jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (4 posts)

Does hormone replacement cause breast cancer?

  1. sholland10 profile image93
    sholland10posted 4 years ago

    Does hormone replacement cause breast cancer?

    Many women refuse to take hormone replacement because there has been so much published about how it causes breast cancer.  Is this true or are the drug companies creating fear so women will choose other, more expensive drugs for their menopausal issues?

  2. profile image0
    lesliebyarsposted 4 years ago

    There are studies that show that HRT causes cancer.  I think that it is important for each individual women to meet with their doctor and discuss the options that are right for them.  Family history places a big role in your medical history.

  3. janshares profile image96
    jansharesposted 4 years ago

    I agree with lesliebyars and add that there are factors that put you more at risk for developing breast cancer if you use HRT. Age and family history of breast cancer are the big ones. The pros and cons have to be weighed by each woman. I remember when those studies scared women into stopping HRT who really needed the treatment for severe symptoms and protection from heart disease. The study was actually done on mostly elderly women where the incidence of breast cancer increases anyway. So it's very confusing to appy it to all women being at risk.

  4. fpherj48 profile image77
    fpherj48posted 4 years ago

    Susan.....Yet another vital question, the answers to which plague women everywhere.  Should we or shouldn't we?  Where do we begin our research and how do each one of us make the safest and best decision?
    To simplify, I can only share my own experience. 
    Having undergone a complete hysterectomy at age 44, mine was not a natural progression of menopause. At that time, taking as much info into consideration as possible, I opted to reject HRT. 
    The Familial/genetic risk for breast cancer literally surrounds me....mother & only sister, as well as aunts on both sides of my family.  However, so does heart disease.  Quite a dilemma. 
    On this note, my mother (female organs in tact) was a breast cancer survivor of 48 years, who ultimately succumbed to congestive heart failure at age 82.  My sister,(ovaries in tact) quite tragically lost a five-year battle with breast cancer at age 60. Neither used HRT. There was one distinct difference between my 2 loved ones:  TREATMENT.  My mother had a radical mastectomy, some radiation and zero chemo.  My sister, a lumpectomy & endless series of chemo and radiation.  What does this mean?  Very little except to add to the difficulty in understanding, wouldn't you agree? 
    It is however, a clear confirmation that HRT remains an individual & personal choice.  We could literally  weigh the issues FOREVER.  It only makes sense to make the choice we find personally correct and comfortable.  I should also mention that none of us (mother, sister nor I) experienced any negative symptoms of menopause....at all.  Go figure, Susan. It's at least a miracle that we women survive the pressures of making these decisions.  Seriously.
    Bottom line?  At least for me, I'd have to say, "So much for putting too much emphasis on genetics and family history."
    One last comment.....I highly recommend the books written by Suzanne Somers, on the topic of holistic HRT.  These books are an outstanding education for women in every regard.....Peace, Paula