Do you think it is OK to "cuff" an uncontrollable child at school?
As a former teacher, I have seen many young children cuffed and taken away by the police. People do not realize that even very young children can be extremely violent and dangerous. Not all are as innocent as we would like to believe. I have had colleagues bitten, knocked into walls and hit by flying furniture...all because kids were labeled "disabled". Personally, I don't see a problem with this because I have seen what can happen if violent kids aren't restrained. What think you?
My daughter is Autistic but never had to be cuffed. That is because she is classified as a functional Autistic (Asperger's) who may be able to lead a normal life as she approaches adulthood. But there are more severe cases of Autistic children where they may have to be restrained because of being violent, There are even seminars special ed teachers attend that deal with restraining. Maybe somebody who doesn't have an autistic child may think restraining in cruel, The teachers/aids just have to be trained in the proper techniques so the child does not get harmed.
Are you referring to rebellious teens? Here they aren't cuff but sacked from school.
Boy, this is a tough one isn't it? On one hand, you don't want to make it a routine procedure to manhandle kids, but on the other hand, teachers and other students have the right to remain safe in the learning environment.
I think if a child has a habit of becoming violent, they need to be in a school that is designed for them, with people who are properly trained in working with those kids.
If a child is violent and a risk to harming themselves and others around them, restraint is probably the best way to ensure that no one is harmed. My problem would be what leads up to the child reacting violently? Are they being provoked by other kids, is the teacher maybe not knowing how to handle that child? Are the parents not doing their job at home?
So many factors play in and it's one of those grey areas for sure. Is it always appropriate? obviously not. Is it sometimes? Certainly.
Violent and aggressive students should always know where they stand with regards to rules and regulations in a school. Consequences should be made known before lessons begin. There are always exceptions but if guidelines are followed to the letter there should be protocols in place to deal with any incident.
I think that violent children should always be restrained if they are in danger of self harm or of harming others. it's a common sense last resort. But they should know this prior to stepping into a classroom. As should the parents.
I have worked with aggressive students in the past here in the UK, some of them on the autistic spectrum it has to be said, others with learning difficulties.
Preparation and prior knowledge was always a priority. I would read reports and talk one to one with parents and educators, meet with support staff to produce a package of care and strategies - that's before the individual even steps into the classroom.
Knowing the triggers was always key so we could help prevent aggression surfacing but even then some students were unpredictable and caused mayhem from time to time!
I was always keen to tell support staff before class what to do just in case of trouble. I had a set of written guide lines which basically stated that, should Bob Smith kick off suddenly and there was potential harm to others then the class should be evacuated immediately and only myself and one support staff member remain.
If Bob Smith was in danger of self harming then two members of staff would step in to physically restrain him.
There were incidents where we had to do just this but thankfully over 10 years nothing serious ever arose. I never had to use cuffs or ropes or anything like that.
I have no problem with physical restraint of uncontrollable children regardless of their mental capabilities.
I worked with "special" children when I studied psychology and I have seen a "child" pick up a full size student desk and throw it across a room hitting a teacher and knocking her out. I've seen one do serious damage to another child. Teachers and public schools aren't equipped or trained to deal with these things, nor should they be.
America's PC syndrome is a detriment to education. Placing the mentally challenged, or worse, child in with everyone else only slows the path for everyone else. In most cases there is really nothing gained by the "special" child often it is detrimental for everyone concerned save maybe the family that gets a day care service.
Under no circumstances should a known violent child be placed in a regular classroom.
by steve-bc-ca 8 years ago
I was involved in a forum discussing whether teachers should be held accountable for a students success. I started thinking about the possibilities of home schooling, but I don't have any information on the subject and I noticed there were no hubs on the topic. What do you know about it and what is...
by Kathryn L Hill 3 years ago
Its way too fat. The Constitution gives these responsibilities to the Executive Branch:1. Oversee interstate commerce.2. Execute laws passed by Congress.3. Protect us from outside influence and military attack. 4. The president is to act as our Commander in Chief. However, many Federal programs...
by Steven Escareno 15 months ago
According to young turks, a young boy was teased and bullied by a bunch of kids. The child being bullied was autistic, yet the parents of the bullies defended their children's actions saying that the kid deserved it. What are your thoughts on this?By the way, here's a couple of links to...
by Sondra Rochelle 21 months ago
Do you think that very young children (18 months plus) are capable of determining their gender needsRecently there has been much discussion about this issue, with some parents claiming that their very young children are capable of telling them whether they are actually, psychologically, a different...
by Donna Hilbrandt 22 months ago
Should students be allowed to charge their cell phones in school?Yesterday a student asked if she could plug in her phone in my classroom. I said, "no. I am not sure that is the intention of tax payer dollars." She came back with, "my mom pays those taxes. What if I have an...
by SEXYLADYDEE 5 years ago
Is arming teachers in the classroom the answer?How do you feel about teachers (possibly your child's) having a loaded weapon in the classroom? I believe in the right to bear arms. But I want to know that ANYONE buying a weapon has a license & background check including mental instability....
|HubPages Device ID|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Google Analytics|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel|
|Google Hosted Libraries|
|Google AdSense Host API|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels|
|Author Google Analytics|
|Amazon Tracking Pixel|