jump to last post 1-3 of 3 discussions (5 posts)

How many of us give constructive comments?

  1. myownlife profile image40
    myownlifeposted 5 years ago

    How many of us give constructive comments?

    Do you think we make constructive comments on the hub or have we ever give negative comments so that specially new hubbers can learn something,  or learn how to write readers writings.

  2. boundarybathrooms profile image89
    boundarybathroomsposted 5 years ago

    I try to point out spelling and grammar mistakes, but in a friendly way as not to offend. Every writer should be equipped to take criticism though, and if new writers aren't prepared to do so then they're unfortunately not going to make it far as a writer. You have to be pretty thick skinned.

    1. myownlife profile image40
      myownlifeposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      boundarybathrooms, yes that is really true, none is born perfect, so let's polish each other, and let's be an idol family of hubpages, I always expect comments, pointing out the mistakes that drives me to the right path ahead.
      Thanks for your time.

  3. dlegendre profile image61
    dlegendreposted 5 years ago

    I feel writers do give newbies only positive encouraging comments for the first 3-5 writes.  Then, let the constructive criticism come when the newbie has some sort of confidence and won't give up or feel stupid.  My attendance is somewhat sporatic because of summer, but I am finding that those who would criticize- in a good way- just don't comment..........yet.
    p.s. I think I had a typo on my first one but no one ever wrote about it.

    1. myownlife profile image40
      myownlifeposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      dlegendre, I have found great great comments so far, I know my hubs are not really great, trying to make it but for that I need comments true ones,

 
working