jump to last post 1-15 of 15 discussions (17 posts)

Do you agree that suicide should be accepted as a personal choice?

  1. krisingreen profile image59
    krisingreenposted 6 years ago

    Do you agree that suicide should be accepted as a personal choice?

    Everyone has the right to their own body, right? So if a person (yes, depressed for a really long time) wanted to commit suicide because he really wanted to, would that make a difference compared to someone who simply want to commit the act because they want everyone to give them attention? What if suicide really is the only way out? I'm not saying that I like the idea but have you ever known someone who don't want to live anymore?

  2. bharath.adupa profile image71
    bharath.adupaposted 6 years ago

    no way....we have a right on our body but birth and death are not our choice so suicide never should be a choice...

  3. MellyMoo profile image61
    MellyMooposted 6 years ago

    Yes, I think that in certain situations it should be each individual's choice but there do need to be laws so that it IS only in certain situations, ie. longstanding physical or mental suffering.  I do not think that people dying from cancer (for example) should be forced to keep living, when relying totally on pain relief and suffering immensely mentally and physically.  What kind of life is that?!!

  4. jimmylesaint profile image61
    jimmylesaintposted 6 years ago

    Definitely not. We did not choose to be born so we cannot have the freedom of choice to kill ourselves. Many religions also frown on suicide and look at it as a sin "murdering yourself" murder is a sin. Also to take your own life where it is deemed to be given to you by God is presuming you know better than God.
    Judaism/Christianity, Islam look at suicide as a sin or eternal sin.
    Hinduism/Jainism allow suicide but only by fasting to death. Buddhism allows for suicide if someone is fully "enlightened".
    The question is who are we, mere humans, to create laws to allow suicide or assisted suicide(euthanasia) that supercede the law/teachings of God,Allah,Brahma,Buddha. For to allow such a law is to not only admit defeat but completely erase hope and faith. The fundamentals of religion and human ideology. No suicide is not an option!

  5. mcrawford76 profile image84
    mcrawford76posted 6 years ago

    No. Wanting to take your own life is almost always a sign of mental instability. Depression or other mental problems can usually be helped with drugs and therapy.
    I don't disagree with the argument of euthanasia of a terminally ill patient. But I don't believe that long term depression qualifies. And I feel that a screening and therapy process should preclude assisted suicide.

  6. nightwork4 profile image61
    nightwork4posted 6 years ago

    it is a personal choice already but i'll never accept it. the damage caused to friends and family of a suiced are horrible to say the least. if you want to kill yourself, at least have the decency to make it look like an accident. drive your car off a cliff during a storm or something.

  7. PainReliefGuy profile image70
    PainReliefGuyposted 6 years ago

    There are far better options than suicide. The concern is not the person killing themselves, as it is the impact that suicide has on the people they leave behind. You're better off walking life as a zombie than killing yourself before you die naturally.

    There are foods you can eat, activities you can participate in, and even drugs you can take to elevate your mood and help you to see clearly that in the end, no matter how bad things are at the moment, life is still worth living.

    It is NOT a personal choice as long as you have people in your life who care about you.

  8. Cardisa profile image92
    Cardisaposted 6 years ago


    As a past suicidal myself (obviously it did not work), I must say it was not a conscious nor rational decision on my part.

    For may years I was depressed, thought only to rid myself of pain and anguish. I could not see clearly and did not realize how much I was loved.

    Looking back I cannot accept that I made that decision consciously or rationally.

    Suicide being a personal choice would mean you were in your right mind when you made the decision, no one who is depressed is in their right frame of mind. Suicide is an effect of depression.

  9. profile image0
    rorshak sobchakposted 6 years ago

    If someone is thinking about suicide they have to have something wrong mentally. They should get help as soon as possible.

  10. Wesman Todd Shaw profile image98
    Wesman Todd Shawposted 6 years ago

    The people who really want to commit suicide are pretty successful at it.  I don't think we have any choice but to accept the decisions of those who are no longer here.  We don't have to like their choices, but we have to accept them, the past is gone.

  11. Hailsale profile image60
    Hailsaleposted 6 years ago

    No i disagree as alot of the time if not all the person who is suicidal is not capable of making that decision due to frame of mind or mental illness.

  12. lambservant profile image95
    lambservantposted 6 years ago

    Been their Kris. Tried and somehow failed. When I saw the devastation it left on my family and friends I came to my senses at how unfair it was to have made that choice. I don't have the right, nor do you, to take your life. First of all, because God gave you life and has said we should not murder even ourselves. Second, to leave that kind of devastation to those you love is extremely unfair. The suffering you create to your loved ones is a grave sin.

    All that being said, I got help, but was still suicidal off an on for many months. But I doubled my efforts to get the help and follow my treatment plan to the letter. I admit, I had to call the suicide hotline several times. I couldn't stand the pain anymore, but I thought of my family and how frightened and devastaed they were when I tried before. I could not do that to them. Go to a hospital emergency room if you are suicidal.

    One time, a crisis line worker told me that there is a very high rate of suicide to family members whose loved one has committed suicide. I know how hard it is, but it is not the answer. Know you are loved by many and most importantly by God your Creator. There is help, there is hope, reach out and find it.

  13. gmwilliams profile image87
    gmwilliamsposted 2 years ago


    Yes, there are times when a person cannot take it anymore or feels that there is utter and abject hopelessness in his/her life.  This person believes that suicide is much better than to live a half-life.  There are those who commit suicide because their life isn't what they want it to be in terms of success and achievement.  They feel that they have not reached their potential and refuse to live their lives on the bases of inauthenticity. They didn't achieve their particular goals and dreams, strongly contending that if they didn't achieve such dreams and goals, then it is better for them to be dead than to not live life on their own terms.

    Then there are people who have been fired or lost their jobs.  Rather than to face homelessness, many do commit suicide because they believe that their situation is hopeless at best. This is the case for those in their 50s and beyond.  Many know that as a result of either firing or downsizing, no other employer would want to hire them especially at their age.  So they contend that rather to live a lesser and impoverished life, they would rather commit suicide.

    Suicide for some is a courageous act.  They refuse to be passive to their prospective negative fate.  They want to be in charge in what happens to them and the masters of their fate so to speak.  Many commit suicide because of the hopelessness and bleakness in their lives.  They have the knowledge that they cannot do any better despite of what the Pollyannas keep telling them.  They KNOW that they cannot go on and that things will ONLY get worse, never better and see suicide as a viable option.

    1. profile image54
      Romanusposted 2 years agoin reply to this

      Captures my thoughts almost exactly.

  14. profile image57
    Lyn Lousteinposted 6 months ago

    As a personal choice,yes. But its teribbly wrong. Suicide it's not the only way. except if you face some movie-like situation when you have to killed yourself in order for many lives.

    Face problem, don't let yourself lose to it. You would never know what you could have if you didn't commit suicide. There are more ways than you now, but you refused to acknowledge it. Stop pitying yourself.

    I'm not boasting over nothing. I have my personal experince too. I'm strugling too, but i'm not going to give up.

    1. dashingscorpio profile image87
      dashingscorpioposted 6 months agoin reply to this

      "But its terribly wrong."
      Only the individual can decide what is right for (them) which is why it's a "personal choice". We can never know what it's like to be someone else grappling with whatever issues/illness they have.

  15. dashingscorpio profile image87
    dashingscorpioposted 6 months ago

    You can't get more "personal" than deciding to live or not.
    Suicide is usually a permanent solution to a temporary problem.