pic is the stickman gunslinger...On a real CD!I have had a very good day.No. I'm not suddenly rich or famous. But I remember what "happy" feels like.The CD is by someone called Clay Harper (of the Coolies) - he's on Wiki! Oh yeah. He did ask me to draw it...
by SunSeven 12 years ago
With regard to Amazon's cancellation of California affiliates, will HP continue to let hubbers who live in other places earn from that affiliate program by keeping the Amazon capsules on already existing hubs or will you do away with it altogether and bring in alternative revenue streams?ebay...
by Bev G 5 years ago
You wouldn't take someone else's writing, so why do so many of you think it's okay to steal photographs?A photo or work of art is a creative endeavour, the same as a piece of writing. Therefore, it usually belongs to someone. HubPages is a commercial site. One where you hope to earn some money,...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|