A true story.
A Saturday morning it was (04/13/2019).
Sitting there drinking my first cup of coffee of the day, I decide to visit one of my extinct profiles. There it is with its one-and-only hub; unfeatured due to lack of traffic it was. Though unfeatured, it was still published and the ads were happily dancing around as usual.
Meanwhile, Facebook had been poking me with a stick and waving a $10 ad credit at me. I bet you see where this is going...
"Let's resurrect this hub and profile!" thinks I.
So I do some minor changes and update the critter. I check and though under review, it is still happily published, etc.
Off to Facebook I went, setup and fired off the ad.
After Facebook had displayed the ad to 20 people, I decided to revisit the hub.
HP had removed the ads from the hub. Yep, gone. Hub still published and still under review; but all the ads were gone, gone, gone. So there I was paying Facebook to advertise a hub that would earn me no money.
Now here is where the rant-to-end-all-rants would normally begin, except for one tiny detail. The number of engagements by the Facebook viewers was precisely zero. In other words, the hub ads suddenly disappearing hadn't cost me anything; nobody had showed up yet to see them anyway; not to mention I was using an FB coupon to begin with.
Needless to say, I immediately shutdown the FB ad and am using the remaining balance of the FB coupon on one of my website articles instead. It's really too bad; could have been a resurrected hub, profile, and all that.
I did not know that we were allowed to put Facebook ads on a hub. Have you done it before?
A clarification. It was an FB ad on FB. The FB ad on FB advertised the existence of the hub and then included a link to the hub when a person clicked the FB ad on FB.
I see, have you done it before and if so, was it successful?
Yep, done it before. In answer to your second question; even when HP doesn't suddenly remove the HP ads from your HP hub, the FB "Boosting" still isn't worth paying for. I only did it because it was free; figured why not use the FB ad coupon to get traffic to the extinct HP hub/profile, thus resurrecting it. But when HP suddenly removed the HP ads from the HP hub, I gave up and decided to use the FB ad coupon to advertise something else.
Could the ads have gone away simply because the hub was under review?
An update. The FB ad on FB results so far: People Reached 124,
Link Clicks (to my website article) 3.
Looks like the FB ad would have indeed gotten my extinct hub and profile resurrected within a few days. Oh, well; it was HP that called it quits, not me.
Just curious if you have ever used adsense to increase traffic to a hub. I got one of those emails offering free adsense but on reading the offer could not figure out how to stop it if the article got too much traffic, more than the adsense was offering.
Yep, long time ago; back when free meant free. These days, the AdSense coupons I receive all say I have to spend $150 real money before I can have the $150 coupon money. Based on experience, it's not worth it; you'll spend more than you make.
Yes, you can turn the ads on and off at will. And you can make as many different ads for as many different hubs as you want.
Meanwhile, I have to retract the title of this thread. Maybe it is worth trying to resurrect dead hubs and extinct profiles. The hub that started all this is now featured and has ads. So I did a little SEO research and submitted it to a niche site. If HP thinks it has a shot at getting traffic, they'll accept it; if not, they won't.
Well, the FB ad is perking right along. As expected, am earning zero money from it; but I do believe the article is getting some long term benefits from it.
Just an update. My resurrected hub did not successfully sneak onto a niche site. I knew the SEO spin on that particular hub was iffy, but it was the only idea I could think of that might generate some traffic. Oh, well. The amount of labor to resurrect that hub to featured status was not that much. I knew that the lone hub would never reach the HP Ad Program payout finish line, so I put it on straight AdSense with the others from elsewhere. All things considered and what with the labor to resurrect the hub being minimal, I'll consider just one AdSense click (even on the HP domain name) as break even and anything beyond that as pure profit. If I ever do get that one AdSense click, I'll alert the media.
I don't know what I make off of Faceberg views, but I know it's something. I'm at around 80,000 Faceberg views in total. I only recently started doing what I do there.
I join every last group I can find about the things I write about, and there are LOTS of groups, some of them with more than a hundred thousand members, and I post my links in those groups.
Easy and free. Lots of traffic. The traffic doesn't last too long, it's just big bursts of traffic, but I'm not the smartest person in the universe, and so, sometimes I get some VERY useful feedback from persons in those groups.
