Should private lives of public officials be off limits to public scrutiny?
Do public officials have a greater responsibility to live moral private lives than the average person? David Patraeus made poor private life decisions. Does that say something about his judgment? Was it John McCain who divorced his wife while she had cancer. Is that our business? Clinton entertained Monica Lewinsky in the Oval Office. There are examples across all political persuasions. Their high profile possessions are what made them "enticing." Don't they understand that?
Never. Public officials take on enormous power and perks. As they do, they make themselves vulnerable to any number of corrupting situations.
Personally, it is sad that Gen. Patraeus did no more than any other human being. Professionally, however, the rules of his job did not allow that behavior.
He did a fine thing by resigning and, if there are no more bizarre, silly stories coming out, this will blow over.. He had an outstanding career and this should not wipe all of that accomplishment away.
I believe people have a right to privacy, but when you are in a position that behavior may effect not only your job performance but might also compromise others and your ability to perform your duties you should expect to be called on it. The thought of the head of the CIA or a General playing cyber grab ass or doing it in real-time at work makes me think their minds could not be on their jobs and that could be dangerous for those working for them and for national security, so no they can't expect a blind eye from the public.
All our lives are under public scrutiny, we, the majority of people, don't have affairs that the media and gutter press want to publish stories about though.
Would we hold ourselves more moral than public figures because our ordinary lives help us cover up our indiscretions?
I think we do.
What Patraus, Clinton, and many other public figures have done is no different to what public figures and other human beings have done for all humman history. Took a risk for what they felt was a reasonable payoff.
No we the people cannot demand higher morals from leaders as long as we the people allow our indiscretions to be annonymous.
Thank you Bretsuki! What do you think about "with position comes responsibility?" If a person with sensitive information is blackmailed, the country could be compromised.
I would argue that we all have responsibility. We all carry information which can be used by an enemy of our countries. Holding another to higher values only hurts ourselves in the end. Plus there is a double standard at play at all levels.
It depends how sensitive and big the public official's position is.If Barack Obama is seen cavorting with some bombshell woman besides (Michelle )and drinking champagne on a yacht in St Tropez while the country is in turmoil, that just doesn't fly with the public, does it? But if it is my small time councilor from somewhere in neck of the woods doing the same thing ,chances are ,that it might not even make it to the local paper.I bet the local townfolks will just shrug their shoulders and say "WHO CARES?
by kallini20105 months ago
Why are people so interested in private lives of celebrities?Who are we to judge?
by thaivalentine6 years ago
The average American teacher works 9 months a year, gets holidays off, receives a base salary, pension, full benefits and a job for life as a result of tenure. What you get, someone with a Masters Degree who on...
by SparklingJewel6 years ago
if you don't understand one of the main concepts that is driving the many people calling for the resurgence of a Constitutional government and as awakened citizenry,(even OWS is, they just don't know it)then read this...
by Elizabeth3 years ago
If Christianity really is the truth, shouldn't scrutiny demonstrate its truth?All over the place in America, we see believers responding with outrage and defiance when Christian beliefs are challenged or...
by Ralph Schwartz11 months ago
Can anyone make a case for Open Borders that stands up to scrutiny?When people protest to demand open borders, I wonder if they've thought the idea through all the way. I don't see how economically it can work,...
by NGRIA Bassett8 years ago
Men seem to role with the punches a bit better than women concerning weight gain, having a pot belly and all. What do you think?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.