jump to last post 1-44 of 44 discussions (45 posts)

Do you leave negative comments from readers on your articles?

  1. Pamela N Red profile image85
    Pamela N Redposted 6 years ago

    Do you leave negative comments from readers on your articles?

    I delete spam but have left comments when a person doesn't agree with me. However, I have noticed I seem to be in the minority on this because when I've left a comment disagreeing with a person (this is not just on HubPages but on blogs elsewhere as well) they are sometimes deleted and not answered.

    I am not a disagreeable person or troll and I'm not disagreeing just for the sake of argument but sometimes if I have a different view on an issue I will leave a remark to that affect.

    I believe everyone has a right to their opinion and unless it's offensive or abusive I do not delete them.

    https://usercontent2.hubstatic.com/6172915_f260.jpg

  2. BeatsMe profile image65
    BeatsMeposted 6 years ago

    Most of the time, I leave comments that disagree with my views. I even give back an answer. But when a comment seems to be insulting or sarcastic. I delete them with no second thoughts. The thing is, you've spent time writing your articles, you don't deserve to be insulted. Rather than create an argument or debate which for me is a waste of time, just delete them.

  3. Wayne Brown profile image84
    Wayne Brownposted 6 years ago

    Unless it is a purely personal attack on myself or one of my readers, I will probably post it.  I would likely do the same if someone is critical of my work given their points are reasonably well taken.  I am not here to agree with everyone nor have them agree with me.  I do believe HP provides an arena where we can hone our writing skills and make our points as to how we believe.  When the exchange turns to nothing more than personal attacks, it has lost all value to anyone there. Sadly, from that, nothing improves and no one wins. WB

  4. lburmaster profile image82
    lburmasterposted 6 years ago

    Yes. It is important to see the pros and cons of each subject. Even if others don't agree with you, it is nice to learn from them. Unless they are commenting on your writing instead of the subject of the hub. Then it's war.

  5. Curiad profile image78
    Curiadposted 6 years ago

    I agree with you Pamela N Red, I leave the comments unless they are rude and abusive. Fortunately I have not had any I needed to delete here at HubPages. I also answer every comment.

  6. imatellmuva profile image82
    imatellmuvaposted 6 years ago

    I leave the comment(s). The Hub isn't necessarily for anyone to agree or disagree. If they agree...fine, and if they don't it's still fine.

    I do agree with other answers here that if a comment sounds abusive, insulting, or argumentative than it's worthy of deletion.

    For me worthy of deletion , does not necessarily mean that I will delete the initial comment. It could mean though that if someone returns, and repeatedly with biased behavior, then I know I have the POWER of the delete button.

  7. hospitalera profile image71
    hospitaleraposted 6 years ago

    I would be a hypocrite not doing so as I like to leave critical (not abusive!) comments on other hubs if I think that helps somebody!
    I am also very grateful if somebody points out a factual mistake, typo, misspelling etc  I made. What I can't cope with are people that read the first ten results on Google and then feel qualified to write and article about said topic without having any real knowledge about it.
    Don't get me wrong - Different opinions are fine!
    It is factual mistakes and outdated info that gets to me, especially if I know something about a topic.
    So quickly, de-friend me if you don't like my love for clear facts with a sound proof!

  8. hoteltravel profile image72
    hoteltravelposted 6 years ago

    If the negative comment is said in the right spirit, it should not be deleted. It makes sense to have different perspectives of the topic. Prospective readers of the hub will find this more interesting than a single person's view on the subject. After all, when we write a hub, we try to promote our viewpoint alone. However, if the comment is in rude, abusing or insulting language, or personally attack either me or one of the previous commentators, I would delete it without hesitation. I have seen this happen with other hubs, but I am fortunate not to encounter one of these.

  9. Lisa HW profile image72
    Lisa HWposted 6 years ago

    Sure.  As long as they aren't crude and/or something I don't want showing up under my name and/or account.  I like debate and discussion when negative comments are civil.  When they're not; besides adding dissent to the Hubs (not such a bad thing), they can add some interest.  I have a Hub aimed at junior-high-aged kids, and that one frequently gets stuff like, "b-o-r-i-n-g" and "fjkeidjngfle"  (LOL   LOL)  I post them all, but sometimes have to delete a few when they build up to the point of detracting from the page.

