jump to last post 1-7 of 7 discussions (27 posts)

We Native Americans DEMAND the removal of the United States flag (?)

  1. colorfulone profile image87
    colorfuloneposted 2 years ago

    "Due to the recent tragedy in SC. People in government are coming together against a flag that has a negative and disgusting past.

    Native Americans have the same feelings about the American flag.

    As African Americans feel about the confederate flag."

    https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petiti … tates-flag


    http://usercontent1.hubimg.com/12493504_f1024.jpg

    (Some other Islam dude is calling for the removal of the American flag too.
    Apple removed all Wargame apps that had the rebel flag in it.)

    1. Live to Learn profile image81
      Live to Learnposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      Good luck with that one.

      1. Paul Wingert profile image80
        Paul Wingertposted 2 years ago in reply to this

        Okay fine. You have that right to challenge it. What would you replace it with? You're chances of success are slim to none, however, who would of thought 10 years ago that same sex marriage would be the law of the land?

        1. colorfulone profile image87
          colorfuloneposted 2 years ago in reply to this

          If you have enough money these days you can replace just about anything.

        2. Live to Learn profile image81
          Live to Learnposted 2 years ago in reply to this

          You may have missed my point. I have no problem with the American flag and find the idea of replacing it as ludicrous as the majority of Americans would. "Good luck with that" was sarcasm.

          However, if we did replace it I think the 'Don't tread on me' flag would garner my vote.

    2. ahorseback profile image47
      ahorsebackposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      This posting is just exactly what's wrong in America today . So many people  just don't love their country , this country  .   I truly believe in one old saying that's speaks volumes to SOME of the people in   America today .   " If you don't stand FOR something -You will Fall for anything !

      How you can turn a rebel flag that stands for a part of this country that  apparently  forgot to surrender a hundred and fifty years ago ,  -into an all out rant against the American flag is beyond me !  My suggestion , if you don't love America  there are what  180 some odd OTHER countries for you to go to  and make your home  .  And don't get me wrong   I don't feel anger , I just feel   that I understand the liberal" free range" mindset of  last fifty years , completely!  .

      If you are Native American , then you either have your own reservation here  where you can fly your own flag , or you live in America where you don't get to  dictate that wish  !

      Wow , No love for country .

      1. rhamson profile image75
        rhamsonposted 2 years ago in reply to this

        I really understand the post as have we no shame more than for want of loving the country. If you wish to bury your head in the traditional history books about the folklore and doctored reasoning's then I can totally understand your outrage about this. If you want to say stop history here and lets proceed from this point in time that is your prerogative. But to tell the Indians to either stay on "their" reservation and fly a flag of their choosing and forget about all the land that was forcibly taken from them flying a flag that reminds them of this is shameful to say the least. America has a convenient memory as well as amnesia.

        1. ahorseback profile image47
          ahorsebackposted 2 years ago in reply to this

          I know very well my history , the US. history  AND a lot of Native American history ,  Lets take a look at world history  ! Have you ever seen a nation "give back " to the indigenous peoples that were there first .....Anything ?  Or should I say , Have you ever seen a country more  accepting of assimilation  of any and all peoples ,than America ?   If one is a native in America  , he pretty much has a head start on a lot of  things in life ....If he so choses to use it .

          I'm guessing here but I don't believe America ever will , ever should , or ever  should even think about giving it all back . In fact I'm not even sure anyone who calls for it is living in the real world !

          1. Live to Learn profile image81
            Live to Learnposted 2 years ago in reply to this

            Last I read the native americans didn't mind taking land from each other either; when it suited them. So, we'd have to find someone to sort it out and figure out who lived where first.

          2. rhamson profile image75
            rhamsonposted 2 years ago in reply to this

            Who said anything about reparations? It is funny how taking that stance can be an indication of the guilt associated with it. It is also an admission that an indigenous people were over run and wronged. That was my point in the first place with regards to the American flag. This country has been involved in so many underhanded and dirty deals including murder, murder attempts on foreign leaders, overthrowing governments and installing dictators and fighting wars for profit disguised as moral or in our best interests for years. We even start wars to achieve our goals or dominance and profit.

            With regards to the Indians this is just another thing where America likes to sweep the past under the carpet and beat their chest with pride over something they understand as a lie.

    3. ahorseback profile image47
      ahorsebackposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      If "We native Americans were going to demand", Anything  .     We might demand answers to real and honest questions of our  own making !

      For instance ,why the  alcoholism , drug addictions , child mortality ,   extreme poverty ,   of it's own peoples , graft and corruption from within many Indian official offices ,    why gambling  and gaming  is their "new ' economy ,   , why  gas exploration ,  oil exploration , uranium mines ,  open pit coal mines --all of this is their basic economic contribution to their own peoples ?  ALL OF THIS FROM  what amounts to mostly sovereign countries within that of America ?

      Seems to me they might have assimilated and gotten better from America , FOR THIER OWN CHILDREN .

      And this is all the best they can come up with  for economic growth and"  a much emphasized "spiritual connection to our earth" ?

    4. Moshka profile image61
      Moshkaposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      I doubt all Native Americans feel that way about the American flag. However those who wish to ban it should start in their own communities by ceasing to sell fireworks on the fourth of July. See if that doesn't go over like a turd in a punch bowl.

      But since we're on the subject of flag banning I've got a proposal;

      http://www.chinatoday.com/org/cpc/old_party_flag_before_1996.jpg

      How about banning this banner of death...

