What do you think of the recent music file sharing case where a jury ordered a man to pay $625,000?
This person could have simply paid .99/song. Instead, he illegally stole the music from the Internet and shared the songs online.
It's a ridiculous amount but the recording industry needed to make an example out of somebody.
Totally agree FatFreddy! I'm a recording artist, and the material I compose is MY property. I put my music on the Internet to sell. When someone steals it, it's akin to breaking in my house and taking my valuables . . . No difference between the 2.
I think the amount is ridiculous, too. Comparatively, if someone gets caught shoplifting, their restitution is usually the cost of the item they stole. Does this dude have to pay the money to the music companies he lifted the music from, or is that mostly fines?
Seriously, though, it has to stop somewhere.
The amount is ridiculous, but that's what happens. The law always uses someone as an escape goat to prove their point. So happens that it was this individual's unlucky---should say very unlucky day.
I think it is a another way to keep people from taking and not buying, a lesson out of the pocket!
I think the fine amounts are ridiculous. While I agree that he was breaking the law and he should be punished, the amount he has to pay is beyond absurd. $625,000 for downloading 30 songs? This is just corruption at its finest. In my opinion, he should have to pay what the songs cost online plus a fine, but nothing near 6 figures. We should all start recording songs and hoping someone illegally downloads them if courts are going to order offenders to pay out over $22,000 per illegally downloaded song. 3 illegally downloaded songs a year and you can live pretty comfortably.
I have been having this argument with people for years. There is an attitude that if its on the web, I can have it and do what I want to.
WHen we checked out real books at the library, and purchased LPs or eight tracks tapes, we would loan the to people. It was not practical to copy. Now, you download an I Tune, pay the 99 cents the make a 1,000 copies for your closent friends and charge 25 cents. In turn, they do the same thing.
I think the fine was appropriate. Once you steal an electronic recording, there is no telling how many times it will be resold or how many times the second layers of recipients will sell, thus robbing the Artist, the writers, the musicians and producers of income. I am not a musician in any way, shape or form. I have had people take some material I had written and called it their own and I did not like that.
I think the fine is outrageous, but it was not levied to him for downloading - it was the UPLOADING (file sharing) that they got him for. Illegally sharing music is the problem, not downloading it.
I have been downloading music for years. I have found out about many, many artists from doing this, and in turn have gone to their concerts, bought merchandise from them, and also (on occasion) full albums. If it wasn't for "illegally downloading" their music in the first place, I wouldn't have given them the money I had purchasing their other items.
And since artists make almost NOTHING on album sales (especially those that aren't at the level of U2 or Metallica, etc) then downloading their songs are only going to HELP them in the long run. It is that way that will lead to more ticket and merchandise sales, and that's where bands make their real money.
I know artists signed to major, international record labels who still make nothing on their albums, and are all for sharing their music and giving it away for free. It's called exposure, and that's how people find you. And people finding you is what is going to make you money.
Some good thoughts, Bob. You are correct in saying signed artists make a laughable % on CD sales. But there are 1000s of independent artists (like myself) who can't afford to tour. We indies are taking the brunt of file sharing, aka stealing.
by breathe2travel5 years ago
How do you know if you're downloading music or other files illegally?I don't understand how people can download music illegally -- as in the logistics of it. Once, a woman was sued for a substantial amount of $$...
by David Covey5 years ago
How do I build a file sharing and collaboration web site?Does anyone know how to build a web based collaboration and file sharing service similar to SharePoint using Visual Studio 2010 but without using a SharePoint...
by Fred Stein6 years ago
How Zimbra compare with Dropbox or Box.NetWhich, Dropbox or Box.Net is better integrated with Zimbra
by matata9 years ago
hi there im a newbie and ive just got myself a ps3 i have it working with wireless with my router but im trying to share my files of movies and music from my pc to the ps3 can anyone give me some solutions on how to do...
by Om Prakash Singh9 years ago
Hi all, It has been more then 4 months that I joined this community of great authors. I have published 14hubs till date and have been active enough in reading and commenting on hubs and on forum here. I have seen that...
by David Trujillo Uribe13 months ago
The World Wide Web has accomplished what politics hasn´t since the 1940´s, to unite the world with no borders. Governments cannot prevent internet users from sharing content, is part of our culture now.These pirate...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.