How does one know whether a comment left is spam related or not, other than the obvious?
Other than the obvious, when one goes to a hubber's profile page, one can tell if it is solely spam; however, if it is not obvious, how does one know? When HP asks one to decide if a comment left is spam or not, how does one really tell? Going to the person's profile page and they happen to have recently joined HP and have no hubs at the moment, should one approve a comment by that hubber? If one does approve a comment and it is truly spam, how does it harm one's hubs, if at all? Thanks for answering
I only ever had one comment that I thought was truly spam. It was a link to a totally different site and the person was a guest user.
However, on another occasion in the answer section, someone stated a very nice comment, and HP notified me that it may be spam. I had no idea why. I looked at the Hubber and it was a regularly active participant. I chose not spam and then the comment showed up. It was very strange.
In another situation, I recently had a new Hubber follow me. They left me fan mail. I looked at their 3 hubs and they were all well written. I followed them back to encourage their writing, and the next day they were banned by HP. I have no idea what happened.
Thanks so much CraftytotheCore! Yes, that has been my experience as well. I recently approved one too, as I saw they had a couple of well-written hubs, but then went back and they were banned? I do not understand it when it is a long-time hubber?
I have had a few comments which HP have notified that it may be spam. However these were hubbers I knew well.
I think if someone makes an unusual high number of comments (maybe catching up) the robot picks them up as spamming
Quite often if I have been away for a couple of weeks I will spend a day just reading and commenting on numerous hubs to catch up, so I wouldn't mind guessing that they may be spam suspects too.
Sorry I've not answered your actual question
But one way you may be able to tell is by going to their activity and checking up on just what they have been up to.
I doubt it would harm your hub
Yea and if it looks too generic like one size fits all. "great article, very interesting for another great article look at this ::::"
Thank you TFR and Eric... yes that would be a good topic for a hub.
Have a great Sunday!
I have to be honest, when in doubt I tend to go with my gut feeling
Sometimes people join only to leave comments. If they haven't left a link or other ad related comments I leave them. If I can't detect spam my readers probably can't either.
Having comments looks good on your articles, it shows people were moved enough to say something and that is always good for your rankings.
by mariexotoni3 years ago
I know there have been some trolls on HubPages and I have already contacted the staff to see maybe if they could help me with my issue.I have an occasional guest commentor.. His messages are disturbing, but I'm...
by Stephanie Henkel5 years ago
How do you react to hubs with comments disabled?As a hub reader, how important is it to you to be able to comment? Does it frustrate you when you are not allowed to comment on a hub? Will you still vote on that hub?...
by Robie Benve5 years ago
Hello, I found three comments to two different hubs that were already marked as spam when I went to see them. At first I did not notice, until the hubber that left one of the comments left another one saying "sorry...
by Laura Smith3 years ago
Hi,One of my Hubs has been showing comments from different people that are unrelated to my post. It seems to be entire discussions going on about another subject. Is anyone else seeing this?
by WeddingConsultant9 years ago
Just something I'll toss out there as it was new to me. I debated where to post this thought, but figured hubber hangout would be a good place.When approving comments this morning I came across a spam comment on my how...
by James Paterson5 years ago
My Hubs seem to be the target of spammers tonight, anyone else having the same problem?, thank goodness hubpages is recognising the spam before it gets published.....jimmyMaybe catchpa for non members?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.