jump to last post 1-4 of 4 discussions (7 posts)

Do you think Officer Ben Fields deserved to be fired?

  1. profile image0
    LoliHeyposted 2 years ago

    Do you think Officer Ben Fields deserved to be fired?

    Do you think he was wrong in his actions, or are teens today becoming more and more disrespectful, or both?

  2. Michaela Osiecki profile image78
    Michaela Osieckiposted 2 years ago

    Probably both, but being disrespectful does not warrant a child being thrown to the ground by a large male. He definitely deserved to be fired, because he could have removed that girl from the classroom in a much less violent way - a pair of handcuffs and a strong grip on her shoulder would have done it.

    1. profile image0
      LoliHeyposted 2 years agoin reply to this

      I think the fact that she was struggling made it harder for him and that is when things got out of control.

  3. Shyron E Shenko profile image80
    Shyron E Shenkoposted 2 years ago

    I think the officer had no right to touch the girl in any way. His reaction was wrong.  It is sad that he was call to the situation, because the teacher had inadequate training on how to handle problem children.

    Why didn't the teacher ask her questions about what was going on in her life, she probably wanted someone to listen to problems and advise her on how to handle them.  No the class room is no place to do that during class. 

    I just think the whole situation could have been handled differently.

    1. profile image0
      LoliHeyposted 2 years agoin reply to this

      The teacher did follow proper protocol.   Student was asked to put cell phone away, refused, and then asked by teacher and principal to leave, and refused.  At that point, officer should be called.  Don't blame teacher.  Kids today have no respect.

  4. aliasis profile image92
    aliasisposted 2 years ago

    Absolutely he deserved to be fired. It was stupid and unnecessarily violent, and more than that, it was an embarrassment.

    Security should have known proper restraints/escort techniques. What's more important yet is not giving an unruly student extra attention - you take care of this quickly and quietly with as little spectacle as possible. Violently wrestling a small girl to the ground? You definitely lost the power struggle. It shouldn't have even gotten to this point in the first place, but a better escort technique would be for two security people to each take one arm. At first, a warning of "Are you going to be able to walk by yourself or will you need to be escorted?" with both security officers there, and if that doesn't work, a safe, painless, quiet and quick escort out of the classroom. But again, this sort of escort should be last case. Better options would be to finish class and make the girl stay behind, possibly with a security officer standing next to her for the remainder (thus, she gets no extra attention and class isn't disrupted), or hell, even have all the other students move to a different classroom or go outside for class.

    Teens are not becoming "more" disrespectful. There is more media attention on their actions, however. What I am amazed by is so much cowing before police brutality and justification of it. No, it didn't matter what the girl was doing. Short of her being violent herself and threatening someone else, which might create a need for quicker action, there was no need for a violent escort. Police brutality is not okay. Police brutality is especially not okay when someone is just sitting there quietly, not harming anyone, and it does not matter how "disrespectful" she was.

    Hopefully this opens a dialogue, and if teachers need better classroom management techniques, extra training for that, and certainly more rules and training in place for these security officers.

    1. profile image0
      LoliHeyposted 2 years agoin reply to this

      Teachers are trained, but parents are not backing them up, and neither is administration.  I can tell you first hand kids today are not receiving consequences for their actions; rather, people just make excuses for them.  Yes, they are worse.