    However, in the interest of full disclosure, I've had to disable comments from a lot of old Hubs, and have them mostly on the most recent ones.  After a few years, I discovered it can take too much time to have to keep going back and re -visiting stuff I wrote in 2008.  I don't want to allow un-moderated comments (that can be a disaster to clean up), and I can't not-respond to people who post comments - so I had to trim some of the comment boxes down.

    What I worry about, though, is that my appreciation of offering other perspectives to a discussion could sometimes be interpreted as "a negative comment".  I'm always polite and kind of take it for granted that people know it's "all in the interest of discussion" - but only some people see things that way (even if it's only mentioning a minor point of mild disagreement).

  10. DzyMsLizzy profile image98
    DzyMsLizzyposted 6 years ago

    I have left comments that do not agree, however, I generally delete comments that indicate the writer is  totally clueless, stoned, or else is not a person but a spam-bot..

    Those would be comments that are so "out there," that it is obvious the person either did not read the article or understand it in the least.

    I don't care to have to "explain" the article in the comments...

  11. tirelesstraveler profile image81
    tirelesstravelerposted 6 years ago

    Completely agree with the theme that seems to be traveling down this forum.  Unless abusive and rude, you are welcome in my comments. Without differing points of view we can get really boring.

  12. kikibird03 profile image60
    kikibird03posted 6 years ago

    I think this is a great option Hubpages offers its members - the ability to accept or deny a comment.  So far, I haven't had any negative comments, but I've only got one hub out there and it's not controversial! lol!  But I have been on other forums where the topics run the route of politics or religion, and the comments some authors get stuck with and cannot remove can really detract from the quality of the comment section, whereas if they'd have had the option to not let the comment post it would have been nice. 

    If in that position, I would look at the intent behind the comment and the spirit it was done in. If the negative comment was someone disagreeing, but in an agreeable fashion, then I'd approve an opposing view.  However, if it was done in a malicious or hurtful way to myself or anyone else, I would be happy to exercise that option to not approve it.  I do not like childish name calling, or condescending mean spirited things because it does nothing useful for a forum.

  13. VendettaVixen profile image70
    VendettaVixenposted 6 years ago

    Yes - if the comment disagreeing with me applies to the hub and isn't just a random angry rant from a troll, I'd be sure to leave the comment unhidden.

  14. QualityContent profile image78
    QualityContentposted 6 years ago

    I don't leave negative comments unless I strongly disagree with the article. I offer my own opinions but keep the entire response constructive.

  15. Dubuquedogtrainer profile image60
    Dubuquedogtrainerposted 6 years ago

    Yes, if it stimulates discussion and doesn't detract from the topic too much or mislead or confuse people. But my primary purpose in hubbing is education.

  16. dashingscorpio profile image87
    dashingscorpioposted 6 years ago

    I leave comments from those who disagree with me. I find it interesting see another person's take on a subject matter.It also gives me the opportunity to further clarify my point of view or acknowledge the comment left contains some validity.

  17. Mary Stuart profile image80
    Mary Stuartposted 6 years ago

    I never have left a negative comment. I have thought negative a few times but never felt like raining on someone's parade. I guess I figure if someone took the time to write then let them be. I have left comments of disagreement but always respectful disagreement. I understood your question to be more along the lines of disrespectful or venomous comments. If that is what you meant by negative then the answer is no. I have never left an ill tempered comment behind. I leave lots of positive comments.

  18. Ironman1992 profile image61
    Ironman1992posted 6 years ago

    I do leave negative comments as long as they aren't hateful. Nothing is wrong with criticism.

  19. feenix profile image60
    feenixposted 6 years ago

    Because most of the 108 hubs that I have published on HubPages are what could be described as controversial, I have received a considerable number of negative comments from readers.

    However, I have never deleted a comment and I never will.

    I am not a cop. I'm a writer.

  20. qeyler profile image57
    qeylerposted 6 years ago

    Depends on the negative.  An opinion is that...You will find some Tea Party Members and other such types who will attack anything that in any way offends their views.  I leave their comments because they are self-revealing and often gain more comments from those who disagree with them. 

    I usually leave personal attacks because again, they are self-revealing.  What I will delete are ads, and the usual racist crap.

  21. loveofnight profile image79
    loveofnightposted 6 years ago

    I tend to allow negative comments but I personally choose not to leave negative them. I would rather not say anything at all and not visit their hub agin.

