.. to put in summaries that have no connection with the topic of one's hubs, but is more searched for and of more lucrative keywords?
Is it ok? I couldn't find anything related to using deceptive summaries.
See this http://hubpages.com/search/include:hubs+top+10
Anyone doing that could really screw over the rest of us.
Am I missing something? Why would you want to write a Hub where the keywords would only appear in a summary? This is mind-boggling to me. It defeats the purpose of writing a Hub.
Bad idea. You'd definitely be penalized by Google. Keyword stuffing has always been looked down upon, but the big G has been cracking down even further in recent updates.
I don't know that I'd call this keyword stuffing, just deceptive (as the OP alluded to). Like, in a summary, "10 ways to whighten your teeth at home," and the Hub is about using Clorox on your bathtub. I don't get the thinking here, at all.
Click on the OP's provided link. HP needs to start kicking butt and taking names.
Actually, if that's a real HP return on a search for "top 10", then HP needs to take a look at what it's returning in its search results.
HP's searcher works just fine! It has just shown us a whole bunch of fraudulent summaries that need to be dealt with.
One of the most ridiculous things I've ever heard. Why would you do this? So you can piss readers off? All they're going to do is bounce right back off your page when they realize the content is not what they're looking for. This gives Hubpages a bad name and us along with it.
I was just getting ready to start a new thread when I saw this one.
For those folks who haven't already noticed. Google is taking us at our word and using the summaries as the description. Formerly google was randomly picking something out of the page text, sometimes it was even the text of a comment and nothing from the article itself.
I guess what I'm trying to say is, “Don't phone it in when you write your summary.”
I'm guessing you're thinking that more searched-for keywords would lead to more page views, and so higher earnings from the Ad Program (and possibly from Adsense too, if people click on the ads anyway - despite not meaning to be there in the first place).
I'm not sure if there's anything to stop someone from doing this, although if there isn't then perhaps there should be. It seems completely dishonest and would be misleading and annoying for the searcher. And as paradigmsearch says, it wouldn't be good for this site.
Maybe you're asking this because you've seen other people doing this and wondering if it's allowed, rather that thinking of doing it yourself?
Paradigmsearch, is that why we're being reminded to write summaries for all our hubs? I wondered about that. Knowing what you've told us, I will take care to write them for the rest of my hubs. Thanks.
Surely if the searcher searches for holidays and sees a title that is about fractions they aren't going to be interested? And vice versa.
Therefore - I can't really see the benefit to the author.
My theory is that they know absolutely no English at all, and their master told them to add this summary to everything.
I can't see how it works on any level.
edit: hmmmm. Strange hubtivity too.
You're right that there would be a discrepancy between the title and the summary in Google, and that should give people a clue that there's something dodgy going on. Maybe if someone wants to scam people in this way they would also use a misleading title. (Although sometimes when I'm using Google I'm a little blind to the titles, as long as my search words are contained in the summary - maybe other people are too).
Either way, the aim is to get people to view their page and earn them more money. I guess that's the benefit to the author. (Obviously no benefit to the reader though. )
Just wanted to pick up on what you said, (I know it's going off the main subject, sorry about that!). But I just tested a few of my hubs in Google, and it still seems to be using wording from my hubs as the Google summary, rather than the summary that I've put together in HP. For one example that I tried, it took the wording from one of the links at the bottom of the page.
So maybe this change hasn't come in yet. Or maybe it's just me, lol. (??)
Subdomain specific maybe? If so, then google really is at least partially (if not more) classifying us by subdomains. In other words, hub A affects the ranking of hub B in that same subdomain. Me thinks I'm going to go do some more clean-up work.
I did a few more, and for some it uses my summary and for others it doesn't. Weird. And interesting.
If you could ascertain if there are any other causative factors in addition to what Sally said, it could be very interesting indeed! Age of hub for example, number of comments, and who knows what else.
There are so many factors, and I'm learning from everyone's thoughts, experiences, and opinions.
