I'd be interested to know what others think about this one:
I published a new hub this week - 100% original, high quality and with zero external links on the page - however, it has failed to get indexed in search from what I can see. My articles usually get indexed pretty quickly, almost immediately due to sharing on social sites and use of RSS feed etc..
However, this one didn't... ;-)
All I can suggest is that it is because it is written about network marketing - I won't post the link here but any of you who are interested in reading or reviewing it (or trying to find it in search) can find it on my profile page easily enough.
I may be wrong in jumping to this conclusion but it seems that even though I have followed HP guidelines and written an article that has been approved something odd has happened to sink my ship even before it has set sail...
Can/Have hubpages decided to close the door to the search engines for specific terms in order to remove any/all association with what (for some reason) they classify as dubious content??
Look forward to your insights ;-)
I've always been told that it takes a while for a new hub to be noticed and therefore rise to the top. Perhaps you have been lucky. My other thought is that this is probably a widely written about subject so it may take a while to be noticed? I seriously doubt that HubPages has played a part in this.
I'm not talking about it being noticed or indeed rising to the top of search - this will take months for this keyword as it is highly competitive - but the hubs I write (I've been writing on here for around 2 years) are usually indexed within 24 hours - some within 5 minutes - this one has been online almost a week and is nowhere to be seen.
When you build your own blog you have the option to close the search engines to certain pages - this is easily done in order to hide pages/content/visitors etc - and can actually benefit your overall site some believe.
I have traffic to the article from several sources BUT not Google... tells a story perhaps??
Neil...you are obviously much more experienced in this respect than I am. I did not even know one could "close search engines to certain pages" etc. So good luck with your query and hope you find out what is happening and that it is to your satisfaction.
I am new member I think some expert Hubber will sure answer you about this problem.
And I think personally it is taking time to indexed now Hub by Google in two or three days.
I doubt that HP has closed any doors to the spiders.
Like you, I usually see hubs indexed in a day or two, but I have also had perfectly good hubs take as long as six weeks to index, and 1 week isn't all that uncommon in my experience.
In another thread, several hubbers report that Webmaster Tools is showing widely varying traffic from the crawlers in individual subdomain. My own went from around 300 per day to 20 and is now rising again; this will certainly affect time to index.
Patience; if you build it they will come!
Side issue; I didn't read it, but if your hub is about MLM (for which I have seen "network marketing" used) it will probably be checked thoroughly by HP. As a whole the subject is mostly taboo here, although a very well written hub without links or promotions might go through.
The hub has been passed and you are correct, network marketing is now taboo (or at least promotional material in that niche is).. this article is not promotional at all - in fact all the articles I have published in this niche (around 40) are non-promotional/informative so it is a little frustrating to have to go through this with each new hub in this niche.. I guess that's a fair price if the sub-domain is ranked well - which it is on most occasions.
It takes time for your hubs to be indexed and if the market has been flooded by the same information, having your work found on google could be a bear. As far as HP blocking search engines. I don't think so, wouldn't be great for business.
The only way Hubpages could close the door to your hub is through robots.txt.
Here is the robots.txt http://hubpages.com/robots.txt and there is no category blocking going on.
I agree with wilderness, it will be YOUR subdomain that's the issue. You need to work on your subdomain as a whole to bring it back again.
That's not quite correct. Every subdomain has its own robots.txt,
which could be used to block individual pages (but isn't in this case)
and hubpages could also use a noindex in an individual pages source code, but that isn't happening either.
My conclusion is that hubpages is not blocking crawlers to this particular page.
Thank you for your comments - how have you come to your conclusion that this isn't the case out of interest?
Because, as I said, I checked the most easy white hat ways for hubpages to block google crawlers from your particular page.
Of course, there are other ways that they could block your page, but these are all considered black hat, so Hubpages would be unlikely to use them.
My conclusion is hubpages hasn't done anything to block your hub.
Just to add, the idea that google necessarily has any problem with the page or with your subdomain is not likely to be true, either.
Google has just ran the panda algorithm. In my experience, pages that are added just before the algorithm is run often have delayed 'uptake' in terms of being added to the index.
My subdomain ranks very well - top 3 positions on Google for most of the keywords I have targeted in this niche until now - which is not why I questioned it but it would suggest there isn't a sub-domain issue here. Perhaps I'll just have to wait a few weeks as some of you have suggested before this begins to show in search..
The last time Googlebot visit your subdomain was "This is Google's cache of hxxp://neilashworth.hubpages.com/. It is a snapshot of the page as it appeared on 24 Aug 2011 02:37:32 GMT.
Today is 3 October so the bot has not visited your domain for quite some weeks.
Now like I said, it is your sub-domain that needs to get the attention of the Googlebot. You cannot get a page indexed unless Googlebot comes and has a look at it.
Your subdomain does not rank very well. Sure you have a few keywords but there different articles. Think of your sub-domain as a whole. It is your subdomains authority that you need to build for quick indexing.
Very interesting that since I posted this question 5 of my articles have now been unpublished by hubpages:
100% unique content
No external links
Looks like the flagging police are out in force again.. nothing better to do I guess.
by Elsy Chapmon 6 years ago
I have published my articles, all are featured,But none of them can be found through search engines.I wonder is featured hubs auto send to Googlee?
by Silver Rose 7 years ago
See this article where they say they are experimenting with staff accounts:http://www.squidoohq.com/2011/09/13/wer … -accounts/I think they are prompted by the fact that HP appears to be slowly moving out of teh Panda penalty (albeit with some accounts seeing wild movements). Here's...
by Audrey Selig 6 years ago
When I first signed up with GA I used hubpages.com Later I added my subdomain address. However, my account is set up with property name hubpages.com and default URL my subdomain. I believe this is incorrect. Thus Webmaster Tools are saying that my sites are not verified. What do I need to do?...
by Sherri 8 years ago
I was sorry to see that this forum thread was closed to comments by HP:http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/78912#topThere was a lot of good information going back and forth there. It may be that some snipe stuff went on between commenters, but the topic is still valid.I'd like to see it continue.
by Tony 6 years ago
There appears to be some changes with the "problem" with google indexing some hubs under our domains and others through hubpages.com."suddenly" webmaster tools are showing that my pages are now indexed under my subdomain rather than through hubpages.com. A search for "site:...
by Dr. John Anderson 6 years ago
About 100 of my pages dropped from the number of pages index shown in webmasters tool on 7th of April .I also have noticed that some pages appear in the SERP results without showing my subdomainThis hubhttp://janderson99.hubpages.com/hub/Mar … Adventuresappears in the SERP results when you...
Copyright © 2019 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|