Church as infalible.
Can a group of people really claim to be infallible?
This comes from the Catholic Catechism which I am studying for the (I really only know more that 6) time:
Although individual members of the Church can err and even make serious mistakes, the Church as a whole can never fall away from God's truth.
Well I am sorry. Yes it can. And if you do not believe me look to the inquisitions and crusades and modern wealth as opposed to saving lives.
Believe me I want a church that gives all and loves in Christ's nature but statements like these made in 2013 are a problem. "the Church never erred"?
Infallibility is specific teaching of the Catholic Church and refers to a limited number of specific teachings in Church Dogma. The Magisterium refers to the singular authority of the Catholic Church responsible for the teachings of the Church. The Catechism is a product of the Magisterium. The Church has been in error and has taught about the errors of various churchmen. It isn't the entire body of the Church that has been in error, but the men who have run it at various times in its history. You would be hard pressed to find anyone in the Catholic Church who would say the Church is perfect, especially the current Pope. After all, the Church is made up of mere humans, it is our nature to be imperfect. All fall short of the glory of God. I commend your studies and am more than willing to discuss any ideas you may have about Catholicism.
Today our lives are filled with phone ques and corporate matters. No one is anyone but a number. Notions of infallibility are best left for dark ages.
I read you loud and clear retief2000 but who accepts responsibility. It is a "never me but....".
I wonder if we have ever really changed, regardless of the trappings of life. Catholic Theology is a pretty interesting area of study if one is so inclined.
when I was charged in early life with lawyer type knowledge of Canons I learned well. When I was charged with later life teaching Catechism I learned that I knew nothing. I am humbled by the teaching and yet required by faith to question for others.
I once heard a priest talking about the nature of doubt and about how essential doubt is in the development of faith. God gave us intellect for a reason.
Retiief 2000 I am not done. Let us keep looking and searching for love.
The Catholics don't believe in church infallibility, but in papal infallibility. This is something the Pope calls on when large issues arise. In fact, the power has only been used twice. First when it claimed that the Assumption of Mary is true. Second, in the declaration of the Immaculate Conception. I myself am not Catholic. I don't believe in papal infallibility, nor in ANY church infallibility. In fact, I believe in church you will find the largest collection of transgressors ever. They go to the church precisely because they want to become better people. They want a change in life as they know it. There are also wiley people who join a church, according to a Pew survey, because church people are the easiest people to swindle.
I am not Catholic but I am catholic and my proposition is directly from catechism which I was charged in teaching as an ordinariate. "Church" infallibility is doctrine. Individuals within the church can fail.
Oh, okay Ericdierker, I stand corrected. Thank you. A little knowledge can be dangerous, so I appreciate your widening my knowledge:)
Most profound, my dear Eric.
Biblical literalists say that the Bible is infallible, but they frequently mean their interpretation of it.
The fundamentalist preacher, Ken Ham once asked a friendly audience, "Who do you believe, science or God?" Of course, the audience answered, "God." But he had loaded the question with a false dichotomy. It's not a choice between science or God, but between science and Ken Ham's interpretation.
God and science get along just fine. Science studies the products of God's creation.
The infallibility of the Bible is not in any one person's fallible interpretation, but in the spirit of its meaning underneath the literal. 2 Corinthians 3:6 warns that we should look to the spirit, instead of the letter, because the letter leads to death and the spirit leads to life.
The problem with The Church and other churches is not with separate or collective infallibility, but with ego which makes all things fallible. The Church turned to Ego as its master under Constantine and solidified that turning away under Justinian.
Ego is the heart of evil. Ego is the blindfold we took up when we ate the forbidden fruit so long ago. The Bible tells us many things, but people do not see. The Bible tells us that only the guilty pay for their own crimes (Ezekiel 18:18–20). Yet, we are taught that we are shackled with the sins of Adam and Eve. There is a way to resolve this, but it invokes our own immortality as children of the Most High.
God created a Rescue Mission and it has been ongoing for hundreds of thousands of years. That mission is coming to its end. My new book discusses these things, focusing on God's reason for Noah's Flood, but that reason is just as applicable today as it was then. The Flood was an act of love—only that and nothing more.
Only the Holy Spirit is infallible and the spirit is pure love when it is awake. The Church has done so much that is not love, it has shown its "bad fruit." The Church and all denominations are corrupt. They are based on ego—the need to be "first." Claims of infallibility are ego speaking.
Love is quite okay being last. If I were pope, I would sell it all and have all priests walk the streets witnessing for Christ. I would use the proceeds of selling all the Church's holdings to feed and clothe the poor, done as anonymously as possible. Then, I would encourage everyone else to do the same.
Love is all that matters.
by Gous Ahmed7 years ago
What is the role of the pope and how is he seen in terms of holiness and closeness to Jesus or God?
by Steven Escareno3 years ago
I was watching a CNN report on youtube that showed some priest exorcising a demon through skype, and I just had to ask...is that even possible? Forget about debating whether or not demons exist for a moment, but...
by Claire Evans3 years ago
On various occasions I have been attacked because of my condemnation of the Vatican even by non believers! It is more severe than any other topic I bring up. Why is it so hard to accept that evil has...
by Greatest I am5 years ago
Women. God’s afterthought and man’s curse to rule.I think it quite ironic that God, who tells us to reproduce as his first commandment to man in Genesis 1, does not give us something to reproduce with till Genesis...
by boyatdelhi4 years ago
Is Roman Catholic church truly follow the bible?Where it diverted from the bible?
by Justin Earick4 years ago
Sodom wasn't smited for homosexuality (false-idol worship, poor treatment of strangers and the poor, gang rape). Leviticus doesn't matter (old covenant, pork, lobster, tattoos, mixed fibers, period sex,...
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.