  22. modgirlok profile image60
    modgirlokposted 6 years ago

    It depends on if the comment is constructively critical, or just cruel. I don't want to perpetuate hate in any way, so if something is truly mean spirited I might delete it, although I would feel uncomfortable censoring somebody.

  23. Sherry Hewins profile image96
    Sherry Hewinsposted 6 years ago

    I have never denied a comment on any of my hubs. But I have not written about politics or anything too controversial. I did have a comment I made to someone's hub denied, which I thought was interesting because the topic was overtly controversial. It seemed like an invitation to a dissenting opinion. Anyway, I would not delete any comment to one of my hubs just because they disagreed with me, or didn't like my hub. I would deny it if was obscene, or broke some kind of HubPages rule. I also would never vote a hub or question down just because it didn't match my opinion.

  24. Thinking Allowed profile image60
    Thinking Allowedposted 6 years ago

    Unless it's spam or a troll, I'll leave it. I'm new to all this, so I haven't had to deal with this yet, but I have read and commented on other hubs. I recently read a controversial hub which can't possible have all agreement, yet it's comment section was a love fest. I didn't even bother to leave a comment 'cause I knew it wouldn't get through. I make sure to steer clear of writers like that and I don't want to ever be viewed that way. Make your comments, good or bad, I'll leave'em.

  25. profile image0
    Larry Wallposted 6 years ago

    Free Speech:
    That is one of the cornerstones of our country. I am rather new to this, but I have yet to delete any comment. I would only do so if I new the comment was completely incorrect or abusive toward any person or group--really abusive.

  26. FatFreddysCat profile image100
    FatFreddysCatposted 6 years ago

    I've only gotten one negative comment on a Hub thus far and it wasn't from a fellow Hubber, just some random troll. I deleted it but now I kinda wish I had left it up there, just so I could've responded "Oh yeah? Well, bite me, Zippy!"

  27. gardengrowmadeezy profile image60
    gardengrowmadeezyposted 6 years ago

    No, I don't. I think it is mean, just flat mean to leave a negative comment on someone else's article. We all are doing the best we can at any given time to express ourselves clearly, concisely and from the bottom of our hearts. At least I do and believe the best of others, unless and until proven otherwise. I am NOT saying I delete a comment because someone may disagree, we do all have our own outlooks and opinions. I can always respect differences of opinion. To me that is a different thing completely than a negative comment. To me a negative comment has absolutely zero benefit to anybody. It can't possibly make the writer feel better, purposely focusing on the negative. We always will succeed if that is what we strive for-finding the negative.
    As a new hubber, not knowing how to do many things very well yet, it really hurt reading a couple snarky (how I perceived them anyhow) comments on my ability (actually inability) to do something correctly (inserting hyperlinks-still don't have it down!). Input from an experienced Hubber on how to do it,would have been much more productive. The negative comments?? YOU BET I deleted them.

    1. LongTimeMother profile image97
      LongTimeMotherposted 5 years agoin reply to this

      gardengrowmadeezy makes a very good point. Encouragement is much better. But maybe if you'd left the comments, some other hubber would have stepped in and helped you.

  28. bankscottage profile image95
    bankscottageposted 6 years ago

    I haven't been doing this very long, but I do agree with you.  I would welcome differences of opinion in response to my hubs or my comments.  I have left one comment that I questioned the premise of the hub.  The comment has been approved, but I only left it earlier today.  We can agree to disagree, we just don't have to be nasty about it.

  29. Mercia Collins profile image71
    Mercia Collinsposted 6 years ago

    I leave negative comments on providing the comment is not rude, offensive or it is obvious that the writer has not read the hub at all or is under the influence.

  30. profile image0
    calculus-geometryposted 6 years ago

    I have a feeling we're only getting one side of the story with this question.  You say you are just leaving remarks "effect" that you disagree.  That is very telling. This makes me think you are leaving terse comments that say nothing other than the fact that you don't agree with the author.  To me, that's not something worth indulging, I'd delete that too.

    It's one thing to leave longer, thoughtful comments that EXPLAIN why you disagree, comments that actually take on some point addressed in the hub. But if you are just going around writing "no, you're wrong" on hubs you don't agree with, what's the point? 


    If you find that your comments are frequently getting deleted, while other comments remain,  perhaps you should look at it objectively to see how you can change your commenting style.