One thing I'm sure of, this is not a day-to-day game. There is no instant gratification. If you want to write here and see consistent financial rewards, then be here for a year or two or more and set your sights on the long-term, not on the short.
In the past, long before the emphasis on writing our own custom summaries, I noticed that what the searcher saw under the title of your hub was dependent on the search terms they typed.
It seemed that the long tail searches simply found snippets of text that had the long-tail phrases, and the searches that used your main keywords displayed the summary created by HubPages when you published your hub.
I don't know how it works now. In the last few weeks, I've just started to write my own summaries, so I know that Google hasn't caught up with my changes yet.
By the way, I'm finding a good custom summary is very beneficial for my traffic.
It takes time for G to pick up new summaries. And more time for them to be populated in such places as Facebook.
Er.. to be more charitable.
The guys got 500 hubs, a lot of which are about travel. He gets the call from HP that everything must have a summary. He cuts and pastes... 500 times. I wouldn't be able to read my own stuff after the first 100.
I just know if I was searching for something and the blurb had nothing to do with the topic I would be very angry.
Ah thanks Sally's Trove, that makes sense. It's probably just the case then that it's using my summaries that I wrote a while ago, and still picking out bits from my hub, for the summaries that I didn't do very long ago (as G hasn't picked them up yet).
I think what Sally said could well explain it, but will have another look tomorrow. Off to bed now.
I wonder why those hubs are not moderated as these could hurt the neighboring subdomains? Just my doubt.
The fact that the OP used the phrase, "deceptive summaries", kind of made me wonder; because I'm not sure most people who engage in that kind of thing would describe it in their thread the way it has been described here. (Most of who engage in deceptive behavior, and don't talk about it, don't use words like "deceptive" to describe it. Anyway, I fell for the bait and clicked on the profile. This person claims to be experimenting (and probably is).
Either way, it's a good example of how use of words/phrasing/grammar (etc.) that don't match the behavior/persona of the person writing can make a reader "wonder" (and sometimes make a Hubber go looking for what might be "flaggable"). But that's a subject for another thread...
Paradigmsearch, I was going to say that whether or not Google uses my summary or snippets from my hub, in some cases, seems to depend on the words on which I search. Then I noticed that gracenotes has explained this a lot better in her post above mine. Thanks gracenotes, what you've written is really interesting.
As I am gradually changing my summaries to all be my own, it's really difficult to tell which ones Google has picked up and which ones it hasn't. It might be better for me to experiment further with this in a few weeks time, (or however long it usually takes for G to catch up with these things).
by SmartAndFun 7 years ago
Is this common? On the Google results page, just under the title of my hub, Goodle is using the first sentence of the hub instead of the summary. (Yes, the summary is there on the hub, I checked.) Are summaries just wishful thinking on my part? Is this just more of Google playing hard to get and...
by Johanna Anderson 7 years ago
I have published two hubs, and both of them have lost points for not having summaries. I'm not against writing a summary, if I can do it without simply being redundant. Would you be willing to critique these and give concrete examples of what good summaries would look like?Another...
by Lisa HW 10 years ago
Does anyone have solid tips on the best way to optimize the summaries? Mine have all been automatically created (only because I didn't know there was the option to create one), and they look like they're essentially the first paragraph of the Hub.Is it better to have, say, a one-line summary...
by Raye 4 years ago
Please do something to the filters so that Hub summaries as graphically-cluttered as the below can be found. This can't be helping.
by Susette Horspool 5 years ago
Boy, now I'm really confused. Our hub summaries (just under the title) are supposed to be what shows up as a description in Google searches, right? So I just launched a new hub. It's reading a 94 hubscore right now and is not an Editor's Choice (yet). Here is what my summary says:"When it...
by Wesman Todd Shaw 8 years ago
I'm finding that the Custom Summaries do improve traffic as they were said to do.I want to know, however, from the folks who do get good traffic on their good hubs still, that recently created a custom summary - how many words should this summary have? Of course putting search terms/keywords...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|