I do tons of sharing in groups as well with music articles. I had a page with 300,000 plus followers sharing articles for a while. I would get 20,000 paid views on share some days with residual views coming in for a week or so. With that volume it was nice, but it is gone now as the page is run by a tabloid guy with no morals who ruined the page. I still do ok sharing in groups here and there, but the pay is no where near a Google impression and seems to be getting worse.
Really? There is a difference between a Google impression and a Facebook derived impression? I thought each pageview was paid the same? How can you tell?
Yep, that's the common consensus. AdSense and Analytics seem to back it up.
According to HP staff (forum, do not have the actual qoute) the advertisers can tell where your traffic is coming from (search engine or social media) and will not pay the same for social media traffic.
There is somewhere you can look on analytics that will tell you how much of your traffic is organic and how much social media, as a percentage. I do not remember exactly where since I hardly ever use that program, so maybe Glenn, Brandon, or Eugene can comment on where it is.
That is sick. A pageview is a view. This is Google taking care of itself, forcing us to cater to them.
Maybe, but I think it is all of the advertisers, not just Google adsense. They have decided that those that come from search engines are serious, those that come from social media just want to watch funny videos and see the pictures. (I have no idea what twitter traffic pays, but I think it is probably the lowest.)
Well that all makes sense. If I'm typing search terms into a search engine, then it is MUCH more likely I'm shopping. I may have my credit card in my lap as I'm typing in search terms for this or that.
Social media is....social. I may click on someone's link merely because I like that person, and want to know or see, or just be supportive of whatever it is they're doing. I'm not feeling any obligation to spend money, as I'm only being social on a social network.
Ouch! I can imagine how angry you must have felt at the time. Good thing you stopped it in time before wasting the entire money on the fruitless ad campaign.
I just found this thread and see that the discussion includes the desire to know how much traffic actually comes from various sources, such as Facebook vs. Google Search.
You can see the percentage of organic search, social media, direct traffic and referrals in Google Analytics by selecting “Acquisition > Overview”.
Then you can further filter the data by changing the “Primary Dimension” on top. For example, if you change it to “Top Sources” you will see a breakdown of each individual source. Google, Bing, Yahoo, Pinterest, Facebook, HubPages, Ask, direct, etc.
Interesting note: In my reports I see that Facebook referrals don’t stick around very long. They click away quickly without reading. The view duration is much better with Google traffic. They actually read! You can see that kind of data in your Analytics report by going to “Acquisition > All Traffic > Source/Medium”. (Of course, your results may vary).
by Dr. John Anderson 8 years ago
I think it is related to images being used for the HUB ads and Google ads. When I turned off the Hub ads my adsense revenue rose significantly. I think it is because the block of adsense ads to the right of the column of text below the title returned to text based rather than image based. I think...
by Bible Studies 8 years ago
I got into an interesting discussion on another thread, and thought it would make a good thread itself. The question of the day is how do you feel about other hubbers clicking on an ad in your hubs?Personally I really don't see a problem with it as long as the ad interests them from a good quality...
by Shadesbreath 9 years ago
Ok, I asked about this before, but couldn't figure out where I'd seen it and nobody could tell me what it was due to my cluelessness, but here it is again on a hub I just published:So, where does that come from? Is that an HP thing? How do I get my hubs to show up in there? Do I have to get HP to...
by Ben Guinter 8 years ago
I'm curious if anyone has tested by a month to month basis whether or not you make more with Adsense alone or with HP Ads?It's impossible to do a true split test, since each month will be different, but I'm curious to hear your results...Some of us won't get a lot of traffic so Adsense might be...
by Janis Leslie Evans 4 years ago
What percentage of your traffic is due to Facebook?I wonder if I would do a lot better if I was on Facebook (socially) for marketing my articles. I have a business fb page for promotion purposes and use it for posting new articles but the return is minimal. Do you depend on fb for the majority of...
by Julie Johnson 5 years ago
I need advice. I have both the HP Ad Program and my own Google Adsense ads on my one Hub. I haven't earned a thing from the HP Ad Program, but I'm earning on Adsense daily. I'm wondering if I should get rid of the HP Ad Program ads completely so more Adsense ads will show. Is this a good plan? If...
Copyright © 2020 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|