It would be nice if when people ask a question you could answer it more than once. My reason is that sometimes a person gives a bad answer and someone needs to let the OP and anyone else who might be reading know that the advice is not good to follow.
Recently someone asked a question about pap smears and if a person feels violated when they get them. One woman mentioned that she goes to a midwife so she doesn't have that issue.
Here is the link:
http://hubpages.com/question/122322/do- … swer291072
A midwife is not a physician. They can deliver babies but have no authority or education in checking for cancer cells, STD's, cysts, tumors or any other number of conditions a woman may have.
It worries me that this young woman feels comfortable seeing a midwife for her healthcare needs.
Sorry but you are wrong. Doctors don't diagnose disease either.
No matter who does the pap smear, it is sent to the lab.
Regardless how it looks , no diagnosis is made until samples are tested. A lot (almost all) Midwives do pap smears.
Yes, doctors do diagnose disease, everyday.
What education does a midwife have? Where I live they are simply women who deliver babies, some have a nursing degree but from what I have heard they don't even have to have that.
I've never heard of midwives doing pap smears.
I am a nurse and doctors do not diagnose. The lab does,
Doctors diagnose the flu, Multiple Sclerosis,etc but when it comes to tumors or cells
Dr's may say it looks like this but they will also tell you they have to wait till they get the lab report back after the cells have been studied by the Pathologist..
Midwives just have to know how to do the pap smear. The lab will diagnose.
Just because you haven't heard does not make it not so. Obviously you have never heard of the lab either.
No need to reply because I'm done
The people at the laboratory are doctors.
The examination is not just for the smear (also for masses, infections etc), and the doctor interprets the test results. Unless the midwife is also an MD or nurse practitioner they should not be doing this.
I'm a nurse myself..a Perioperative nurse, so I know who can do what.
What I meant was the Midwife only does the pap smear and the Pathologist diagnoses.
I was not saying that's all Midwifes do.
A midwife is allowed to do a pap smear. Are you in the medical field?
The Pathologist diagnoses and the doctor reads the report.
Here, I found this for you.
What a Midwife does. Go here and scroll past the Google ads.
http://stason.org/TULARC/child-parent/m … es-Do.html
Here is another link
http://ezinearticles.com/?Nurse-Midwife … id=6217039
Giving medical advice is against the law.
(saying don't go to a midwife for a pap smear, is medical advice)
I would much rather have a person who has gone to medical school take care of my health than a midwife. If you feel comfortable putting your health in the hands of someone less qualified you certainly have that right.
A midwife is just a nurse, not a doctor.
http://www.allnursingschools.com/nursin … se-midwife
I am in a related field and know that not all midwives are nurses. As I said, a midwife that is also a doctor or nurse (aka nurse-midwife) can do this. A midwife that is not also a doctor or nurse cannot. And yes, in many countries including the US you can be a professional midwife without being a doctor or nurse (aka a lay midwife).
In the US you have to take a national examination and get certification to become a CPM
I may be able to help in this debate seeing as I'm in this field. Practises vary by country. Here in the UK, smears are taken mainly by nurses but those who do are specially trained and certified in the specific skill. Most nurses cannot take smears because they do not have the training. Midwives NEVER do smears. It is simply not their field. Pap (cervical) smear are a 'screening' test and therefore, strictly speaking, should not be looked at as a diagnostic test. If a woman has any symptoms she is concerned about, she will of course not see a nurse, not even one with pap-smear taking training. She will see a doctor as there is then a need for a diagnosis. That's outside a nurse's remit. I hope that helps but I am aware practises may be different in other parts of the world.
where I live there are midwives at the hospital who work under a doctor, if they have problems or issues with patients the doctor is notified but the midwif is capable of doing pap smears as well as the doctor.
In many cases I've seen the midwife do a better job at seeing the issues such as disease as the doctors, she then notifies the doctor of her suspisions who then comes in as needed for further testing and diagnoses.
To me midwives do more than just deliver babies, they have a much more holistic approach to the patient.
by Susannah Birch6 years ago
I'm so happy! I'm going through a public hospital, which usually means it's rather random what doctors, midwives and nurses you see during a pregnancy and birth.However my hospital has a special program that accepts 20...
by Onusonus7 months ago
A poll for the ladys out there.Planned Parenthood claims that only 3% of their services are for abortion. The rest is for cancer screening and other unrelated health services.So how many of you women out there actually...
by gajanis7866 years ago
Do you think herbal medicines and alternative method of treatment will overlap modern day method of treatment?Now a days herbal medicines and alternative methods of treatment for different diseases are becoming more and...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.