Tiwan Strong Odds to Win American Idol
Can the Christian and Soul Singer Win AI?
Tiwan Strong is a singer from Racine, Wisconsin. He sings a capella,
Christian and soul. According to JoesPlacBlog, Tiwan has made the Top 40
for the 10th season of American Idol. The producers and judges pick a
Top 20 voting round (the semifinals), so he has only round left to the
get to that semifinal round. At this point, it is somewhat difficult to
assess Strong's chances on Idol. His MySpace music is Christian, but the
show focuses on mainstream music. He is definitely a skilled singer
and, depending on his personality, could make a run on Idol. However,
recent history suggests that he will have a tough time winning American
Idol.
Idol seems to be poor at casting certain types of
contestants. The casting of black men has been particularly troublesome
on Idol. This is probably not a racial thing, as the casting of females
has also been poor at times. Only guys in general seem to be cast well
on Idol, at least in the past few years. Tiwan Strong seems to be an
example of the type of singer that gets cast for talent but just doesn't
have much of an audience on Idol.
Those who do well on American
Idol don't necessarily have the same traits or styles as singers in the
business who succeed. Christian, opera, punk rock and hard-rock singers
certainly don't seem to be welcome, for example. And it's been clear
for several seasons that black males who are or are at least portrayed
as RnB singers don't fare well on this show. Yet, Idol just keeps on
casting them while never giving a hard rocker or an opera singer a
chance (even one who is willing to attempt other genres). There are
loads of pretty blatant, pathetic biases on this show.
The simple
truth is, if you are a modern RnB singer, the chances of winning Idol
are slim to none. It does not fit the demographic and probably never
will. By objective observers, it is clear that Todrick Hall, for
example, is an excellent singer and songwriter. And even he couldn't
muster a finalist spot for Season 9.
So the first thing Tiwan
Strong needs to avoid is getting cast as an RnB singer. I see the
potential to avoid that if he wants to and the show lets him. After all,
Tiwan doesn't really seem to be a modern-style singer. He seems to be
more of an old-school soul man. Although some voters would moan that he
is old fashioned, the truth is old fashioned is going to work better on
the show than modern when you are a black man. That's just the way the
cookie crumbles.
Perhaps the show is finally going to wise up and
let people be what they are good at being. If the producers give Tiwan
Strong the green light to do what he is good at (I suspect but don't
know for sure that he could excel at older soul songs), he stands a much
better chance than being cast as one of a long line of helpless modern
RnB singers. That casting spot is a death sentence on American Idol.
Tiwan should avoid dancing and other unnecessary performance gimmicks.
He should just stick to his soulful voice if he wants a chance to win
Idol.
Resources:
Tiwan Strong MySpace
JoesPlaceBlog Spoilers for Tiwan Strong and Season 10