haha thats great...I am all for american's knowing multiple languages...honestly we are behind every other country and it is going to hurt our chances getting good jobs as more people move to the US from foreign countries.
Many signs here in California are in both English and Spanish, but I can read the latter language enough to comprehend most. Once my brother in law and I had an out and out debate about how he should learn a little bit of Spanish since he works with people on construction sites that speak limited English, which made him very mad. However, he was the one complaining about the language barrier and having to draw pictures, so if he learned a little bit of Spanish that could greatly help. I wish I spoke the language more proficiently, so sometimes it is fun to watch those stations to try and see how much I can comprehend.
Now I also think that if you are going to be a citizen or live here you should know english. It is important to know english more so.
In California many people are recent immigrants learning the language, and since I work with the public I often have to communicate with many ESL speakers. Many are learning the language, but being able to speak Spanish also helps me. I enjoy being able to communicate with people as much as I can, so by strengthing my Spanish language skills I am able to convey what I am thinking and feeling to more people.
I personally think foreign languages should be taught in US schools earlier, which is why Americans are behind Europeans on that accord. I had a pen pal from Norway who spoke fluent English by the time she was in seventh grade, and she did not even live around any native speakers. She simply wanted to be able to communicate with a wide range of people.
I wonder about that. I do think learning languages is a good in and of itself, but it is still the case today that most Americans will rarely, if ever, need to use foreign language skills throughout their working lives. If teaching time is a limited resource, might that time not be better spent improving math and science skills, for example? I'm not sure, just putting it out there.
Also, I wonder if all the signs and phone prompts and whatnot in Spanish aren't really to the detriment of Spanish-speaking immigrants and unfair to non-Spanish speaking immigrants. Again, just putting it out there.
For many of us we are interested in knowing more about the world, and living in California I would say there is a need for bilingual signs. Canada used to have the stigma regarding bilingualism, but they finally got over their issues with it. The reality is many people in the US are bilingual, or have parents that are, so I do not think your ideas would be helpful. I am just putting that out there.
You don't think that having access to almost everything in Spanish might retard the acquisition of English for many Spanish-speaking immigrants?
Knowing about the world is nice, but not what I was talking about.
No I think it will prompt people to become more bilingual, which actually is a good brain exercise really . You may not be talking about knowing more about the world, but I certainly am when it comes to being able to speak Spanish more fluently.
Are you saying those signs and whatnot are there to teach native English speakers to speak Spanish?!
For me it has. You know a good part of the English language is based on French and Latin anyway, so it is not at all that difficult to find cognate words. Also, I have noticed my niece and nephew know far more Spanish words than I did growing up. In many ways Spanish words are infiltrating the colloquial language, which does not bother me. English is one of the most mixed up languages in the world anyway, and that goes back to the days of Norman the Conqueror when French became the official language of the court in England.
No Spanish is not the poor man's language as I have known many intellectuals that speak it. That is only perception.
I am cognizant it is William. I am a smart cookie with history, I was just typing fast. Try not to correct people before they have a chance to go back and edit lol.
Great, but was that the purpose when those signs were put up? In your opinion, should it be?
The Montessori schools have the right idea. They start kids learning a second language at 3 years old. (Only problem for my kids was that French was being taught. Not very useful for them.)
Oh my. Next too English, French is the second most common spoke language. It is spoken through out Europe, the Middle East, Africa, India, Korea, Vietnam, Japan, and on and on and on. It is as common as English, if not more so. What in heavens gave the idea that French wasn't useful? Amazing.
I think what Ironher is trying to say is she would prefer her kids to learn another foreign language that is spoken more widely where she lives. Of course French is useful, but if I had thought more about it I would have taken Spanish in high school instead.
Boy this is going to get me into trouble. But please do excuse me- for this is not how I personally feel. But in the business world, and in the intellectual community- Spanish is the poor man's language Sweetie. Only blue collar workers are pushed towards Spanish. Children with higher intellect, its preferred they be taught French. Now I'm a big city kid. I've lived my whole life in the educational community, this has been my personal experience. Spanish is derived from old world French. It is not the other way around. If you are fluent in French, you are capable of speaking quite a bit of Spanish as a side effect. Same with Italian Sweetie. It is the mother of the romantic languages. French is far more important to learn. Because you can communicate with far more people. But hey- no matter the language is it good to learn it.
Both Spanish and French are derived from Latin. Neither is derived from the other.
Spanish is derived from old world French. All languages are built from one another. All of them. But of the romantic language bases, French is the predominant influence. It is the dominator.
The "base" of all the romance languages is Latin. And languages did not develop over time in a simple 1-2-3 progression. It is far more complex than that.
Well something like that. Googled that did yeah?
I do not agree with you at all times TK, but I have noticed people like to disparage your education level. Not sure why, but I would ignore those type of comments.
Who did that? You by making the accusation. Yes, I believe you just did. Nice one Sweetie.
