I published an article on suicide. I thought the ads were off until it gained more traffic. But I just checked it out and it appears that the subject matter falls outside of the TOS?!!?? I had no idea. Staff and veterans, please clarify.
Is this helpful?
https://support.google.com/adsense/answ … 8?hl=en-GB
Yes, chef, very helpful. I guess exploring the notion of choice when discussing suicide falls under "Advocating Suicide" under the category of "Dangerous Content." Sigh. Not my intention, I'm so bummed. But I hope the information gets families talking and the resources help those who need it. Thanks for your help.
When writing I always bear in mind that our articles are supposed to be acceptable for children to read. Topics such as suicide, abortion, etc are never good choices, regardless of how helpful they may be.
That's sad... This is what happens when one policy has to fit everything. Not HP's fault, it's an Adsense issue.
Yep, I have two articles that are about the difference between self-harm or thoughts about suicide and these symptoms in OCD with the focus on OCD. One of them is my second highest in terms of views by tens of thousands of views and the other one usually is about fourth or fifth with tons of views as well. Ads off due to content = lots of lost money. Oh well. I had several more planned but decided not to do them because I knew it would be the same story. Sorry your article is in the same boat but at least you only did one
Thanks, Natalie. That's great your articles are informative. I do hope I can provide information to a lot of readers, too. I think I stocked my article with enough information so I won't need to touch this subject again.
Natalie, I looked for your articles but couldn't find them on your profile page. I wanted to know if they were accepted onto a niche site?
Nevermind, mine just got picked up for Owlcation.
There's this one https://owlcation.com/social-sciences/S … ion-in-OCD - which is always second or third in terms of views and this one, https://owlcation.com/social-sciences/W … Obsessions which is usually in the top 10 for view. Both are on Owlcation.
I never thought about it before but even though HP says they want articles to be family friendly they still put these types of articles and lots others on niche sites - they just turn off ads. So it's doesn't seem that they're really trying to be family friendly they are just trying to appear that way to google by having these articles fly below the adsense radar.
I thought I'd made a previous post here, but it is gone.
At any rate, I no longer attempt medical articles; too many obstacles from everywhere.
Yes, now I know the hard way. Now I'm curious about how writers on sites like WebMD, Medscape, MedicineNet, Mayo Clinic and Psych Central get paid it they write about topics deemed "dangerous." I did have a hard time finding articles on the topic for my research.
They are not monetised by Adsense.
I wonder how they are monetised. I don't think WebMD is monetized but I know PsychCentral is. Are they ways to determine how a site is monetized? Just wondering in case I want to create a website with content that adsense might not be friendly to. Thanks
After a quick look at both sites, it looks like WebMD and PsychCentral sell their space directly to advertisers. Maybe they use other avenues as well; I didn't look too far into it.
As far as Google goes, it is my understanding that HubPages goes the extra mile and interprets Google's guidelines very conservatively so that there is no possibility of any violation. For example, AdSense rules say that they will not advertise on any content that glorifies suicide. Jan's article does not glorify suicide, but HP chooses not to place ads on any article concerning suicide, so that there is no possibility of even the appearance of a violation. I hope an HP staff member will correct me if I am wrong about this.
Right. Mine certainly don't glorify suicide either, but I get they don't want to risk even the possibility of a problem with adsence and google. It's not worth it and could shut down the whole site permanently.
Thank you, smartandfun for more understanding of how this works.
While it sucks on your end, it is important to remember that Google must make advertisers happy. If advertisers refuse to show ads on suicide-related topics, Google has to submit. They wouldn't risk losing big advertisers.
They already lost some due to YouTube related issues and their response was to moderate hard.
Update and question:
My article on suicide gets no organic traffic. I understand the rule about the ads. My question is does Google not index the article that has no ads because it's not advantageous to them, i.e., it makes no money? No money for HP either if no one is clicking on the article.
Lesson learned. I initially said "oh well" at least those who need the information will see the article even if I don't make any money on it. But now it looks like NOBODY can see the article if Google doesn't allow it in the search.
Please advise and/or enlighten. FYI, I changed the title to see if that would help and it hasn't budged. I know there is a need for this information out there but if nobody sees it . . .
If it is featured, then it should be indexed regardless of the situation with the ads. There may be a whole lot of articles about suicide online, and so that may be why you've yet to see Google traffic.
I wanted to mention one thing to you I recall from years ago. Personal experience here. You shouldn't ever mention rape, or use that word. 'rape.' That will kill your advertising instantly. At least it did to me once a long time ago.
by Sally Gulbrandsen 7 years ago
If we turn off HubPages Ads and replace them with one Amazon Ad would our ability to earn decent money be compromised? Would we still earn from Adsense? Could someone please explain the different scenario's to me so that I can better judge and understand which option is better for...
by Andrew 14 years ago
I was refraining about talking about this but it really is bad. Last month with adsense was my most profitable month, but this month so far I got 3 clicks...What could have made this change?-New Hubpages Layout?-April 1st Conflicker Virus? I was thinking these two things can't be so harmful to my...
by Pamela Lipscomb 10 years ago
I was kind of frustrated with my earning for a while. Since last Feb as a matter of fact. Last month I decided to block Google certified ads and my earnings a up 100 last month. I would be really interested to know how this works for other as well. I also blocked...
by Dorsi Diaz 13 years ago
Something just occured to me, not only are we writers here but we are ALSO CONSUMERS. I see nothing wrong with clicking on a fellow hubbers google ad if it's something we are interested in. I am getting the feeling that some people are afraid to do this for fear of reprisal for being click happy...
by Disillusioned 13 years ago
Think of this.People say, content is the king in Hubs (or anywhere where you write articles and aim to get Adsense revenue).If I write a good article containing rich info on the subject, people will read it, get the info they wanted, appreciate it and go away.But if I write a "keyword"...
by westcoastwife 8 years ago
Heads up to those applying for an AdSense account! After publishing about 10 hubs I applied for an AdSense Account and was declined due to the standard lack of content. After publishing 16 hubs, I reapplied and was hit with with the following warning as I was about to leave the HP site...
Copyright © 2023 The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers on this website. HubPages® is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website.
Copyright © 2023 Maven Media Brands, LLC and respective owners.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|