You have Adrian Peterson of the Minnesota Vikings coming back from a knee injury just a year ago to all of a sudden coming 9 yards short of breaking the record that is still held by Eric Dickerson, You have Peyton Manning of the Denver Broncos who had multiple neck procedures and questions of whether or not he would play again, and you have Thomas Davis of the Carolina Panthers who tore the same ACL in his right knee 3 straight years in a row from 2009 to 2011 (That's right the same ACL in his right knee, Thomas Davis tore it 3 straight years in a row) and was able to play in all but 1 game in 2012. If there was a player that you know that deserves comeback player of the year, who would it be to you?
I am a born and raised Coloradan/Bronco fan; but the things that Adrian Peterson did all season were truly remarkable. He lead the Vikings to the postseason while having only 850 yards less than his starting quarterback in a very pass happy NFL. We watched AP come back to full performance level week one, just 9 and a half months after shredding his knee. #AP2097.
It's a tough one between Adrian Peterson and Peyton Manning. Adrian Peterson had a knee injury and Peyton Manning had neck surgery and was out for an entire season. It's impressive that Manning has led the Broncos to an AFC West Title, plus a first round bye after his surgery. Adrian Peterson on the other hand has been a beast all season (and I'm a Packers fan). I think it's more difficult to rush for over 2,000 yards then it is to throw for 4,000. I'd have to go AP.
I am not a big Bronco fan but you have to give Manning some respect. I guess the thing that stands out to me is the fact that not only did he return from his injury, but he changed teams as well. I have seen plenty of times when a star player changes teams and for whatever reason does not enjoy success with the new team. To me, that puts Manning over the top, not only coming back from an injury but also changing teams in the process. Impressive.
I have to agree with atechwiz, Manning came back from a neck injury, changed teams, had to learn a completely new offense, new team mates, coachs etc, and still simply dominated. Peterson has been impressive as well, but I would give the nod to Manning.
by alexandriaruthk5 years ago
Comeback Player of the Year - 2012 NFL? Thoughts?Peyton Manning, Adrian Peterson and Jamaal Charles who else? Peyton can be MVP too, just saying.
by alexandriaruthk5 years ago
Who is going to be the 2012-2013 NFL MVP Player of the Year ?Brady, Manning who else? Any thoughts about this?
by CJ Kelly3 years ago
Should Ray Rice and Adrian Peterson be reinstated to the NFL?Raven RB Ray Rice lost his appeal of his suspension which had been levied based on his domestic violence incident with his wife. Adrian Peterson was...
by Julio E Olmo Sr5 years ago
Should the Minnesotta Vikings trade Running Back Adrian Peterson?To which Team?
by EJ Lambert4 years ago
What is the greatest comeback you have ever seen?The word "comeback" gets tossed around most often in pro sports. However, it is a word that applies to all walks of life. Robert Downey Jr. and...
by Kevin W5 years ago
Do you think the Broncos comeback against the Chargers was one of the greatest of all times?
Copyright © 2018 HubPages Inc. and respective owners.
Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners.
HubPages® is a registered Service Mark of HubPages, Inc.
HubPages and Hubbers (authors) may earn revenue on this page based on affiliate relationships and advertisements with partners including Amazon, Google, and others.