What would happen if the House of Representatives would never agree?
If the Democrats do not get agreement from the House, what are the constitutional options for a Democratic House and President? Is it that they could not increase revenue, because of Article I, Section 7? Anyone have the legal knowledge to say?
The way the Constitution is written, it appears that the House would have to pass any revenue increase bills.
The first sentence reads as follows:
All bills for raising revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with amendments as on other Bills.
That is about a clear as you can get on that topic. As for what can be done, the answer is not a whole lot. But that is the current aim of the GOP.
Their goal is to keep the Dems from being able to accomplish much of anything, and then retake control in subsequent elections. It turns out that they have realized that many voters: a) are stupid, b) have short memories or c) a combination of both of the above.
As such, most of us have forgotten that the reason the Bush tax cuts were extended was to get a vote on the extension of unemployment benefits even brought to the floor. And that happened only eight months ago.
They have managed to muddy the debate just enough to confuse those who aren't paying attention.
Hence the current debate about the debt ceiling even though it has routinely been raised under GOP administrations.
Seems as if we are seeing the consequences of that this election year when little or nothing will get done.
by Deidre Shelden 7 years ago
If the Democrats do not get agreement from the House, what are the options for a Democratic House and President? Is it that they could not increase revenue, because of Article I, Section 7?
by GA Anderson 16 months ago
I am about half-way through "Man Of The House," an autobiography by Tip, (Tom), O'Neil and William Novak, and I have been thinking about my fellow Politics and Social Issues forum dwellers since the very first chapter.Tip O'Neil started his political career in Massachusetts in 1936, and...
by dutchman1951 7 years ago
If this below is really true, and it is from the Library of Congress on Congressional By-laws and operations. Than how did any bill proposed that affects the Public generaly. sucH as Cap and Trade, Health reform, get to be declared Private.Did Pelosi break her own Congressional law? I think...
by Prakash RnP 4 years ago
What lesson should we draw from the US Govt shutdown?If viewed from the communistic viewpoint, the current US Govt shutdown appears to be an expression of the internal contradiction of capitalism, and this contradiction is without any resolution. How do you view it?
by Mike Russo 6 years ago
I'm curious to know what have been the Republican congress accomplishments since Obama has been in office? It seems to me all they have done is criticsize everything that he has done and say no to any bill or legislation that he wanted passed.
by rhamson 20 months ago
With Kerry and Netanyahu arguing the US vote in abstentia effectively condemning Israel for continued new settlements on the West Bank one has to wonder why all the remaining votes went to condemn Israel without notice or discussion. Is it that the US blocking such votes make it any less important...
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|