Is Experience the best form of any education?

  1. shahkar-khan profile image60
    shahkar-khanposted 4 years ago

    Is Experience the best form of any education?

    Can a 25 year old (highly talented) chartered accountant equal to a mediocre (but highly experienced) chartered accountant?
    I am asking this question because I recently applied for an internship at KPMG, and this was the first (non-academic) question that was asked by the interviewer.

  2. kschimmel profile image46
    kschimmelposted 4 years ago

    When I was young, I would have said "Yes, of course!" Now I would give a more nuanced answer: No two accountants (or engineers or cooks or whatever) can be "equal" as in identical.  Really, you need both of them: the younger to bring fresh enthusiasm and a new pair of eyes, the older to know how to handle the weird situations and client relationships that one only learns to handle with repeated experience.

    1. shahkar-khan profile image60
      shahkar-khanposted 4 years agoin reply to this

      i said yes too.
      i agree that a corroboration of youth and maturity is a pre-requisite for any team to work well. "Professional skepticism" can be innate and is a nice weapon for any CA, but "Professional judgement" is what comes with experience.

 
working