Is there thinking without language?
Is it possible to think without language given that language is needed to understand sound and visual representations.
Yes,Helen Keller is proof that before Language was acquired she still thought, it just differentiated from the thinking process of someone with the knowledge of language.
Can you give some examples Nichol. I am interested in knowing what she thought in terms of what a flower was or the smell of bread. It is just further exploration of this question. What was bread if she didn't know the name for it?
xaxorm • 4 year. Comment 5 2 the
human brain is readily adapted to find correlations in behavior, experience, and observation and format them into abstract constructs that symbolize the phenomena.
I don't think that true thinking without language is possible. Reacting to various cues is certainly possible, but dogs, horses and other animals do that without (IMO) being able to think. To me, thinking necessarily involves reasoning on an abstract level, and I don't see how that's possible without language. Was Helen Keller ever really without language? Humans are born with innate language ability, and nothing says it has to be verbal. Patterns of touch can constitute language, as is proven by Braille. So, I don't think she is a counter example to the generalization that there is no true thought without language.
I would agree with your statement and find it fascinating that other people would take time to entertain such a notion. I think and therefore I use my language skills to formulate responses to people,without that I am not sure what form would be used
by Steven Philip Lindquist and aliases in nature9 months ago
Is thinking possible without language?You may need language to identify thoughts even if language is another sense or form of communicating.
by Emile R5 years ago
I just had an odd thought. We spend a lot of time in our lives reflecting on our actions, attempting to put things into perspective and wondering how to be better people. We also probably spend a similar amount of time...
by William Thomas7 years ago
No special expertise is needed for this question, of course. Just look deeply into yourself, and tell me what you think the connection is between language and thought (how have you noticed the cycle operate within...
by Annie7 years ago
Is it possible to remove the words YES/NO from our vaculabury?Is it possible to remove those two words from our vaculabury? some might asked why, would they want too, what do you all think?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.