I just got my first-ever negative comment on one of my movie review Hubs. This person left a long rambling message picking apart everything he felt was wrong with my review. In a nutshell, since I didn't shower the movie in question with praise, he decided that I must not be a fan of that particular film genre and therefore I was an idiot who had no right to be reviewing the film in the first place.
Wow! My first troll! I feel like, all "official" 'n' stuff now.
I deleted the comment but now I kinda wish I hadn't. It might have been fun to leave it up there and respond "Thanks for stopping by, Zippy. By the way, bite me."
How do other folks deal with negative comments like these? I'm just idly curious.
You can still bring it back I believe. And I agree that you should do so.
For movie reviews, I'd encourage the more opinions the better. And if they vary, so much the better.
I have had any yet. But it really would depend on the definition of 'negative'. I usually welcome both, but if it is as you 'trollish' in nature, I would have to delete that and report it as being abusive. Negative should also be accompanied by 'constructive criticisim' not attacks on your character. There are rules that should be followed. Hope this helps.
That's what I do when a commenter leaves scathing words, but with maybe a little extra like, "It's always interesting to hear another's view."
I ADORE the negative comments people make!!! I guess as a gay Jewish man I should expect the bible thumpers to tell me I'm going to hell and the homophobes to tell me I don't have the right to live. I thrive on all of these comments.
It takes a certain type of person to type hate into their computer with their semi-anonymous screen names. I call them the "cheetoh's stained finger set" - I can see them in their parent's darkened basement at age 45, with their laptop on a tv snack tray as they type their brand of hate at the world into their computer in between reaching for another cheetoh (and we all know how that orange gunk can get all over so can you imagine their keyboard?)giving them a momentary feeling of power.
Take heart, a lot of people may read and move on, be thankful for those who leave comments (good or bad) at least you know you "reached" them in some way!
I just ignore them, it's not like anything anyone says here will impact your life after you walk away from your computer. The world is full of bullies, let them say what they want, but don't let them bring you down.
I got a whole batch of negative comments after I wrote a hub where I was venting about a nine year old girl stealing my nailpolish. I was ticked off at the time about how the parents treated me and vented and published. I think a lot of the people might have been friends of the family. I chose not to approve most of the nasty comments, but let one come through to which I defended myself about the comment. After a little bit I chose to delete those hubs as I was sick of the nasty comments and figured I would benefit more from hubpages if I took them out. But it has inspired me to write my new novel that I might self publish someday. Maybe in a few years. Got to spring for a new computer now and pay off my nasty credit cards first then in a year or two I should be able to swing the basic price for self publishing.
Everyone has an opinion and you know what they say about opinions right?
Haha, ain't that the truth! I knew I was in for it when I got the e-mail from HubPages about the comment, cuz it said "Garbage Review From A Non-Fan, Idiot" (yes, that was the name he used) left a comment on your Hub..." I was like "Oooooh boy, that can't be good." Haha.
And an inflammatory movie review opinion can draw other differing inflammatory opinions. The more text and the more traffic, the better.
Yeah, I thought of that, but if there's a way to restore that comment, I can't seem to figure it out. Oh well. Maybe this guy will start stalking me in all of my other reviews and telling me off in them as well.
Depends how long ago you killed it.
http://hubpages.com/my/hubs/comments?co … ter=Denied
Uh-oh. I remember my first bad comment - it made me so sad!! Now if I get a negative comment that doesn't offer valid points for disagreement but only tells me how stupid I am I try to get some digs in without being too much of an A-hole. That way it makes me feel better to give the other person a hard time - but then I don't offend my other readers by coming across as unwilling to accept actual criticism. THEN I always thank the person for stopping in
You could add a note that if anyone disagrees with your review that they are free to write their own
@ paradigmsearch - I've been fooling around with that function for a couple of minutes now... but it's not coming up with anything. I guess too much time has passed and it's gone. Ah well. He used some not-very-family-friendly language in his rant anyway, so it's probably for the best.
@ Uninvited Writer - not a bad idea, but it would be more satisfying for me to simply say "Bite Me, Zippy." haha.
@ Ardie - you always "thank the person for stopping in?" That's great. Kill'em with kindness huh? You're obviously much nicer than I am. Haha.
I would have kept the comment. I think a comment like that would give your hub some excitment and encourage others to leave comments reviewing the movie, especially if they disagreed with your commentor. You could get some nice banter going in your comments section, which of course is more text and keywords for your hub. With movie reviews, that is the nature of the beast. Some will love the movie, others will despise it.
Believe it or not, my hub with the most comments is the one where I review my kid's water bottles. Some of the commentors absolutely hate the water bottle and have no problem speaking their mind. Others love the water bottle. I have left every single comment on the hub. The funny thing is even with the negative comments I still sell quite a few bottles.
Yes, I Agree with Janet21. Take the good with the bad. It will all make a great mix and you will be the winner!
I have just created a forum suggesting a solution to deal with fakers on hubpages.
I will earnestly request everyone to make a visit: http://hubpages.com/forum/topic/85543
Please share you views if you think the solution will help every hubber.
Well I wouldn't take it too personal. Trust me, people will always disagree with your opinions on movies whenever you review them; regardless of how much work you put into it. Hell, I still find myself disagreeing with a lot of film critics from time to time, but I've also agreed with them as well on other movies.
Besides, I'd probably just take it as a compliment that your review could inspire that much passion from a fan of the film to begin with. After all, not a lot of reviewers on here are lucky to get a lot of comments...hell, I'm one of them. However, I think you'll be fine. Just don't take it too seriously whenever someone says something negative to you in the comments; unless they threaten you, then you might have something to worry about. Other than that, I wouldn't worry too much about it.
by DanPowers 8 years ago
Hi all,Do you ever get negative comments posted on your hubs? Do you block them or put them up in the hope that stirring up some controversy is good for your hubscores?P.S. My last negative comment was from someone commenting on one of my Asian dating hubs - she obviously thought most Asians still...
by Pamela N Red 6 years ago
Do you leave negative comments from readers on your articles?I delete spam but have left comments when a person doesn't agree with me. However, I have noticed I seem to be in the minority on this because when I've left a comment disagreeing with a person (this is not just on HubPages but on blogs...
by Nicole Canfield 4 years ago
Do you all ever get soooo many negative comments on a single hub that you just get tired of dealing with it? If it was all positive comments that wouldn't bother me, heck I even like a good debate from time to time...but to have hundreds of comments from random people trying to shame my writing or...
by Anne Harrison 3 years ago
What do people is the best way to respond to negative comments which offer no constructive criticism or feedback?)
by Tina Siuagan 6 years ago
How do you handle pesky comments in your hub?
by johnnyco12 4 years ago
Do you approve negative comments that readers make about your hubs?It's great to have readers compliment your hubs, brag on you for a job well done,but what those about those readers that disagree with you on what you've written written or have less than constructive criticism about your writing...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|