Many churches have Psychologist and or Psychiatrists on staff Is this accceptable to scripture?
Many modern churches have psychological counsellors, Psychologist or Psychiatrists on staff , call or referral. Does scrpture cindone this practice?
To my knowledge, scripture does not condone the use of Psychiatrists. In fact, I believe it goes against the Word of God. Jesus never tried to counsel a devil out of a person.
I will also add, God will give people what they ask for, if they are persistent in asking, whether good for them or bad. Israel wanted a king and God gave them one. Saul ended up causing a lot of heartache to the Israelites.
Great answer. Yes Jesus said we are to crucify our flesh (psyche), not understand it
Collasians 4:14 is very troubling then as psychiatrists are physicians of the flesh (psyche)
Thank you Eric for bringing that to my attention. The psyche has to do with the mind of a man. They call Psychiatrists doctors, but a physician is a doctor of fleshly diseases. They treat the body, not the mind.
Eric -only to those who do not know how to interpret scripture. Flesh is talking about the natural carnal man, the essence of the man, not the meat on the body. Crucify the natual man feed the spiritual one
Luke was certainly a physician and a dearly loved one at that. Truly he was a member of the church.
Eric - yes he was a brother, and loved. That is the measure not his occupation. WHAT CHURCH? BY BEING A BROTHER HE BECOMES THE CHURCH (Part of Christ's body) do you think they had a building like the modern apostates that they call the church?
Off topic already? No one is denying that Luke was a physician or a brother in Christ. The question was about psychiatrists being used in the Church to counsel. Psychiatrists are taught according to the ways of the world, not God.
Celafoe -- Psychiatrists are physicians and have worked for years with the church. Luke was the physician to Paul as he makes clear "our beloved". Guidance counselors are different as are psychologists. Ministering to the sick is a worthy calling.
Eric -are you aware that psychology was not everecognized until mid 20th century. I know, after several years of debating you that you have a mixture you believe, but it is just not scriptural and i am concerned for the young that you say you teach
That is just a slam against me. It is insulting.
Sorry eric it is not intended as a slam but as a wake up call. 2John 10-11,
Look at some of the thing you have said, eastern religion material, etc. Christianity demands a correct use of the gospel ONLY.... I care but the word is #1 not feelingss
celfoe is your interpretation of the Bible infallible?
Eric infallible NO Correct on what parts I teach YES
I am always open to correction by scripture properly used IN CONTEXT but never by any other means
1I have told you before We live in THE NEW TESTAMENT NOT THE OLD.2. Most of your scriptures have NO place in this discussion as they are not relevant at all. 3.You cannot use the OT to outline the new things so I will not address them again. Insults
The reason the modern churches have them on staff is that they are specially qualified to concoct the opiate for the masses. The more they are allowed to gloss the eyes of the people, the more money will fall into the offering plates. These are among the clergy class who are hired by the church elite to control their minions.
Those in the church system claim to follow Scripture, but in their actions defy it. Psychologists and Psychiatrists are trained in the secular practices of the world and will use their secular psycho therapies and pop psychology on their own church members for a fee.
There are no hirelings in the body of Christ, just servants.
The bible says - We are ALL to be counselors for one another and especially to counsel those in prison. And yes, I do believe that having a professional that has studied in a university is acceptable for counseling individuals seeking guidance for enlightenment. . Lets be very simple here and use an analogy - of a "fork" for example. An individual can see this is a fork, yet if they are not counseled "give enlightenment" - they may not know what is is used for - it is simply a fork. One must learn it is used to place food upon and then moved to your mouth to eat! Professional have the ability to aid those who are lost - not to say others can not- but with serious issues - they can offer "tools" to help the lost...Do I think they should be on a pay roll...no- pro bono is the way!
Will you please post the scripture you have stated here. I would like to read the book, chapter and verse you describe. ...(As a minister (are we not counselors as well?and a psych major (masters degree - Thanks Respectfully Eddy Von
check my hub -- http://celafoe.hubpages.com/hub/The-Tru … the-Church NO minister led by the Holy Spirit would use psychology, but those that serve the churches of men , instead of Christ do, churchian hirelings, not CHrist led.
