I just had the strangest form of editor snipping. It wasn't Amazon, since this was a new hub, and I had used the topic template as a guide. Instead it was the capsule where it is suggested that you introduce yourself as the gardener (on a home and garden template).
Why would the template suggest we write something into a hub, and then it gets snipped? I find that both strange and frustrating.
Does this mean no one should trust Hubpages own templating suggestions?
What I'm really asking is for greater clarity, Shouldn't we be able to use the template as a trustworthy guide? I think perhaps those guides should be updated to reflect present expectations. Thanks for listening.
We absolutely recommend talking about your expertise, training, experience, etc, with the subject you're writing about. However, such an intro may be snipped if you include things like links to your personal blog or social media pages, in which case it is considered overly-promotional. Those links belong in the link section of your profile page, not on individual articles.
I understand, thanks. It wasn't just a link, but the entire content and photo that was snipped. I did have my moniker imprinted on the photo of myself. Is that considered overly promotional?
And on this topic, I have a garden site, which is informational, not a personal blog, and it is always penalized by editors, so I don't even link it now.
We do advise against using watermarks on images on HubPages. A good rule of thumb is that your paragraph about yourself should establish authority. (For example, you'd want to include your professional qualifications like if you worked at a nursery or had a degree in botany, if you'd been gardening for years, if you participate in gardening groups or clubs, etc. It's ok to mention that you run your own popular gardening blog or website, but we advise against linking it because the bio should never appear to be promoting anything.)
The content in question related my gardening experience with the fact that I had grown those particular plants and the way they performed well for me. There was no mention of my site or the fact that I blog or even my writing here on Hubpages.
Not to pursue any arguments about fine points, I do think the conflict between what the official template advises and the zealousness of the person doing the snipping is where there is a rub. I didn't actually watermark the picture of myself, but decorated it with my identification. I guess that could b considered a watermark of a type. The whole matter is quite arbitrary, and that creates unnecessary work for Hubbers. If it was only the photo that was a problem I would think that would be the only thing snipped. I am not invested in having this portion of the hub published, but strongly believed I should not have been lead to add it by way of the template calling for it.
Thanks for all the feedback.
by Ghaaz B3 years ago
While I was creating a hub, I read that all source links for images will count towards determining if a hub is overly promotional. Are they checked and confirmed by staff, or just automatically detrimental to hubscores?...
by Mary Craig5 years ago
Wouldn't it be nice if some explanation about the hub came with the above mentioned notices. All you get is the general notice that you hub is overly promotional or substandard and it needs to be fixed. If...
by Paul Deeds6 years ago
As predicted in yesterday's announcement, we've rolled out some additional warnings on Hubs today. The new warnings that appear are detailed below. Enforcement of these rules is currently schedule to begin...
by Daedalu7 years ago
by RanaKm3 years ago
So, I've had a hub unpublished due to HP claiming that it's overly promotional.The hub only has 2 outbound links ( which is the number of links we're allowed to put for the other external sites ) this is the only thing...
by Novel Treasure3 years ago
I just logged in and it shows every single one of my hubs highlighted in pink, to need review. The majority of these were well trafficked and featured hubs or editor's choice. Did something happen? I tried looking in...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.