What do you prefer, the Christopher Nolan batman or the old Tim Burton Batman?

1. 66

   Stickyponyposted 12 years ago

   What do you prefer, the Christopher Nolan batman or the old Tim Burton Batman?
   
   Both have done some fantastic Batman movies if you ask me.

   replyreport
2. 60

   PhilipShawposted 12 years ago

   I agree, both are great adaptations of the comic that everyone should see. Like most of Tim Burton's awesome works, his Batman films have both a macabre and cartoon-like style. This fits Batman's character perfectly.
   
   However, this is also the reason I prefer Christopher Nolan's vision of Batman. Unlike Burton's imagining, I could picture the events of Nolan's trilogy unfolding in real life. As cliché as that might sound, to me, that gives it a more engaging quality.
   
   Christopher Nolan's trademark style is prevalent throughout his trilogy, but subtle enough for reality to breathe and let viewers easily suspend their disbelief. He's made the idea of a guy dressing up as a bat seem perfectly sensible.
   
   On the other hand, Tim Burton's Batman seems more like it took place in an alternate universe. Not the DC universe either... but somewhere you'd be more likely to meet Jack Skellington or Ichabod Crane than Batman's superhero colleagues.
   
   This is probably going to sound extremely blasphemous to true Batman fans, but Hans Zimmer's score is also part of the reason Nolan's Batman seems more engaging than Tim Burton's. As much as I love Danny Elfman's soundtrack, and find myself still humming his theme daily over twenty years after the first film came out, Hans Zimmer helped to breathe a new kind of life into the latest Batman with his scores. So much so, that other composers have been constantly mimicking the soundtrack's style since.
   
   That's just a personal opinion. Both of these film series are a real treat (not counting the two by Joel Schumacher), and will provide timeless entertainment to both Batman fans and general movie fans alike.

   replyreport
3. 59

   MickSposted 12 years ago

   Adam West, he truely brought out the stupidity of superheroes.  Along withe Burt Ward as his boyfr... Whoops, sorry sidekick, they really sorted out Gotham City.

   replyreport
   1. 60

      FatFreddysCatposted 12 years agoin reply to this

      I love the Adam West "Batman" show. I met Mr. West at a book signing event years ago and he was cool as hell!!

      replyreport
4. 80

   Mitch Alanposted 12 years ago

   Christopher Nolan's Batman is much more in line with the Dark Knight of the DC comics universe. He is gritty and dark. He he tormented, but always on the side of justice. The Tim Burton version became evermore a joke and a slip back to the 60's television version. We all grew up watching and loving that show, but it isn't the Dark Knight Detective. But, that is just this humble Hubber's opinion.

   replyreport
5. 0

   scottcgruberposted 12 years ago

   The William Dozier Batman, of the 1966 movie and TV series starring Adam West in the titular role, is the only true Batman.
   
   All others are false Batmen.
   
   The idea of a grown multimillionaire dressing up in a cape and a chiroptera-themed body suit is inherently campy. It is silly and surreal - particularly when said man has no special bat-powers resulting from the bite or scratch of a radioactive bat.
   
   Dozier, executive producer of the 60s series and movie, saw the inherent silliness and worked with it.  Producers and directors of the more recent versions fought against it to their - and the character's - detriment.

   replyreport