  31. dBrian profile image66
    dBrianposted 6 years ago

    I accept all comments (not just hubpages, but all my websites in general) even if negative.
    Now if the person is being disrespectful this is a different story, people have a habit of saying rude things online when they would never act like that in person. It is ridiculous... I delete spammy comments, and comments with no meaning that are just disrespectful. I noticed not many people accept comments that disagree with what their hubs are saying.. but I guess that's their choice to make so w.e.

  32. mirabea profile image61
    mirabeaposted 6 years ago

    comments are something like your opinion and we have the right to comment as the way we want to. if i disagree with some articles or topic i will not comment so much..negative  comment is the same as positive one....it is both needed to know your readers opinion so you can know what readers want

  33. profile image0
    jasper420posted 6 years ago

    Depends if there attacking me pearsonly then I delete it but if there simply in disagrement or making a correction then no everyone has a right to there opinon Im not ashamed of my work and never will be I respect others for being open and honest with me

  34. Peter Allison profile image77
    Peter Allisonposted 6 years ago

    I think that any serious writer will leave all comments up regardless - excepting offensive comments I suppose or spam. Oddly, even though I select 'un-moderated' on my Hubs, comments always seem to need to be approved. Anyway, I think it comes down to trust in yourself and your readers and letting the conversation take its natural course.

  35. maxweber04 profile image57
    maxweber04posted 6 years ago

    No probably it will harm your online profile authenticity.

  36. registerdomains profile image66
    registerdomainsposted 6 years ago

    Being open to all the viewpoints is a sign of maturity. Leaving all the comments (except spam) helps than hurts. All sorts of things will go in the mind of a hub reader, so having all the views on the hub is certainly an advantage. By leaving all comments, your hub cover most of the viewpoints regarding the topic which increase relevance very much.

  37. Tams R profile image85
    Tams Rposted 6 years ago

    I welcome disagreements which are not rude or distasteful in my comments. I dislike when someone attempts to stage what should be an entire blog post in my comments to make someone look stupid. Thankfully that hasn't happened to me yet.

  38. YvetteParker profile image76
    YvetteParkerposted 6 years ago

    Some of my articles have received negative comments. As of yet, I have not denied any of them and have allowed them to be posted. That's not to say that I haven't been tempted to deny them; I just chalk it up as people expressing their own views and thoughts. Some of the comments, although negative, can be helpful and I do learn from them. Others??...oh well!!

  39. Daughter Of Maat profile image98
    Daughter Of Maatposted 6 years ago

    The only time I really leave a negative comment is when the information in the hub is completely wrong as in some medical hubs I have commented on, or if the hub didn't make a logical argument. Sometimes when I see a hub without a logical form of an argument, I just can't help myself and I have to make a comment, but I try really hard not to be mean or condescending.

  40. pisean282311 profile image60
    pisean282311posted 5 years ago

    I entertain all kinds of comments unless those comments are abusive....I discard comments only if comments use foul language...

  41. ljrc1961 profile image82
    ljrc1961posted 5 years ago

    I do.  Although if the person is being very nasty, I make comment of it and ask them to watch what they say.  If they continue, then I don't allow it.  I give them a chance.  I think that stating one's opinion does serve to elicit more responses from other readers.  This can in the end, produce a hub that becomes even more interesting.  I do not allow however profanity or sexual over tones.

  42. Ciel Clark profile image74
    Ciel Clarkposted 5 years ago

    Pamela, I like this question and the answers that followed.  I have only been on hub pages a few days, not many hubs and no negative comments yet, but this is one of my favorite topics.

    I teach ESL at a university, and in the writing class I try to get the students to always show a little of the other point of view.  I think it makes your own point stronger if you understand the opposing views.  Sometimes my mind has been changed by a good disagreement, but more often my own thought processes were made stronger by debating the points.

    A negative comment is not useful and I might delete that, (unless I was curious enough to follow up on it) but an opposing/disagreeing viewpoint can be very helpful.

  43. sheilanewton profile image61
    sheilanewtonposted 5 years ago

    I agree with you Pamela.  We should take the good with the bad comments - and leave them alone.  As you say, everyone has a right to thier opinion.  And not everyone can LOVE our work, can they?

  44. LongTimeMother profile image97
    LongTimeMotherposted 5 years ago

    I don't have a problem with people disagreeing with me, as long as they are not offensive to other readers and are willing to engage in healthy debate.

    One place I would never post anything is youtube. I am stunned by how many rude and degrading comments are posted there.

 
working