http://www.cnn.com/2013/11/06/us/paraly … hunter830a
What do you think about this?
From my safe and healthy perspective I do not agree with his choice - also I would think a little more time before making the decision would have helped validate his choice.
But I do think the choice was his to make!
I would agree that he needed more time, but...was his hospitalization sucking his wife and mom-to-be of his son dry? Would they lose their home, retirement, etc.? That could have played a part in the quick decision.
Whatever the reasons, though, it was his to make.
His life, his choice. It is the same as if he had a living will. What is sad is that so many can not answer the question, being forced to live and suffer.
By the way, it reminded me of a great movie, Mar Adentro; the real-life story of Ramon Sampedro.
Since it was his life to live, he had every right to make that choice. I have worked with elderly and handicapped people for over 20 years. Some of them have lived nearly 20 years after paralyzing accidents. One quadriplegic who had crashed his motorcycle in the late 1970s told me it would have been easier on his family if he had died in the accident. Not only did the accident cripple him, he contracted Hepatitis C from the necessary blood transfusion.
Modern technology has extended life. Along with that comes the responsibility of choosing when to end it.
What I think about this...is that it's a deeply moving story that has made me very saddened for all those closely involved. I can state with certainty, I never want to be the person left with this decision to make for someone else. I know in this case that the man himself made his firm and truthful wishes known...and that his family members honored, respected and accepted them. What a heart-wrenching situation. although I can understand the ultimate end.
I've tried to think of what I would choose, were I to be in the same condition. The reality is, I couldn't be 100% sure. I do know that my husband felt identical to the man in this story, because we often had talks about this very thing. Because I knew my hubby so very well, I completely understood his feelings and would have to agree that his choice would be the best for him.
This will never be an issue however, since my sweet husband died in less than 30 seconds, due to a fatal heart attack, while kicked back in his lounge chair, watching a football game. In the past 8 months, I can tell you I have lost count, for how many people have commented that they just HOPE that is how they will make their exit. I understand that mindset.
This article told me, this man broke his spine high up in the cervical vertebra and his couldn't breath on his own. He would have been a quadriplegic.
Joni Erickson Tada is a quadriplegic who had a diving accident 45 years ago. She has had a spectacular life, but it hasn't been easy. She has had many near death experiences.
by krisingreen5 months ago
Do you agree that suicide should be accepted as a personal choice?Everyone has the right to their own body, right? So if a person (yes, depressed for a really long time) wanted to commit suicide because he really wanted...
by sunasia226 years ago
Abortion is regarded as the most controversial issue in bioethics, law and politics worldwide. This issue has been subjected to fervent debates in many legal and ethical fora around the world. This is so...
by Lizam14 years ago
What is the most important choice you have ever made and why?From cradle to grave we are faced with a myriad of decisions and choices. Sometimes we look back and wonder what would have happened if we had chosen...
by Helen Murphy Howell5 years ago
Euthanasia for those who want it - yes or no?The euthanasia debate has reared it's head again in the UK about people having to travel to Switzerland if they want euthanasia to end their life. Many people are saying that...
by Clive Williams3 years ago
Abortion, what is your views on this sensitive issue? is it morally wrong or do you support it?Do you think abortion is murder, or do people have the right to do what they will with whoever is in their bodies?
by kallini20104 years ago
What was the most difficult ethical decision you've ever made?I probably should say the "most difficult ethical decision" that you are comfortable to share because certain decisions concerning ethics we are...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.