I've searched NASB, NKJV, NIV for "we are ALL to be counselors" and can't find it. The part about being professionally trained by man I know isn't there, but not sure about all are counselors. A little help please?
By insolence comes nothing but strife, but with those who take advice is wisdom.
Without counsel plans fail, but with many advisers they succeed.
When the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all t
eddy- the scripture ( jn 16:3 from the NT ) you use shows that the only wise council is from the Holy Spirit, The OT scriptures were from before the Holy Spirit was sent to lead us into all truth. in OT men were
between man and God, not in NT
Proverbs 20:5 -Proverbs 12:18 - 2 Timothy 3:16-17 -Galatians 6:2 -2 Corinthians 1:2-3- 2 Corinthians 9-17 - Proverbs 27:9 - 2 Samuel 20:18 -Colossians 1:28 -2 Timothy 2:15 -Amos 3:7 -Proverbs 12:15 -Matthew 23:34- Jeremiah 1:5 -Job 33:23 -Psalm 79:11
rich- it is not in scripture, another lie of the churches of men, NT we are to seek the holy Spirit for answers, not men
I realize the mistake I made asking for scripture. People that minister to the flesh have a mill stone with their name on it waiting.
Eric, I must agree - insulting is an understatement by this author. I posted many scriptures to the author- who has the option to post. this is not done, but rather the comments I received were considered "non - relevant". I will post in next comment
eddie-- you did what all hireling pastors do, gave me a bunch of scriptures , none of them supporting your position. If you are going to call me names then at least be man enough to be truthful. I am not responsible for your lack of understand.
Celafoe, I have told the truth- the comments I made were copied and pasted from your writings to me. Post the entire conversation, so as the Truth will be seen. I am done with this conversation, and by the way - I am a woman...May God bless you
by charlie 4 years ago
Scripture says wives are to submit to their own husbands. Why do most churches not teach this?Scripture says that Christ is head of the church and that the husband is head of the wife in like manner. Why do the majority of churches and those professing Christianity not...
by charlie 6 years ago
Why do the Churches talk about "good friday" when it was a horrible dayI know Jesus was killed on wednesday not friday but since the churches teach friday and they call it "good" friday, how can anyone say it was good when it was one of the most horrible days in...
by Ann810 4 years ago
Why do Psychologist diagnose Christians as being Schizophrenic when they go to counseling?Is it an attach on Christianity?
by r-o-y 8 years ago
God said the of today church is lukewarm and not hot or cold, and that this church is the worst in the history of the church. What is it about this church age would up-set God's stomach so bad?
by Jewels 10 years ago
Can anyone answer why it would not be more appropriate for Christians/Christian Fundamentalists to have their own virtual church? Wouldn't that solve the problem of being scorned in the name of their religion? Wouldn't that satisfy the hunger of Scripture readers to have their message...
by Eric Dierker 4 years ago
Is a person who preaches and insists that his way is right any different than a preacher in a churchThere are those who demand that they have Holy Spirit divine guidance. Yet they "hate" churches. The elephant in the room is that they do the exact same thing. Holding court and demanding...
Copyright © 2021 HubPages Inc. and respective owners. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc. HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.
HubPages Inc, a part of Maven Inc.
|HubPages Device ID||This is used to identify particular browsers or devices when the access the service, and is used for security reasons.|
|Login||This is necessary to sign in to the HubPages Service.|
|HubPages Traffic Pixel||This is used to collect data on traffic to articles and other pages on our site. Unless you are signed in to a HubPages account, all personally identifiable information is anonymized.|
|Remarketing Pixels||We may use remarketing pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to advertise the HubPages Service to people that have visited our sites.|
|Conversion Tracking Pixels||We may use conversion tracking pixels from advertising networks such as Google AdWords, Bing Ads, and Facebook in order to identify when an advertisement has successfully resulted in the desired action, such as signing up for the HubPages Service or publishing an article on the HubPages Service.|