Thank you for the thoughtful comments (really). Some folks 'round here just seem to be very, very sensitive, and apparently live in a sphere where disparaging educational level is the worst possible insult - which is hilarious. Again, thanks.
Study the Italic Branch of the Indo-European language family.
Do you have any proof of this or is it just your prejudice in favor of French? (which you are welcome to)
prejudice in favor of French? Yeah that's it. I'll write a hub about the history of languages, which I carry a degree in from Brown and email it to you. That be alright with you?
Write whatever floats your boat. I'll be happy to read and correct your hub if you want.
How about you try to apply to my great university, and I'll let you set in my class free for a day. Better yet, you can help me grade a dissertation or two on the subject matter. How many languages do you speak? Fluent in Latin are you? Well, feel free to speak it if you know it so well. How about French? Spanish? Italian? Cajun? Or just plain Carolina back hills dialect? Haven't graded too many thesis in written in Latin with Southern style English twist. Could be interesting.
Thanks for the invitation, but I've already got a master's degree in Linguistics so I'll pass on the visit. If it makes you feel any better I guess I can get by in 5 or 6 languages alright, and I have proofed, edited, and graded many, many, many university papers of all sorts.
Anyway, thanks for your recent hub comments. Much appreciated.
Understand doggie language do you? Hows that dog of yours? Cute fella. Like to fetch does he? Hubs on squirrels, great writer, yeap TK your such a real special person. Howl.
He's not real big on 'fetching' to be honest. Too lazy most times.
If I did I'd be as rich as that little 'Dog Whisperer' guy.
Quemadmodum possums scire utrum vere simus an solum sentiamus nos esse, y'all?
RK: My kids have spent most of their time in the US, South America and the Caribbean. Trust me -- their Spanish has been called on many, many times, but never their French. Not even in the French Quarter in New Orleans.
My experiences are the same as yours having grown up in Southern California where the majority of ESL speakers are of Hispanic origin. Interestingly I even had several professors that were highly intellectual historians conducting ground breaking research on Spanish colonialism in Mexico, and those first hand documents were obviously not in French.
I believe Spanish is spoken by more people than French, and of course Mandarin is the most common first language.
Here is a list by popularity:
1. Mandarin Chinese - 882 million
2. Spanish - 325 million
3. English - 312-380 million
4. Arabic - 206-422 million
5. Hindi - 181 million
6. Portuguese - 178 million
7. Bengali - 173 million
8. Russian - 146 million
9. Japanese - 128 million
10. German - 96 million
I think there is a middle ground to all of this. As you can see French is not listed on the list above of popularity, but statistics can be interpreted however you like. Although French is not listed on this list, I believe that it is more widely spoken than many of these languages -- many of which are localized to a specific geographic area. French is spoken in many African countries for example which makes it a very useful language if one is interested in international travel.
This is not to say that Spanish is not also a very useful language, especially for someone spending alot of time in the southern US, or Latin America.
I think it really all comes down to where you live, and what you're trying to accomplish with your second language.
http://www.soyouwanna.com/site/toptens/ … ages4.html
Another link for ya:
http://geography.about.com/od/culturalg … guages.htm
I think hubs about dogs are cute. What is more cute than a dog?
Definitely knowing Spanish is more useful in South American countries. It is also the fastest growing language, if I'm not mistaken.
But what RK is saying about French is also true. Many African nationals speak French (ie, my friend from the Ivory Coast who completed a Phd in French just recently), plus many other French colonized countries....here listed
I cannot say numbers wise it is as common as English, but certainly, when considering world literature, it has been perhaps more influential than Spanish.
If we give priority to language, then the matter (to be discussed) will go back. Whether we like it or not, English has established itself as a global language. Almost all countries have English-speaking people. It will be better to let it be as it is. English may well be treated as a common language. Let no other controversy crop up in the present controversial world.
by klevifusha3 months ago
If you were able to learn a foreign language without any effort, which language would you choose to speak and why?
by sannyasinman7 years ago
What problems have you encountered learning to speak a foreign language?Example: . . in French au-dessus and au-dessous are pronounced virtually identically, and are difficult for a foreigner to say, but the first means...
by Smart is Good4 years ago
Name the languages you can speak including your mother language and how good do you speak the others. My mother Language is Spanish, I speak advanced English and intermediate French. I'd love to keep learning german...
by Greensleeves Hubs4 years ago
Perhaps the saddest thing I see on a regular basis on HubPages is the effort of foreign HubPages members with limited English to establish a readership for their hubs. Too often I come across hubbers whose intentions...
by Leah Lefler5 years ago
I was hub hopping and saw a rather innovative approach to having a hub written in two languages. The text portion of the hub was written in English, and then a photo was uploaded containing the same article, written in...
by Mtbailz5 years ago
The Tampa republican debate brought up the topic of a national language. This would mean all politics would be dealt in the English language. This includes voting ballots. What are the bonuses to such a policy and on...
Copyright © 2017 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.