      1. Paul Wingert profile image80
        Paul Wingertposted 2 years ago in reply to this

        Hows that a banner of death?

        1. Moshka profile image61
          Moshkaposted 2 years ago in reply to this

          Because it's the commie flag.

    5. Writer Fox profile image79
      Writer Foxposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      I looked at that petition.  So far, only 13 people have signed it.

      Actually each Native American Tribe has its own flag.  You can see many of them here by clicking on a Tribe name:
      http://www.tmealf.com/DH/

  2. psycheskinner profile image80
    psycheskinnerposted 2 years ago

    I think opposing the confederate flag is all about loving the country, and opposition the pro-segregation weirdos who picked this one obscure banner (it's not even the main confederate battle flag) to use in their fight against civil rights in the 1960s..

    Opposition to the national flag is limited to a few loonies and radicals, and a few people just trying to make a point about how the national that uses it has screwed them over..

    1. rhamson profile image75
      rhamsonposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      "Opposition to the national flag is limited to a few loonies and radicals, and a few people just trying to make a point about how the national that uses it has screwed them over."

      Good point! No it isn't!!!!!!!! How easily you tread on the rights and property of others and label them loonies and radicals. Remember a few radicals that had a little uprising over some taxes and waged a war to not pay them? Many thought they were loonies and wanted no part of it. You should read up on Andrew Jackson and his treatment of the Indians before you make this your rationale.

  3. Superkev profile image85
    Superkevposted 2 years ago

    Well, since we are going to ban all things offensive and racist by any and all definitions. I hereby demand that all roads, highways, buildings, monuments or any other such structures bearing the name of Senator Robert C. Byrd (D) West Virginia be removed immediately.

    Sen. Byrd was not only a member of the KKK but a leader of that racist organization for many years. He recruited many new members to the KKK and is directly responsible for the actions those members took on behalf of this racist group, including racially motivated killings and lynchings of black people in West Virginia and other states.

    He was the Democrat Senator from West Virginia for over 50 years and I am deeply offended that he was not removed from office for his racist past. His racist views are and were well known and documented.

    It is a travesty that he was allowed to serve so long as the Democrat Senator from West Virginia, even holding many leadership positions with in the US Senate, and was not held accountable for his racist past.
    http://usercontent2.hubimg.com/12495457.jpg

    1. rhamson profile image75
      rhamsonposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      + 1

  4. colorfulone profile image87
    colorfuloneposted 2 years ago

    Could it be the petition was created as a distraction and a division to cover up covert military operations?

  5. ahorseback profile image47
    ahorsebackposted 2 years ago

    Maybe  after all , banning anything like  'burning  the books " is  simply a movement of  naiveté  , a "feel good "moment  for a collective guilt complex  by all of us?  Sometimes these forums might as well be  the whole image of America's  facebook mentality .  A huge public forum , a bathroom wall if you will , where  anyone of us  can scratch our  porn message on the fresh paint  and get away with it , before returning to our measly , pitiful "normalcy" !.

    Banning anything  is about as helpful to  humanity as turning  our collective faces away from the NEXT Dyllin Roof  , the next  Lee Harvey Oswald , the next Jeffrey Dolmer ,   There is , after all , NOTHING we can do about  real  psycho's , thereIS probably one born every hour .

    So , scratch away people !

    1. rhamson profile image75
      rhamsonposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      "So , scratch away people !"

      This is what makes America great and makes me glad I live here. We get to say what is on our minds without fear of reprisal for our right to say it. Even if it may sound less than intelligible or if it comes from a place of anger or fear it is what we have a right to do. I think because we can and do have the conversation it makes us stronger in our beliefs and unites us in understanding each other better.

      1. ahorseback profile image47
        ahorsebackposted 2 years ago in reply to this

        I was just about to post a new  thread , Rant's - Raves and Reasons ,     something about how when we ask a question or post a new topic , we've  already realized our own answers and that we only ask in order to proudly  fan the fires of our differences .  That's more like what I see happening here  most times .

  6. ahorseback profile image47
    ahorsebackposted 2 years ago

    There are so many  writing ,reaction--ists  here in forums ,  A lot of threads , forums , questions are tainted by the  design and THIS is simply just  one more of them. so much so I doubt seriously that if any such thing as a poll were taken by Native Americans , that there could be much interest in  the removal of the American Flag - AND from where do they remove it from ,   ?  Do you  remove it from  the reservations , where I doubt it flies anyway-  given they are generally sovereign countries  within America  and have their own flag .?   Do you wish to remove the flag of another country from their own soil , No .    Do you wish to remove a Navajo flag from say Kyenta  Arizona , a town  within  the Reservation , no , I doubt it .  This entire thread is getting boring , Nothing but child like reactionist's

    I don't see such  high amounts of social-maturity in a topic like this  .

    1. colorfulone profile image87
      colorfuloneposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      From what I have been hearing from Native American people who I have known for many, many moons, they are not in agreement of this petition. 

      Native Americans are some of the most patriotic people I known. Because of that, I believe a few were involved in this petition and have brought disgrace to Nationhood. It sounds like a paid commercial at the White House level.

  7. alex35aclll profile image60
    alex35aclllposted 2 years ago

    We should all forget about the past and move on to growing more respect for all people in every community.

    1. rhamson profile image75
      rhamsonposted 2 years ago in reply to this

      That's a nice idea but impractical when some repeat poor behavior anchored in the past. Trust is the key and how can you have trust when one party continually abuses the other?

 
working